The Gates of Heaven (1945) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A semi-lost masterpiece
ItalianGerry10 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Vittorio De Sica's "La porta del cielo" ("Gate of Heaven") was made during the last part of the Nazi occupation of Rome and was not released until after the liberation and then only minimally and pretty much shelved. De Sica took on the project as a delaying tactic so as not to be forced to join the Italian cinema industry in its forced move northward after the Badoglio government signed the armistice with the Allies and Italy was thrust into a fratricidal civil war. De Sica told the urging Nazis that he had taken on a film project for the Vatican and worked on the movie, slowly, hoping the war would end while he filmed.

The movie was financed by the Centro Cattolico Cinematografico and much of it was shot inside the extra-territorial basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, with the interior doubling as the shrine of Our Lady of Loreto. The story follows a group of pilgrims, each with personal health issues and other problems, hoping to find a cure or solution in the church at Loreto, Italy's version of the shrine of Lourdes in France. Much of it takes place on a special train ("treno bianco" or "white train") transporting these pilgrims to the shrine from the south of Italy and making stops in other cities along the way to pick up additional participants.

The narrative includes several flashbacks into the lives of the people on the train. Among the pilgrims is a young concert pianist, played by Roldano Lupi, who has lost the use of his left hand, and who hopes for a miracle, despite his not being a believer. There are two workers, Carlo Ninchi and Massimo Girotti, one of whom is blinded in a factory accident that turns out to be caused by his friend. The blind man wants to regain his sight; the other seeks forgiveness for his act of malice. There is a handicapped boy in a wheelchair accompanied by his sister, played by Maria Mercader. Mercader was De Sica's wife/mistress and it was she who had arranged for the project to take place. There is an old woman, a governess in the service of a wealthy family, who wants to seek peace for the warring family members. There are many wonderful sequences, and the screenplay, written in part by De Sica's great collaborator Cesare Zavattini, adds a good deal of humanity to the movie and a realism not characteristic of much Italian cinema of the time. In a way this was a precursor of neorealism as much as Visconti's "Ossessione", and De Sica's own "I bambini ci guardano."

For De Sica himself this was one of his favorite movies and he always regretted that circumstances had caused it never to reach a public in the period after it was made. For the longest time De Sica's son Christian owned what was the only know copy of the movie, a 16mm print that she showed to people from time to time, including the writer Nino Lo Bello, who published on article on it in 1981 after a private viewing. In 1991 The film was shown, based on newly discovered archival-quality 35mm materials, as part of a De Sica retrospective at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. That was where I first saw it. DVD copies of the movie can, as of now, only be found in private collections and derive from a RAI-TRE television showing.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The neo-realistic masterpiece of compassion
clanciai31 May 2023
This was Vittorio de Sica's own favourite among his films, and he always regretted that it was more or less thrown aside, as it was made during the chaotic ending of the war when Italy was thrown into the turmoil of civil war and practically lost in the national confusion, and few copies of the film have survived, mainly only in 16mm format. Hopefully the film will some day be completely restored, as it is an undeniable and indispensable masterpiece, being definitely de Sica's most compassionate film, compassion pervades the film from the beginning to the end in constantly increasing fervour, and there are many scenes of unforgettably touching if not heartrending poignancy, the boy in the wheelchair and his way of descending the stairs, the passion of the pianist who loses the command of his right hand in the middle of a concert, the old lady with her concern for a family at war in constant harrowing conflict, the merry industrial worker who gets blinded for life, the scenes at the train station and in the train, and the grand finale in the cathedral, actually San Paolo fuori le mura in Rome, borrowed for the purpose of the film and transforming it into an equivalent to Lourdes, it's a very Catholic film, but compassion dominates everything Catholic here, giving it a universal significance and solemnity of the high communion of a large congregation - there are many actors and actresses here, and they are all indispensable for the whole. The film is a revelation of compassion and perhaps even de Sicat's most beautiful film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed