36 user 11 critic

Car 54, Where Are You? (1994)

PG-13 | | Comedy | 28 January 1994 (USA)
Brash NYC policeman Officer Gunther Toody is partnered with stiff, by-the-book Officer Francis Muldoon to protect an important mafia witness prior to testifying against orgainzed crime in ... See full summary »


Bill Fishman


Nat Hiken (television series), Erik Tarloff (story) | 4 more credits »
2 wins & 2 nominations. See more awards »




Cast overview, first billed only:
David Johansen ... Officer Gunther Toody
John C. McGinley ... Officer Francis Muldoon
Fran Drescher ... Velma Velour
Nipsey Russell ... Police Capt. Dave Anderson
Rosie O'Donnell ... Lucille Toody
Daniel Baldwin ... Don Motti
Jeremy Piven ... Herbert Hortz
Bobby Collins Bobby Collins ... Carlo (as Bobby C. Collins)
Louis Di Bianco ... Nicco
Al Lewis ... Leo Schnauzer
Barbara Hamilton Barbara Hamilton ... Mrs. Muldoon
Eliza Roberts ... Boys in Blue Director (as Eliza Garrett)
Rik Colitti Rik Colitti ... Sgt. Abrams
Penn Jillette ... Luther (as Penn)
Teller ... Luther (as Teller)


Brash NYC policeman Officer Gunther Toody is partnered with stiff, by-the-book Officer Francis Muldoon to protect an important mafia witness prior to testifying against orgainzed crime in Brooklyn, all the while dealing with their personal lives, overbearing spouses, common criminals, arms dealers, and their officious boss Captain Anderson. Written by Anonymous

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis




PG-13 | See all certifications »

Did You Know?


Director Bill Fishman was unaware that the movie had been released until he was forwarded a check for post-release royalties by his agent. Fishman was also not informed of the extensive re-edits that the movie had been put through, and said that had he known how different the end product would be from what he filmed, he would have asked to be credited as Alan Smithee. See more »


During the opening credits, when Toody and Schnauser are in the car reading, Toody steers left before hitting the dirt ramp, but the ramp is on the right side of the road. See more »


Officer Gunther Toody: Luthers, this is my new partner Francis Muldoon, the pride of the 53rd.
Luther #1: Hello, Muldoon. We're Luther. How are you doing. What are you packing?
Officer Francis Muldoon: I'm packing a 9mm Beretta in my shoulder holster and a Walther PPK in my back pocket.
Luther #1: You know what you need? A nice little crotch derringer. All it does is...
[Luther 1 pulls it out, and Muldoon goes for his gun]
Officer Gunther Toody: No, no, no! It's all right!
Luther #1: [to Muldoon] Keep it in your pants. What? Little more sneaky? Look at this. All you gotta do is, now listen carefully. ...
See more »


Afternoon Delight
Written by Bill Danoff
Performed by Starland Vocal Band
See more »

User Reviews

Very likely the worst film I've ever seen
10 March 2006 | by QanqorSee all my reviews

I've sat through some dreadful films in my time, but this one may well be the all-time winner. I watched the whole thing with my mouth hanging open in stunned disbelief that it could be as bad as it was.

I was extremely interested in seeing the film around the time it came out. This was back when Nick@Nite was showing reruns of the old Car 54 TV show, and I was one of the many who was first exposed to it there and fell in love with it. My understanding was that it was this renaissance of cult interest in the show that motivated the making of a movie. So I was looking forward to seeing said movie.

The thing about this movie was, it seemed extremely evident that NOBODY associated with the making of this movie HAD EVER actually *seen* the original TV show upon which it is (supposedly) based. That the main characters are named Toody and Mulldoon seems almost a coincidence; they aren't even *remotely* like the original characters, except in so far as being cops. The original Car 54 TV show had a delightful, wacky sense of humor. This abomination of a film has NO sense of humor. I didn't not laugh once, not one single time. The original TV show had an amusing, catchy theme song. This thing had some monstrosity of a rap. What I will never, ever fathom is how *anybody* ever signed off on this thing at any stage in its development. I want to know who looked at the script for this and say "Yeah! That's great!" and what drugs they were on.

I remain in everlasting awe that they were able to propose, write, film, edit, and release a Car 54 film that had absolutely NOTHING to do with the great old TV show, Car 54, Where Are You. When you factor in the disappointment factor over what it could have been, I think this could well be the worst ever. There was just *no good reason* for it to have been this bad.

35 of 40 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 36 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.






Release Date:

28 January 1994 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

Car 54, Where Are You? See more »


Box Office


$10,700,000 (estimated)

Opening Weekend USA:

$791,182, 30 January 1994

Gross USA:


Cumulative Worldwide Gross:

See more on IMDbPro »

Company Credits

Production Co:

Orion Pictures See more »
Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:




Aspect Ratio:

1.85 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Recently Viewed