Goofs

As the regiment is heading out, we see Philadelphia standing to the far left of Mrs. Collingwood and Mrs. O'Rourke. Soon after, she is on the far right, which indicates she moved. However, right after the close-up of her standing on the far right, the next immediate long-shot has her standing on the far left again.

During the battle, when York rides toward Thursday, his saber hangs from the saddle. But when he dismounts the saber is held in his waist.

As York and Thursday are about to leave to trail Lt O'Rourke and the repair wagon, Thursday is wearing a blue kepi with a white cloth in the back to protect his head. When they arrive at Meachem's, he's still wearing the kepi with the cloth. However, as they charge after the Apaches chasing the repair wagon, where's Thursday? There is nobody wearing a kepi in the whole charge.

Wrong Guidon/Flag. Early on Capt. York (John Wayne) is relieved of temporary command of Ft. Apache by Lt. Col. Thursday (Henry Fonda) whom then orders him to return to HIS Troop which we learn is "A" Troop. A bit further on in the movie York (Wayne) is ordered to take a platoon from "A" Troop and trail the telegraph repair crew at a striking distance. A moment after that we see that strike force headed by Capt. York being lead by a Trooper/Standard Bearer carrying a "C" Troop guidon/unit flag.

When Collingwood is replaced by Lt Gates as adjutant, Gates begins to take off his saber. Film cuts to Henry Fonda and back to Gates already seated at the desk.

During Captain York's search for Cochise, the Apaches keep track of his progress via mirror flashes. Even though the Apaches did not have a written language, they still could have used any code of their own devising to communicate (as they did with smoke signals).

It is claimed that years later Geronimo's witnessing of a heliograph (mirrored code transmission) in use by the US Army it caused him to surrender for the last time.

A written language is not necessary to interpret mirror flashes (heliograph). They wouldn't be using Morse Code.

During the Grand March at the dance, the actors perform the first round (couples) leading with the dance-favored right foot. When they double up to 4s and then 8s, they are leading with the military-favored left foot.

This is an observation of who leads with which foot. There is no official lead-off foot for the Grand March. Military are trained to step out with the left foot, as in marching. It doesn't matter as long as everybody does it the same way. It's just walking.

When Lt. Michael O'Rourke and Philadelphia goes riding, they stop for while with a high and peaked boulder on their left-hand side. In the next shot, when they renew to ride, seen away from the other side, the boulder has changed to a large and low one.

That's not seen from the other side. They turned about face and were riding away from the high, peaked boulder. It's now behind them.

When Col. Thursday leads a company "at a striking distance" from a repair patrol lead by Lt. O'Rourke. Sgt. Mulcahey is part of O'Rourke's patrol, but when the action shifts to show Col. Thursday's company in a saber charge against the Apache's there is a clear shot of Sgt. Mulcahey riding next to the flag bearer with his saber drawn. Note: this scene was duplicated from Col. Thursday's final charge against Cochise.

During the final charge of the Apache onto Lt. Colonel Thursday's troopers, a far shot of the warriors streaming around their position shows just a single Apache warrior leaping into the position. When the warrior does so, most if not all the trapped troopers fall at the same time.

When Lt. O'Rourke and his party is escaping from the Indians they show the detail riding from right to left. However, in another cut you see the Apaches riding from left to right as if the two parties were riding toward one another instead of both riding in the same direction with the Indians chasing Lt. O'Rourke's detail.

Filmed from the right side and filmed from the left side. One gets used to it after a while.

Captain York, remembering Thursday as a general from the Civil War, politely calls him "General Thursday", reflecting an elevation to that brevetted rank during the war (for Thursday's valiant charge mentioned by Capt. Collingwood, which earned Thursday the honor).

Thursday says his rank is lieutenant colonel, the rank he is paid in. Since Thursday is a brevet major general, and a brevet honor is for life, often granted posthumously, he has the right to wear a major general's uniform, but chooses not to. Which reflects both his obsession with honor and a perverse egotism, spurning a shallow honor while determined to earn the full one, a permanent promotion to general. That is why he is so frustrated and unglued by his derailment to the backwater of Fort Apache, as he sees the path to that legacy impossibly occluded. And instead takes a shortcut not merely to glory but immortality with his flashy kamikaze charge.

Loose handling of military history. Colonel Thursday is clearly based on Colonel George A. Custer and his "last stand" at Little Bighorn in 1876. Apache Chief Cochise is presented as Thursday/Custer's adversary. The real Cochise agreed to a peace treaty with the US Army in 1872 and died two years later. And Custer never fought Apache. He was occupied with the Plains Indian tribes to the north.

At 01:00:20 a small truck is seen on a road in the background, behind and to the right of the row of Apaches who are about to attack the repair wagon.

Colonel Thursday tells York his hat should be creased "like a fedora." The action of "Fort Apache" - entirely a work of fiction - ostensibly takes place some time after the end of the Civil War and before Cochise's final surrender in 1872. The word "fedora" does not enter the language until 1882.

When the new recruits are assembled for the second time (in uniform) the two closest to the camera appear to be wearing denim jeans resembling Levi's. That style of work pant was still just taking shape in California and Nevada at that time, with the patent granted for reinforcing stress points of loose-fitting "waist overalls" with copper rivets only issued in 1873 (one year after Cochise's final surrender, and one year before he died).

Cavalry trousers, when available, were made of blue kersey wool material, not cotton denim. Though superficially straight-leg "original" blue jeans appear to fit in just fine with the movie timeframe they are clearly anachronistic in that form, and unlikely to appear in frontier Arizona in that period regardless.

Just before the Indians are about to attack the wagon, a vehicle is clearly visible in the background in the lower right corner.

When Captain York and Beaufort are riding to meet Cochise they pass a spot on the Colorado River which is on the northern border with Utah not the southern border of Arizona with Mexico.

During the dance in the Sergeants Mess, when the dancers are coming round in front of the camera in fours, one of the dancers curtsies, but none of the other women do this. They had already done so in a previous shot and obviously the woman must have been confused.