Shattered Hearts: A Moment of Truth Movie (TV Movie 1998) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
From a prolific novelist of teen books
blanche-231 August 2005
Even though this apparently is not a movie produced by Lifetime, "A Champion's Fight" has Lifetime written all over it. It's based on a Lurlene McDaniel story of two teenagers in love, but the young man has cancer. McDaniel has written many novels for teens, often with a spiritual theme.

I can really see this film appealing to a young crowd, as it was intended. It's very sports-oriented - the boy, Luke, is the star quarterback at the high school. Beth Broderick plays the girl's mom, and she's always good, conveying an attorney's sophistication and later, compassion and support. Adrienne Barbeau is Luke's mom.

The story is poignant and also predictable. There really isn't anything exceptional about it, except Barbeau's problems with her employer.

Given all that, I cried like a baby and hated myself.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Pretty good movie with a very good cast
evergreen_1226 May 2002
Warning: Spoilers
***warning - spoilers*** It's to bad that this movie is so predictable because it has alot of good things except for that. The cast it great, especially Beth Broderick (Patricia Ellis), Adrienne Barbeau (Nancy) and Scott Vickaryous (Luke). Beth Broderick plays Patricia. She is a lawyer and the mother to Julie (Katie Gratson), who's boyfriend Luke has cancer. At first Broderick's character seem to be really harch and a little unfair and only seem to care about that her daughter get into a nice college but after a while we'll see that she is really a strong and caring person that has to fight both for her daughter and for Luke's mother Nancy. This movie is also sad and the last scene between Patricia and Julie is very touching. It's one of my favourite scenes and the one where Patricia tells Julie that even though she miss Luke she need to get on with her life and be strong. I also liked the scene when Patricia went to Nancy's boss and demended that Nancy would get her job back. I liked the strenght that she was showing and that she really fought for what was right. Anyway, as I said, there is to bad that the movie is so predictable. Since

Luke survives the cancer early in the movie, we understand that the cancer will come back later on, and that he then probably won't win over the cancer again. Except for that, I really liked this movie.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Heart touching....
teddygirl-227 June 2004
This movie was extremely heart touching & you will need a box of tissues to watch it. I myself lost my father almost a year ago to cancer & it really touched my heart in so many ways with the story line & the emotions everyone felt. I was blessed with the special gift of being with my daddy when he died & sadly it was in my arms that he did. I would highly recommend this movie to everyone just to let them know that if they have experienced this situation, that they are not alone & it is okay to feel these emotions & thoughts. It brought back a lot of feelings & emotions for myself & can very well understand the heartache & feeling of emptiness it leaves you. Take a moment after watching the movie to feel grateful for what you have in life & remember it can happen to you or someone you know. Take into consideration that life is short & enjoy it day by day. If you happen to know someone who is terminally ill with this or any other kind of disease, make time for them & offer your support along with your sympathy & they will accept it with open arms. You will be surprised on how they respond.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great movie
angelove12 December 1998
When I saw that a made for TV movie was on I decided to tape it. Little did I know that this movie would mean so much to me and make me think so much about my life and how precious it is. It was a fantastic movie and taught me a lot about courage and how to deal with tough situations. I loved it!
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
If you liked the movie, you'll LOVE the book
emjor20019 February 2008
I thought this movie was really good for a made-for-TV special. Some of the acting came off a little cheesy, but I think that's to be expected.

It seems that there are a lot of movies out there, mostly movies made for television, that try and deal with young love and some sort of tragedy. It's become so common that they often don't touch our hearts anymore, because they just follow a formulaic pattern. Let me assure you that this is NOT the case with this movie.

The movie is based on Lurlene McDaniel's book, Don't Die, My Love, and I had to take off one star for the sheer fact that the movie doesn't do the book justice. There were some key scenes that I really think should have been included in the film, especially the final part of the book, which is probably the most touching thing I have ever read (but I won't spoil it!). So, all in all, this is a significantly above par movie, but if you liked it, you HAVE to read the book!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very inspiring movie.
Ashbug4826 December 2003
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILER I have to say this movie inspired me so much. Although in the end Luke does die of complications due to his battle with cancer this movies showed me so much. It showed me that love can with stand hard times and that love is what keeps you happy when things aren't so good. It let me believe that there are some high school relationships out there that are alot more than just about sex, that you can have a very loving and complete relationship at such a vulnerable time in your life. It also showed me through Luke's struggle with the cancer that grew as a person and although he got angry at times he knew he did nothing wrong to get this cancer and God wasn't punishing him. This movie shows how two families and friends at school feel when someone they love is hurting, its shows how people come together in times of need. I would recommend this movie to anyone, especially those dealing with similar situations. I know this movie has opened my eyes to see things not for what I expect them to be but for what they really are meant to be, Luke and Julie's relationship had the kind of love you only feel once in an entire lifetime, it proved that although you loose that love it may hurt its okay to move on.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Movie Beautiful Actors
bjsebring5 February 2006
Movie was a sad but great story of its time for Lifetime. The players in the movie contributed well with their abilities. The ending was sad but the sadness was near the ending with a life honoring moment. I enjoyed it even 8+ years after production. It is my wish that everyone who has not as of yet seen this movie try ti make time to see it. I truly believe it will not be a waste of time.

Genna said it all in her short description:

Julie Ellis and Luke Muldenhower are high schoolers in love. They're lives are going great! Luke is going to get a scholar for football and Julie is an honors student. Suddenly, they're perfect world comes Based on the book "Don't Die, My Love" By Lurlene McDaniel. Summary written by Genna Reeves {g_reeves02@YAHOO.COM}
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Do you think that when you die young you'll stay young forever?
sol-kay26 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
(There are Spoilers) Powerful made for TV movie, one of the best ever, about facing the realities of dying at a very young age with everything and every dream you looked forward to dying along with you.

17 year-old Luke Muldenhower, Scott Vckaryous, had everything to look forward to in life. A sweet and caring girlfriend Juile Ellis, Katie Gratson,a football scholarship at the state collage and most off all a long life ahead of him. This all came crashing down on Luke when after suffering a number of fainting spells he's diagnosed with having Hodgkin's Lymphoma; cancer of the lymph nodes.

Put under chemotherapy for some six weeks Luke at first seems to have recovered with his cancer that is reported by his physician Dr. Sanchez, Teryl Rothery,in full remission. It's only later where the deadly disease reappears with a fury, creating a deadly tumor in Luke's chest, that all bets are off in his recovery. For a while everything couldn't have been better for Luke with him now back in school and on the football team as well as back with his girl Julie and planning their future as a married couple. That was all shattered in the blink of an eye and the click of an x-ray machine that showed Luke was now in danger of dying if he didn't get a bone morrow donor and fast before the cancer in his lymph nodes overwhelmed him.

Intelligent touching and realistic drama of what it is to face the death of a loved one who's life is slowly, and painfully, being taken away from him. Luke who at first was inseparable form his beloved Julie Ellis soon realized that her caring or, as Luke put it, feeling sorry for him was the worst thing that Julie could do. Trying to get Julie to realize the truth, that he's doomed to die, has her almost suffer a complete emotional breakdown. It's later that Luke realizes that his treatment of Julie would only hurt not help her in the matter of his eventual death that Luke lets his feeling for her, far more then himself, come out. This made the ending of the film, despite how depressing it was, a lot easier to take for not only Julie but Luke's widowed mom, Adrenne Barbeau, as well as Julie's parents and all his friends in and out of Vincent Collins High School.

The movie "A Champion's Fight" or "Shattered Hearts" didn't linger on about what Luke as well as his friends and family went through his, as well as their, ordeal. We see Luke going through the painful stages of cancer treatment and how his courageous response to them not only strengthened him but those around Luke who were pulling for him to survive.

It was a double tragedy for Julie, as well as Luke's mom Mrs. Muldenhower, in what they went trough sacrificing their job, in Mrs. Muldenhowers case, and collage career, on Julie's part, in standing by Luke when it was obvious and a forgone conclusion that he wouldn't pull through. This despite all the state of the art cancer treatment, through Luke's mom's medical insurance, he was getting. ****SPOILER**** It later came out that Luke had indeed a bone marrow donor before he was put under chemotherapy only to reject it and hope that the therapy would be successful before he's treated with it. Luke sadly never recovered despite all the top notch treatment he was getting and died before the bone marrow, which was already available for Luke, could possibly save him.

In the end Julie was not left alone as she thought that she would be in losing Luke but became a far better person in having both known and loved him. Not wanting to continue with her life with Luke no longer around Julie finally saw what Luke meant in wanting her to free herself from him. It wasn't that Luke, knowing that he doesn't have long to go, didn't love Julie he in fact love her even more. All Luke wanted was for Julie to go on with her life and not ruin it, as well as any new love that came into her life, by being fixated on him even after he was no longer around.

It was that lesson that not only Luke but Julie's mom Mrs. Patricia Ellis, Beth Broaderick, thought her that got Juile through the pain and suffering over Luke's death. That very important lesson also made a better stronger, in her being able to face the future, and loving person out of Julie as well.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Typical Lifetime
CranberriAppl9 June 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I've been watching Lifetime movies a very long time. Started back in college on rainy days when it was too nasty to be outside. Could always count on LT for constant movies to help pass the time. Well, I'm out of college now, but sometimes I'll find a LT movie that looks interesting. Sorry, but this wasn't it for me. The messageboard is glowing for it, but I just cannot. It's OK, but it's got the LT cheesiness (subject matter not withstanding) and that makes it a little hard to get through.

Before anyone thinks I'm some cold-hearted person, I do enjoy A Walk to Remember, Love Story, Brian's Song (which is a TV movie like this one), Dad, and many other stories dealing with death. Also, "Now That Andi's Gone" was one of my favorite books as a teen.

I just didn't really find myself very interested in this story once I started watching.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed