Rogue's Gallery (1968) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Surprisingly good.
planktonrules22 September 2012
You can tell that this is an A.C. Lyles production, as it has Richard Arlen in the film--and he's in just about every Lyles film of the 60s. In addition, Lyles' trademark of using other stars well past their prime occurs in this film (with the likes of Jackie Coogan, Denis Morgan, Edgar Bergan and Brian Donlevy on hand as well)--though he uses far more younger (and mostly little-known) in many roles as well. In Lyles' westerns of the time, you'd often see NO ONE younger than about 50--so this is a bit of a departure. My guess is using older actors and mostly unknowns seriously cut down on production costs and that's why he did this.

The title, "Rogue's Gallery", is a play on the name of the main character, a private detective by the name of John Rogue (Roger Smith). He's very much a detective in the pattern of a Philip Marlow or Dashiell Hammett character--a guy who is down and out and willing to do just about anything to get himself out of hock. In this case, he's asked by a psychiatrist (Morgan) to follow a strange rich lady (Greta Baldwin) who seems bent on suicide. While this might sound like a simple case, naturally there are LOTS of dangers, klunks on the head and dames--all the usual elements of a dime novel mystery.

So is it any good? After all, the 1940s brought us amazing similar characters by wonderful actors like Humphrey Bogart, Dick Powell and Robert Montgomery--is the little-known actor Roger Smith up to the challenge of such a role? Yep. It's a dandy little film that shows a lot of influence from Robert Louis Stephenson's novel "The Suicide Club". And Smith was quite good in the film--handsome and quite capable. Sadly, however, he soon was diagnosed with myasthenia gravis and soon retired from films. He also is the husband of Ann-Margaret.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Misses that hip address
bkoganbing11 June 2014
Rogue's Gallery was Roger Smith's farewell to acting. Playing a rather seedy private eye whose cash flow is so bad, he's hocked his gun and before the film is over he's going to need it so he appropriates one from one of the bad guys. He also has to say farewell to his girl Friday secretary Mala Powers. It's such a contrast between this role and that cool and hip private eye who operated out of that cool address with Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. at 77 Sunset Boulevard.

For those who thought A.C. Lyles only did westerns, think again. Smith who was headed for early retirement because of health and management of wife Ann-Margret's career heads a typical A.C. Lyles cast of players past their salad days. It's psychiatrist Dennis Morgan who hires him to keep an eye on Greta Baldwin who was the fiancé of Smith's former friend who was killed in a skydiving accident. Morgan is worried about Baldwin committing suicide and he says for Smith to tail her. She exhibits certain behaviors in that direction. Shades of Vertigo.

Before it's over a whole lot of the geezer cast is involved in a nasty insurance racket and Smith has a few close calls due to lack of a firearm. It's an average mystery with shades of The Maltese Falcon as well.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Grim Business...
azathothpwiggins23 July 2021
John Rogue (Roger Smith) is a Private Detective, or as he puts it, he's in the "Confidential Human Relations" business. Rogue is rather down on his luck, so, when a job comes up he jumps at the chance. He's hired to keep track of a beautiful, rich, and purportedly suicidal woman named Valerie York (Greta Baldwin).

What seems like a simple assignment soon gets complicated when Rogue attracts the attention of some thug types. He's eventually led to a secret club catering to those with Valerie's terminal proclivity.

Rogue uncovers a sinister plot having to do with something shown at the beginning of the movie.

ROGUE'S GALLERY is a nice update of the old hardboiled detective movies from the 1930's-40's, right down to the voice-over narration. It's packed with mystery, thrills, and a host of familiar co-stars like Farley Granger, Jackie Coogan, Brian Donlevy, Richard Arlen, and Edgar Bergen. There's even a cameo for singer Johnnie Ray!

A highly enjoyable yarn...
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A good 60's private investigator,though not quite Marlowe.
mike kent20 April 2001
Being a 60's baby I love the 60's in film.Have seen this film twice I think both times as a teenager would love to see it again now.Cannot remember lots about the plot apart from the main character being a P.I.onto a tricky case in a tongue in cheek way not quite like the"Marlowe" style.An interesting watch,I'm sure its dated by now.Love to see it again though.Never show it on TV anymore,probably not known or popular enough for DVD?
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed