Angel and Sinner (1945) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Ticket To Ride
writers_reign27 March 2007
There's a school of thought that makes a case for Pyshka as the finest adaptation of Guy de Maupassant's short story Boule de Suif. Directed by Mikhail Romm and starring Galina Sergeyava this was also the last silent film produced in Russia but I'd have to ask another Galina, a valued friend, for more information on this version. Another friend, dbdmonteuil is slightly mistaken when he says that Dudley Nichols used Boule de Suif as a basis for Stagecoach. Nichols adapted a short story, Stage To Lordsburg, by Douglas Haycox, a well-known Western novelist so it is Haycox who may have been inspired by Boule de Suif.

What matters ultimately, of course, is what kind of fist Christian Jacque and Micheline Presle made of it and the answer is a pretty damn good one. Jacque had a penchant for period films - his Fanfan La Tulipe - remains a benchmark in French cinema and he exhibits a sure touch with his material. For good measure another Maupassant story, Mademoiselle Fifi, is thrown into the mix and blends in perfectly and seamlessly; the Hollywood Bomber Crew are all out of the right bottle with stalwarts such as Gabrielle Fontan (Porte de Lilas, Les Portes de la nuit, etc) lending sterling support but ultimately it is Presle's movie and she takes it with both hands and runs with it. A minor gem.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
French black and white classic, with De Maupassant to boot
jimcheva8 June 2020
I was actually trying to watch "Grease" (which I'd never seen), gave up to go to this film version of one of the great Guy de Maupassant's greatest short stories. No regrets. The main theme of the original story is the rank hypocrisy of various bourgeois and two nuns when their fortunes depend on a good-hearted prostitute they have all treated with contempt. This version covers that angle but, even before getting to the added-on adaptation of "Mademoiselle Fifi" adds in some other touches, notably a lone male who probably for post-war French suggested a maquisard hero. Here, he also serves as a bit of a Greek chorus in his regard of the despicable behavior of the townsfolk. Knowing this was made just after the war, one might think the hideous portrayal of the Prussians was a disguised take on the Nazis, and it may have been, but de Maupassant's portrayal of the Prussians was close to what one sees here. Micheline Presles (who apparently is still acting) is magnetic here. It is also fun to see the nuns portrayed here in a far more positive light than in the original. For those who know the original story, it might have been interesting to see how a director would show Boule de Suif's reaction at the end of the story, but the shift the story takes here is actually pretty gratifying. The core social commentary survives, but is extended here to a richer story.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Two short stories.....
dbdumonteil24 October 2005
These are two short stories of MAUPASSANT transferred to the screen but this is not the usual film made up of sketches .The two stories "Boule de Suif " and "Mademoiselle Fifi" are blended with skill:as Boule de Suif was coveted by a Prussian officer,it was easy to introduce the hero of another short story ,a sadistic soldier nicknamed "mademoiselle Fifi".THe smug mean bourgeois of Maupassant are present and Micheline Presles is a memorable heroine.This is one of Christian-Jaque 's best films and it should be more known.

NB:Maupassant's short story also inspired Dudley Nichols for "Stagecoach" (1939) whose main character played by Claire Trevor is some kind of "Boule de Suif".
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed