Body Puzzle (1992) User Reviews

good style, but the story is puzzling

[movieman_kev · 5/10 · 13 July 2009]

Police officer Michael (Tomas Arana, "The Church") has his hands full while investigating a serial killer who's been leaving parts of the bodies of the people that he's been murdering at the house of one recently widowed, Tracy (Joanna Pacula). Mike has to find a way to stop the bodies from piling up, while perhaps finding love in the process.

A feeling of the 'giallo' films of yore pervades this film, even though we know who the killer is from the get-go, and the film contains a few good set-pieces (a scene later in the film set in a school for the blind being particularly memorable), but it doesn't make all that much sense when all is said and done either. All in all, not nearly as good as Bava's earlier "Macabre" nor his first two "Demons" films, but enjoyable enough if you can forgive the rather outrageous plot twists towards the end of the film. A pity the Image Entertainment DVD lacked extras of any kind, as I would have been interested in some.

My Grade: C-

The Bone Collector.

[morrison-dylan-fan · 6/10 · 11 October 2011]

After being left disappointing,and then being left completely gripped with Bava's first and second films,I decided to watch his last ever "Giallo" with above average expectations of it leaning more on the great A Blade In The Dark side,and less on the muddling Macabre.

The plot:

Heading to lay flowers by her husbands grave,Tracy is stopped in her tracks by police,who tell her that she cant lay the flowers by her husband,due to a grave robber having tampered with her husbands corpse during the night.Shortly after the grave robbery,murders start increasing rapidly around the city.Investigating the case,Police Detecive Michele notices that the serial killers "signature" seems to be getting hold of peoples recently transplanted organs.Suspecting that time is not on his side,Michele does everything he can,to stop the killer in time,before he gets the final piece of his own puzzle..

View on the film:

For his directing,Lamberto scales back the Giallo/Slasher mash- up,which had made A Blade In the Dark so enjoyable,and instead goes for a very near-middle of the road style of directing,with the main stylish moments being the use of a freezer (a call back to his first film,Macabre),some good tracking shots which show the characters in a jig saw puzzle way,and the stand out swimming pool and class room murder scenes,which allows Bava to at last show what he could have done for the whole film.Due to the plot of the film being a great opportunity for a fast moving Giallo-horror,the screenwriters instead decide to make the film into a Giallo drama!,and although the script does contain a nice twist,the rest of the screenplay just feels like it is on auto- pilot,with there being nothing particularly bad with the film,but there also being nothing particularly great,to turn the film into a must see Giallo.

Final view on the film:

A pleasant enough Giallo dram,which is just about saved from being middle of the road,by the stylish "horror" moments from Bava.

An example of the Giallo genre dying out

[acidburn-10 · 4/10 · 9 May 2021]

I recently came across this movie after seeing a review for it on a certain Horror website (who gave it a positive review) & after finding out that Lamberto Bava directed it, I instantly thought to seek it out after enjoying some of his other movies such as 'Demons' & 'Rabid Dogs' & well I was disappointed by this rather lacklustre effort.

The plot follows a detective on a trail of a serial killer who leaves his victims body parts in a young widow's home, all of which seems to be connected to her late husband's death.

Initially this title sounded a little bit highbrow & yeah, I'd say it is, but that doesn't make it better, despite a promising premise. There's no mystery as to who the killer is as its revealed right from the start, but you don't know why & that could have made for an interesting set up. But as the movie goes on it all becomes muddled with a very unsatisfying twist, that not only comes across as ridiculous, but makes the detective incredibly stupid.

However, there were some cool scenes & some well-maintained tension, but overall, there was a lack of flourish and comes off as very generic with a lack of interesting cinematography, tones & lack of style, coming across as very on the nose. The performances were also very stilted & stuff, despite both actors giving far better performances in other projects.

Overall 'Body Puzzle' isn't one of the better Giallo movies & you can see why this genre died out as by the 90's, the genre clearly run out of gas.

The Idiot Plot strikes again!

[nemkutya · 5 August 2000]

James Blish's definition of the Idiot Plot is familiar to Bad Movie fans: it's the sort of plot that would be dealt with in seconds by normal people, which only works in the movies if everybody in the cast is an idiot. Body Puzzle is a classic example of the device.

None of the "professional people" in the movie behave as though they knew anything about their jobs. The policemen do things that would have them booted off the force. There's a female psychiatrist who makes snap judgments on patients she's only seen for a few minutes, and shares these judgments with the police as though there was no such thing as doctor-patient confidentiality. There's a medical examiner who makes pronouncements on the times of death that don't fit even remotely with the timeline of the movie (a lot of this is Bava's and the editor's fault, though). We have a lifeguard (it seems to me he's performing his duties a very short time after a kidney replacement, but I don't know about such things) who gets killed in broad daylight in a swimming pool -- but nobody notices! And there are no traces of blood in the water, even though the victim has been dismembered.

Then there's the final twist. It's a twist so jaw-droppingly stupid that I would never dream of giving it away.

I will give one bit away, though, to give a further example of how awful the movie is: the hero comes across a freezer chest. Suspense builds as he opens the chest, to find... frozen pasta! Ahh, but underneath the pasta he finds the frozen corpse we've been expecting. Now, at this point, we're expecting the killer to sneak up behind him and surprise him. Everything points to this happening: the camera angles, the music, the rules of bad movie making... so what happens? The killer jumps OUT OF THE FREEZER CHEST! He was hiding UNDER THE BODY, UNDER THE PASTA!! First, how did he get there without assistance, covering himself up with frozen stuff and then closing the lid; second, why didn't he freeze to death, trapped under all that ice; and third, how did he know the hero would stop by and open the freezer?

The mind boggles.

Giallo ala Lamberto

[BandSAboutMovies · 4/10 · 16 February 2020]

At least this Lamberto Bava film has a unique premise: A detective discovers that a serial killer's murders are all connected by the late husband of a beautiful widow. After all, his organs have been transplanted into each dead body!

That said - there is a great scene where the killer eviscerates a schoolteacher victim in front of her class of blind students, spraying one of them with plasma. If only the rest of the film lived up to its premise like this scene!

That said, there are plenty of Italian exploitation faves in this one.

Polish actress Joanna Pacula was in Virus with Jamie Lee Curtis (it's an early comic book film, based on a Dark Horse comic) and Gorky Park. She plays the lead, Tracy and in real life, once dated Roman Polanski.

Tomas Arana - who is on The New Pope these days - is better known to our readers for appearing in The Church, He and Pacula were also in Tombstone together.

Look out! There's Gianni Garko, who is beloved here for his work in movies like Devilfish, The Psychic, four of the five legit Sartana films (If You Meet Sartana...Pray for Your Death; I Am Sartana, Your Angel of Death; Have a Good Funeral, My Friend...Sartana Will Pay and Light the Fuse...Sartana Is Coming), Encounters In the Deep and Star Odyssey. There's Erika Blanc (Kill, Baby... Kill!, The George Hilton-starring Sartana's Here...Trade Your Pistol for a Coffin, The Night Evelyn Came Out of Her Grave, A Dragonfly for Each Corpse)! And Giovanni Lombardo Radice, always a great scumbag in movies like The House on the Edge of the Park and its sequel where he was the main focus, Stagefright, Bob the literal pervert in City of the Living Dead, Cannibal Ferox and Phantom of Death.

Jasmine Maimone, who was in Demons, Demons 6: De Profundis and Paganini Horror was the original choice for the lead, but she retired before this bloody mess could be made.

Several puzzle-pieces missing in the script, but still a FUN 90's giallo!

[Coventry · 7/10 · 17 November 2006]

There once was an era, approximately from the late 60's up until the early 80's, during which nearly every Italian director delivered his own personal giallo-movie and they featured the craziest plots and the most far-fetched red herrings. What great times they were! After this, however, the magnificent sub genre almost got extinct and there were only TWO directors that regularly attempted to breathe new life into the formula of mad black-gloved killers and sleaze-laden twists. Dario Argento is the king even to this day and the other one is Lamberto Bava, who was responsible for some truly underrated giallo-efforts like "Delirium: Photos of Gioia" and "You'll Die at Midnight". "Body Puzzle" is yet another criminally neglected film that features all the giallo's extraordinary trademarks, although that sadly also includes the major holes in the plot. "Body Puzzle" serves the absolute most implausible story I've ever beheld, but there are plenty of sadistic & gore-soaked murders on display and the absurd screenplay hints at some controversial topics like hidden homosexuality and schizophrenia. Lamberto Bava doesn't really bother to keep the killer's identity secret, as we immediately witness how a handsome young man brutally stabs an anonymous candy store owner to death. Several more grisly murders are committed before police inspector Michael discovers that the victims have one thing in common. They all received donor organs from a pianist who died in a motorcycle accident and the mysterious killer tries to puzzle him back together. The inspect is much quicker when it comes to falling in love with the deceased pianist's wife, played by Joanna Pacula. "Body Puzzle" completely stops to make sense halfway, but you've got to love Bava's enthusiast direction and his desperate efforts to maintain the suspense. The music and camera-work are more than adequate while the cast features some familiar faces. Giovanni Lombardo Radice briefly appears as the exaggeratedly gay acquaintance of both the killer and the dead pianist. Italian horror fans will certainly recognize him as the poor sucker who always dies sensationally ("Cannibal Ferox", "City of the Living Dead", "Cannibal Apocalypse"…).

S10 Reviews: Body Puzzle (1991)

[suspiria10 · 7/10 · 30 April 2006]

A cop is investigating a weird series of murders that don't add up. Parts are being removed like trophies but not the same part. He races against the clock to save the next possible victim and solve the body puzzle.

'Body Puzzle' isn't a great movie by any stretch of the imagination but I didn't find it as bad as many reviewers suggest. It's not all that flashy as a Giallo or as well thought out but the acting isn't too horrid and the direction kept me zoned in. The plot is a bit far fetched but hey it's a slasher! What can you do? I give it a 3 of 5 for keeping me entertained and an interesting character or two.

a grisly tale with more than a few twists and killings

[christopher-underwood · 7/10 · 15 May 2006]

Very decent horror/thriller, not quite falling into the 'giallo' category as few of the classic ingredients are present, except perhaps plot holes and inefficient policemen, but let us not be churlish. This is a grisly tale with more than a few twists and killings. It is more what happens after the kills that is particularly grisly and then we have various bits being sent to the leading lady. Joanna Pacula plays throughout the movie a heroine in peril and pretty well too. Stylishinteriors at the start remind one of A Blade In The Dark and whilst this is not as consistent as that film it is nonetheless a decent ride.

Bava Jr surpasses himself.

[ulicknormanowen · 8/10 · 21 February 2023]

An absorbing giallo , with an above -average screenplay; sometimes one thinks of the golden hour of Dario Argento (roughly 1967-1980) Gore is kept to the minimum and this story of body parts is not a remake of "les mains d'Orlac" or the poor adaptation of Boileau -Narcejac 's "body parts" .

The story is labyrinthine and definitely off the beaten track ; it deals with split personality ,homosexuality and mistaken identities ; the trick of the photograph is so simple (and so effective) that one wonders why it had not been used before .Lamberto Bava never equalled his father Mario's best horror films such as " I tre volti della paura" ,but here,he delivers the goods .

Body Puzzle

[Scarecrow-88 · 7/10 · 9 February 2008]

A psychopath, who uses a musical score playing when he sets off to methodically kill his victims, torments a "widow" by leaving the removed body parts(from those he kills, with a large, sharp butcher knife) in her home or near her parents' house. Her past, what supposedly occurred to her husband and brother, is a piece to the puzzle as is a certain motorcycle accident caused by the quietly deranged killer(..we see this "accident" take place in the memory flashback of the killer at the very beginning of the film). Detective Michael(Tomas Arana, of Michelle Soavi's "The Church")is the one burdened with trying to find the killer and François Montagut is the killer he's pursuing. Joanna Pacula is Tracy, the female protagonist whose life is possibly endangered by the psycho leaving her the parts.

Incredibly convoluted murder mystery(the identity of the killer, for example, yields a few twists)with a rather tasteless premise, stylishly executed by Lamberto Bava. I thought it was professionally made and not overly gory despite the killer's methods of destruction & removal of organs and limbs. There's a particular disturbing sequence where a schoolteacher, for the blind, is killed by the psycho while teaching class(..blood even sprays on a kid's face!). The victims chosen by the killer have something in common..there's a motive behind the killer's madness, so to speak. The theme of identity crisis plays at the heart of the film as to why the killer is committing his grisly deeds.

I thought it was kind of cool seeing Joanna Pacula in a giallo type of mystery and felt she was fitting as a book editor paranoid and frightened by what is revolving around her..her husband's body was even removed from his grave to fuel her fear and horror(..although, even that sick event plays within this macabre plot as it plays out). Gianni Garko(..of Lucio Fulci's "Seven Notes in Black), looking quite suave in his tailored suits, has a nice little minor role as Michael's demanding Police Chief wanting the brooding detective to solve the complex case as bodies start to mount. Can not forget Giovanni Lombardo Radice as a flamboyantly gay aristocrat with ties to the killer and Tracy's husband. Erika Blanc portrays the coroner whose expertise come in handy as Michael pursues the killer, trying to piece this delicate puzzle together.

Great as far as 90's giallo goes

[nick121235 · 7/10 · 19 April 2018]

I actually enjoyed this more than i thought i would, this being 90's Lamberto Bava- whom i was never a huge fan of (Delirium aside). Despite an incoherent plot it manages to stay engaging, doubtless aided by the wonderful cinematography of Luigi Kuveiller (A Woman in a Lizard's Skin, Profondo Rosso). The ending is quite charming as well. All around fun , especially for a giallo made in the 90s. Better than most of Argento's output during that decade.

Interesting giallo from Lamberto Bava.

[HumanoidOfFlesh · 7/10 · 29 June 2001]

"Body Puzzle" is a typical Italian thriller,not exactly a masterpiece,but it delivers some surprising twists.The death scenes are pretty vicious and graphic,especially when the woman has her hand chopped off.Director Lamberto Bava creates a reasonable amount of suspense and Luigi Kuvellier("Deep Red","Blood for Dracula")does the slick photography.Polish horror queen Joanna Pacula("Warlock 2","The Kiss" and awful "Haunted Sea")is pretty good as a widow in peril.It's also very nice to see Giovanni Lombardo Radice("House on the Edge of the Park","Gates of Hell","Cannibal Ferox")as the epicene Morangi.Overall this one is worth a look,if you like Italian giallos.

Piece by bloody piece.

[BA_Harrison · 7/10 · 22 April 2018]

Body Puzzle is something of an atypical giallo in so far as that the face of the killer is seen from the outset. The rest, as they say, is business as usual, with director Lamberto Bava delivering a convoluted murder mystery with a beautiful woman in peril (Joanna Pacula), a tough cop trying to crack the case (Tomas Arana), and several elaborately staged, mean-spirited murders.

Pacula plays widow Tracy, who begins to receive gruesome gifts from a serial killer: body parts from his victims. As the murderer goes about his business, police detective Michele (Arana) tries to figure out the motive for the slayings, thereby leading him to uncover the killer's identity. It all gets a little tough to follow at times, but Bava's stylish direction and the grisly death scenes ensure a good time for giallo fans.

Gory highlights include the vicious murder of a pastry store owner (who loses his ear) and the chopping off of a woman's hand in a toilet cubicle, but the most ingenious killing has to be that of a teacher in a classroom full of blind children, the psycho committing his crime as the kids happily listen to a recording of 'Peter and the Wolf'. Fans of italian horror will also get a kick out of seeing genre favourite Giovanni Lombardo Radice as camp stable owner Morangi, who supplies Michele with a vital clue.

An enjoyable Bava thriller

[Kent-13 · 8/10 · 2 June 2000]

After a man loses his lover in a motorcycle accident, he learns that the lover's organs have been transplanted into several different people. So he does what any reasonable person would do, and hacks up everyone, believing he can rebuild his lover and bring him back. Lamberto Bava directs this film with confidence, creating exciting and suspenseful scenes all the way until the wonderful surprise ending. Mario would have been proud!

Lamberto's best giallo thriller

[Andreas_W333 · 6/10 · 5 September 2020]

"Body Puzzle" is a genuine example that the gialli were still brought to life with style in the 90's. Features a high end cast, a nice plot twist and better score than most other 90's (and late 80's) gialli. I would say that this one and Argento's "Stendhal syndrome" are the two best giallo thrillers from the 90's. Well done, Bava Jr.

a dizzyingly brutal hit of anatomically deviant death, and generously plasmatic overspills

[Weirdling_Wolf · 9/10 · 24 January 2021]

Hugely admired Italian horror icon, Lamberto Bava's spectacularly sanguineous 'Body Puzzle' (1992) has lost none of its morbidly off-colour fascination and continues to beguile the world's Giallo addicts! Not only one of the more luminous examples of marrow-freezing, late-period Gialli, but an exquisitely thrilling example of maestro, Bava's uniquely twisted art. Utilizing a Columbo-like approach, viewers are immediately aware of the graphic, eviscerating mania of Body Puzzle's sublimely sick-headed, body perforating protagonist (François Montagut). Unmasked at the very beginning of the film, the catalyst for his manifestly malevolent, viscera-pilfering peccadillo remains intriguingly obscured.

The persistently exhausted Detective, Michele Livet is performed with a weathered charm by versatile character actor, Tomas Arana. Poor Michele now has the singularly ignominious task of having to quite literally piece together the gruesomely excised physical evidence! His only viable lead being that the random slayings appear to be oppressively encircling the beautiful Book Editor, Tracy Grant (Joanna 'Death Before Dishonor' Pacula). Soon their disparate fates become ardently intertwined as, Tracy's stalwart cop protector is inexorably drawn ever deeper into her darkly alluring vortex of sex and encroaching danger!

As the abhorrent killer's apparently motiveless lust for histrionic organ harvesting reaches some vile apotheosis, Michele's stresses are compounded by prototypically dour Police Chief Boss (Gianni 'Sartana' Garko) bluntly warning his beleaguered, increasingly vexed subordinate that, Michele must very soon bring the murderous miscreant to book or face extreme censure from his lofty superiors.

Maestro, Lamberto Bava's frequently exhilarating, consistently engaging thriller is no less stylishly handled than his sublime 1980s classic, the razor-sharp, arterial-spraying aria 'Blade in the Dark' (1983). Body Puzzle's dynamic set-pieces and deliriously convoluted narrative offers Giallo junkies a dizzyingly brutal hit of anatomically deviant death, and generously plasmatic overspills from one of Italian cinema's more visually exciting, perversely-minded genre icons.

Not much of a puzzle...but the gore is decent.

[The_Void · 8/10 · 28 February 2007]

Well, the Giallo had it's heyday in the early seventies, and ever since the stream of these great films got thinner and thinner until we reached the nineties and the genre sadly all but petered out. With that in mind, this isn't a particularly bad film; but it pales in comparison to its seventies counterparts, and it has to be said that by the conclusion, you kind of wonder what the point is. Giallo's are renowned for featuring over the top and frankly stupid plot lines; and this one is certainly no different, as Body Puzzle has one of the most ridiculous story lines of all! The film kicks off with two murders; the second of which sees us introduced to the cold and calculating murderer. The murders continue, and the copper on the case sees a connection to Tracy; a window who lost her husband Abe in a motorcycle accident. The cop wastes no time in falling for Tracy, meanwhile; the murder spree continues and all the signs seem to point to the dead husband and his donor card, as all the victims have the fact that they received something from Abe in common...

The film was directed by Lamberto Bava who, despite never topping the achievements of his father, has proved himself to be a capable director on a number of occasions. This film is actually the worst Lamberto Bava Giallo that I've seen, as both Macabre and A Blade in the Dark were better. The film does have its plus points, however, as Bava doesn't let the film fall short where death scenes are concerned. The murder sequences aren't overly gory, but they are pretty nasty as we witness things such as a connectionist being stabbed to death, a woman having her hand cut off and a teacher having her eyes cut out in front of a class of blind kids! The plot has its problems, however – as the fact that we know who the murderer is makes the rest of the mystery fit together all too easily. The cast is decent enough, with cult stars Erika Blanc and Giovanni Lombardo Radice standing out amongst a cast of lesser known actors. The music is completely over the top like the rest of the film; although the central classical tune is used far too often for my liking and gives the film something of a farcical feel. Overall, this film is unlikely to top anyone's list of favourite Giallo's - but considering the over the top ridiculousness of the production...it could have been worse.