I've seen several stagings of this musical play-- even acted in it once in college-- and I have enjoyed the liveliness of every staging. The movie, however, is quite dead. The characters are stilted and almost everything is presented in a dry and detached manner-- so detached that the viewer can't really appreciate the important ironies of the plot even while being hit over the head with them. I also felt that the camera work was very uninspired. This film is still worth seeing just because "Die Dreigroschenoper" is an excellent play; but, if you have a choice, I'd recommend that you go see it performed as a play.
8 Reviews
Keep your change I'd say
Horst_In_Translation30 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"Die Dreigroschenoper" or "The Threepenny Opera" is a West German/French co-production from 1963, so this mostly German-language movie has its 55th anniversary this year and of course it is another take on the famous Mackie Messer story wtitten by Bertolt Brecht, who was already dead when this came out. It runs for almost 2 hours and the writer and director is Wolfgang Staudte, one of the country's most influential filmmakers at that point already for quite a whoile. So nobody can be surprised that the stars were lining up: Jürgens, Knef and Giller are just some of the names and then we have Gert Fröbe of course too who got a German Film Award nomination for his portrayal here and this was made shortly before his career-defining turn as Goldfinger, but lets talk about that one on another occasion. This one here is in colir too, which makes it a slightly better watch I guess, but still I wasn't impressed at all with any of the key components like the story (or lets say the adaptation), the characters and acting and also the music, which is a bit of a pity because I usually like musicals, but perhaps German ones not so much.
Anyway, the sets were perhaps not too bad, but otherwise I struggled caring for any of the characters, especially Mackie (not too great a Curd Jürgens fan probably) or the female protagonist (hey that's what you get for wanting a career criminal, no feeling sorry there for sure). The final execution scene felt really opulent and I wonder what Brecht would have thought of it. The best moment for me was perhaps the very final scene when we have one character sing to the audience about those in darkness vs. those in the light and that was the only musical moment I really liked. But it is definitely not worth to sit through all the lengths and mediocrity before that for that final rendition only as like I said it is a really long movie. Cannot see this overlong film to be defining whatsoever from the crime perspective either. I see the ratings and reception it got weren't too favorable and I have to agree. The cast list sure offered the potential of a far better film in my opinion and every German film buff will agree. Still Fröbe's singing wasn't too shabby and better than expected I guess. Cannot say the same about Jürgens and there's a reason he has so little singing here despite playing the man in the center of it all, perhaps not the best casting decision. So it is many minor flaws that turn this film into a disappointment overall, the sum of all these. My recommendation is to skip the watch here and go for something else instead.
Anyway, the sets were perhaps not too bad, but otherwise I struggled caring for any of the characters, especially Mackie (not too great a Curd Jürgens fan probably) or the female protagonist (hey that's what you get for wanting a career criminal, no feeling sorry there for sure). The final execution scene felt really opulent and I wonder what Brecht would have thought of it. The best moment for me was perhaps the very final scene when we have one character sing to the audience about those in darkness vs. those in the light and that was the only musical moment I really liked. But it is definitely not worth to sit through all the lengths and mediocrity before that for that final rendition only as like I said it is a really long movie. Cannot see this overlong film to be defining whatsoever from the crime perspective either. I see the ratings and reception it got weren't too favorable and I have to agree. The cast list sure offered the potential of a far better film in my opinion and every German film buff will agree. Still Fröbe's singing wasn't too shabby and better than expected I guess. Cannot say the same about Jürgens and there's a reason he has so little singing here despite playing the man in the center of it all, perhaps not the best casting decision. So it is many minor flaws that turn this film into a disappointment overall, the sum of all these. My recommendation is to skip the watch here and go for something else instead.
Great Poster Artwork - Extremely Poor Film
Ron-7212 January 2007
This film was picked up for distribution in the United States by Joseph E. Levine through his Embassy Pictures, and it premiered in a number of cities including Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Cincinnati, Houston, Milwaukee, and Oklahoma City on October 14, 1964. The advertising campaign was conceived to make the film look like one of the big "roadshow" musicals of the era--indeed, the artwork used in the posters, newspaper ads, and the eventual RCA LP album is probably the best thing about the film. Business was terrible, in part because the film was dubbed and the synchronization between the sound and visuals was off, as well as the "washed out" look of the color. Some of the theaters pulled it after several days of poor business, in others it lasted only for a week, and it only got a few sporadic openings thereafter. I do not believe that it ever made it to a theater in New York City, San Francisco, Boston, or Washington, DC.
Colour, what colour?
morrow-94 December 2006
I purchased this film video on Amazon from a market trader as it was the only version of The Threepenny Opera available in English at the time. The quality looks like a typical fifties TV video, blurred and indistinct with poor contrast and definition. The colour also seems more like a 'colorized' version of a b&w print (perhaps my copy is!) not true 'technicolor'. Of the performances I agree with the previous reviewer it is cobbled together with Sammy Davis seemingly tacked on. Many of the songs are missing and the Englisj translation is not really as authentic as you might wish. It is better to go for the original German version from the 1930s (with its French equivalent on the other side of the disc). That gives you a quality b&w film beautifully restored with very good acting and singing. If a decent copy of this 1962 version, fully restored appears it might be worth obtaining as a reference point and a curiosity. Unless you want a curio save your money and wait for a decent English-language version to appear.
The 1989 remake is far, far better
HotToastyRag27 March 2023
It broke my heart to watch The Three Penny Opera. I always thought the great German actor Curd Jurgens should have played Captain Von Trapp in The Sound of Music; in this (yes, lousy) musical, audiences could hear the proof that he could have held his own against Julie Andrews.
Sammy Davis Jr. Starts the show singing an unusual rendition of "Mack the Knife", which most people don't know was actually written in 1928 for this musical. Then we delve into the story, of head criminal Curd seducing the beggar king's daughter while trying to outrun the law. It's a melodramatic story that calls for hammy acting, but audiences should be expecting that when they watch an opera. Curd gets to puff himself up and indulge in every ounce of sex appeal as countless women in the movie fall at his feet. In one scene, while his bride laments the great danger he's in and the long list of crimes he's accused of, he merely smirks and nonchalantly unlaces her blouse.
Yes, the direction is odd, the production values are terrible, and the only copy available to watch now is in bad condition. But I couldn't bear to turn it off, not with Captain Von Trapp playing the king of the thieves, Mack the Knife. The 1989 remake (with Raoul Julia and Richard Harris) is infinitely better. The only reason to sit through this one is if you're a die-hard Curd Jurgens fan, like I am. Sammy Davis Jr. Continues to intersplice the movie with his fourth-wall narration, but it's unnecessary and silly. Plus, since this is a German flick dubbed in English, the supporting characters are really lousy actors.
Sammy Davis Jr. Starts the show singing an unusual rendition of "Mack the Knife", which most people don't know was actually written in 1928 for this musical. Then we delve into the story, of head criminal Curd seducing the beggar king's daughter while trying to outrun the law. It's a melodramatic story that calls for hammy acting, but audiences should be expecting that when they watch an opera. Curd gets to puff himself up and indulge in every ounce of sex appeal as countless women in the movie fall at his feet. In one scene, while his bride laments the great danger he's in and the long list of crimes he's accused of, he merely smirks and nonchalantly unlaces her blouse.
Yes, the direction is odd, the production values are terrible, and the only copy available to watch now is in bad condition. But I couldn't bear to turn it off, not with Captain Von Trapp playing the king of the thieves, Mack the Knife. The 1989 remake (with Raoul Julia and Richard Harris) is infinitely better. The only reason to sit through this one is if you're a die-hard Curd Jurgens fan, like I am. Sammy Davis Jr. Continues to intersplice the movie with his fourth-wall narration, but it's unnecessary and silly. Plus, since this is a German flick dubbed in English, the supporting characters are really lousy actors.
A review from a German Student.
MTHarden796 June 2000
This movie is the classic story of Mack the Knife. The version I saw was in the original German, and subtitled in English. It was filmed as a barb towards Nazi Germany, however, since anti-Gov't were forbidden the film takes places in London England. Our Hero, is a Thief. The Head of the Thieves guild. He and his crownies continually steal from the One bank in town. Mackie, likes to visit the Women of Ill Repute and they all know him, and the cops are all bought so they can't touch him. He has intentions of Marrying the Daughter of the King of the Beggars guild, and all is going well. Until the Police chief gets aspirations of Arresting Mackie, and the bank they rob goes bankrupt. Fortunately Mackie has enough money to buy the defunct bank and his crownies can become the Tellers. This is an excellent old film, and I recommend it to anyone.
West German Classic: DREIGROSCHENOPER with Hildegarde NEFF and BAFTA AWARD nominee Curd Jürgens
ZeddaZogenau26 October 2023
Epic musical theater with Hildegard Knef and Curd Jürgens
On February 8th, 1963 the time had come: the German-French film adaptation of the DREIGROSCHENOPER / THREEPENNY OPERA by Bertolt Brecht and Kurt Weill premiered in the GLORIA-Palast in Munich. Directed by Wolfgang Staudte and produced by Kurt Ulrich, the film was shot in the Berlin-Tempelhof studio with a huge cast of stars. The plot is largely taken from the play, the music was adapted somewhat to contemporary tastes with a larger orchestra.
The plot about the criminal Mackie Messer (Curd Jürgens), who is up to mischief in London at the turn of the century, can be assumed to be familiar. The cast is more interesting anyway. Lino Ventura plays the police chief Brown, June Ritchie can be seen as Mackie's bride Polly Peachum, whose parents are played by Hilde Hildebrand (Große Freiheit No. 7) and Gert Fröbe (GOLDFINGER!). Walter Giller, Siegfried Wischnewski and Erna Haffner appear in smaller roles. A casting coup from Hollywood is at the start as the moral singer: Sammy Davis Jr. Sings Brecht and Weill as if he had never done anything else.
And then Hildegard Knef (Decision Before Dawn)! Stepped in for Giulietta Masina, who was actually supposed to shoot her third film for Kurt Ulrich. Of course, Hilde was a better fit! Of course she sings the song about the dive bar Jenny and the pimp ballad together with Curd Jürgens (The Spy Who Loved Me). You simply have to see and hear this!
563,000 tickets were sold in the West German box office. It couldn't have been because of the star line-up. The lack of popularity was more likely due to the fact that the image quality and coloring could no longer meet the standards of "Der Schatz im Silbersee / Treasure in the Silver Lake" (1962). But the film is definitely worth seeing, not just for educated people and theater goers!
On February 8th, 1963 the time had come: the German-French film adaptation of the DREIGROSCHENOPER / THREEPENNY OPERA by Bertolt Brecht and Kurt Weill premiered in the GLORIA-Palast in Munich. Directed by Wolfgang Staudte and produced by Kurt Ulrich, the film was shot in the Berlin-Tempelhof studio with a huge cast of stars. The plot is largely taken from the play, the music was adapted somewhat to contemporary tastes with a larger orchestra.
The plot about the criminal Mackie Messer (Curd Jürgens), who is up to mischief in London at the turn of the century, can be assumed to be familiar. The cast is more interesting anyway. Lino Ventura plays the police chief Brown, June Ritchie can be seen as Mackie's bride Polly Peachum, whose parents are played by Hilde Hildebrand (Große Freiheit No. 7) and Gert Fröbe (GOLDFINGER!). Walter Giller, Siegfried Wischnewski and Erna Haffner appear in smaller roles. A casting coup from Hollywood is at the start as the moral singer: Sammy Davis Jr. Sings Brecht and Weill as if he had never done anything else.
And then Hildegard Knef (Decision Before Dawn)! Stepped in for Giulietta Masina, who was actually supposed to shoot her third film for Kurt Ulrich. Of course, Hilde was a better fit! Of course she sings the song about the dive bar Jenny and the pimp ballad together with Curd Jürgens (The Spy Who Loved Me). You simply have to see and hear this!
563,000 tickets were sold in the West German box office. It couldn't have been because of the star line-up. The lack of popularity was more likely due to the fact that the image quality and coloring could no longer meet the standards of "Der Schatz im Silbersee / Treasure in the Silver Lake" (1962). But the film is definitely worth seeing, not just for educated people and theater goers!
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
