Shamrock Hill (1949) Poster

(1949)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Not worth adding to your regular St. Patrick's Day viewing schedule.
mark.waltz2 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
As a movie musical, this is a decent, if corny, bit of cinematic nonsense, top notch for the dancing of leading lady Peggy Ryan whose twirling tap dancing rivals Ann Miller's. She's a young lady who lives near the much beloved Shamrock Hill that wealthy John Litel wants to purchase, sending his daughter's fiancee (Rick Vallin) to secure the sale, bur as he gets to know the people (which includes fellow dancer Rick Vallin and everybody's grandma, Mary Gordon), he sees how much this should remain out of his boss's hands. Truly Marshall, as Litel's daughter, adds sophistication in what could have been a one dimensional part, ironically resembling Miller even though she doesn't dance.

Pert young Ryan hasn't aged much since those energetic B musicals where she sang and danced with Donald O'Connor between a slught plot and Andrews Sisters numbers. She's great in this as a young woman who believes in leprechauns and insists that they're on Shamrock Hill. Gordon (whose Scottish accent makes her a miscast Irish matriarch) also believes, and indeed, the little folk do eventually appear to help Ryan. Obviously influenced by the hit Broadway show "Finian's Rainbow" two years before this, it's enjoyable fluff saved by lots of energetic singing and dancing, but the whimsy of the plot is a minor element.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Film With Heart
magicshadows-9009826 June 2019
Peggy Ryan plays Eileen, a young lady from the Rogan clan. The family is as Irish as a four leaf clover. She is a lass with lots of heart and spends her days entertaining the younger children with songs and tall tales. The children play on abandoned property that they call Shamrock Hill. The Hill is coveted by a local businessman, Judson (John Litel), who wants to build a TV station on the property. Judson assigns his attorney, Matthews (Rick Vallin) to deal with Eileen and the children.

Eileen's open heart charms Matthews and instead of scaring her off Shamrock Hill, he ends up helping her. Yes, it's all a bit of blarney. The story is simple, yet pleasing. The opening sequence made me smile, when me meet Grandma Rogan (Mary Gordon), and we learn she paints landscapes using only the color green.

When I was a youngster there were plenty of shows and movies where the theme was, "a good heart is better than a fat wallet." That theme holds true for this film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It's like kissing the Blarney Stone! When Movies Like This Were Your Best Entertainment!
vilenciaproductions30 March 2021
Bought an original 16mm print of "Shamrock Hill" in 2016, since then I have projected this picture four times every year since I bought it! Tonight December 13, 2020 I will project it yet again! What I loved about this picture are Peggy Ryan and Ray McDonald, two of the best dancers in Hollywood! They were simply the best! The only scene in this picture that I didn't like was the slow-motion dance fantasy scene that happens right after Peggy tells the children the story near the opening of the picture. They should have photographed that scene in real time, it would have made it tolerable! The nice thing about owning a copy of a movie on a film print, is you can cut out a scene that you don't like! And before the third run of the picture I cut out 100 feet of film, of that lame slow-motion scene! And it's not missed at all. That's three minutes of pain that I don't have to endure, the rest of the picture is a gem! Love the Irish family, the Rogan clan! The idea of a television tower build on Shamrock Hill is most interesting, first off when this picture was released in February of 1949, television here in Los Angeles was only a year and a few months old! KTLA was the first local television station to come on the air, this side west of the Mississippi River! By early 1948 there was still less than one thousand television sets in operation in Los Angeles! Imagine that, there are probably a thousand television sets in operation on a typical neighborhood city block now in 2020! Love the scenes with Mr. Rogan as he tries to figure out the new "analog oscilloscope" when a magnet is accidentally placed next to the device the waveform straightens out and Mr. Rogan makes his discovery! All of the cast members are great! Trudy Marshall was a babe in her time! Rick Vallin breezes through his scenes in his typical fashion! The Leprechauns are great! I knew they were real! At only 70 minutes (less the three minutes I cut out of my print) it's a perfect picture! We all need a place to go and imagine and dream like Shamrock Hill! It's a shame that television would soon take over our lives! But this was 1949 and the world was still good! America was still the best place on earth! Best of all there are no dumb female idiots with different colored hair, stupid guys covered with tattoos, loud horrible recorded rap, rock, country music! Computers, cell phones, I-phones, dumb-phones! Car chases, people yelling at each other for no good reason! NO Mr. Trump or Mr. Biden! NO Covid-19! It was the best time ever! Vinson Pictures made only two films, "Shamrock Hill" and "An Old Fashioned Girl" both released one month apart from each other in the first two months of 1949! Who knows what happened to the 35mm cut nitrate camera originals and soundtracks? I bet they are lost to careless decay! But tonight Shamrock Hill lives on our movie screen and Bell & Howell projector! Bought some beer, and we're ready to roll! Now where did that Leprechaun put my Covid-19 mask?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed