Fleischer Studios' "Color Classics" cartoons were very uneven. There were good to wonderful ones such as 'Somewhere in Dreamland', 'Poor Cinderella', 'Greedy Humpty Dumpty', 'Play Safe' and 'Christmas Comes But Once a Year'. There were also average at best ones such as 'Little Lambkin' and all of the Hunky and Spunky cartoons ('Barnyard Brat' being the worst and one of the series' worst). And there was a good number that were in between, none of which being terrible while still being nothing special.
'Peeping Penguins' is one of the in between "Color Classics" cartoons, despite being made in one of Fleischer's better overall periods (with exceptions such as the later toned down Betty Boop cartoons). It is cute, well made and scored but also somewhat bland and routine with more energy and humour needed, making for a pleasant enough effort but nothing special which as said is the general standard that the in between "Color Classics" cartoons have.
Once again, the animation and music are the stars. The animation is vibrant, atmospheric, meticulously detailed and fluid, the background art being especially good and the snow is very strikingly used. The music is lively in character and the lushness and clever instrumentation is very pleasant on the ear. Oh and the song is very catchy. It is cute without being too saccharine, does have its charm and there are a few inspired and amusing moments. Like with the fire. Part of me was not expecting the ending either.
The penguins could have been more distinct from each other in personality but are pretty adorable and amuse, compelling enough characters. Jack Mercer has done better in the individuality department but still does solidly.
However, the story is very thin and feels rather run-of-the-mill with not enough surprises, making it come over as very predictable as well. More consistent energy wouldn't have gone amiss too. 'Peeping Penguins' is not completely without entertainment value, but the gags could have been more in number and only a couple of them are properly inspired, competent but not much more.
Despite good intentions, the moral could have been handled with much more subtlety, for my tastes it was laid on too thick.
In conclusion, nice but unexceptional. 6/10
'Peeping Penguins' is one of the in between "Color Classics" cartoons, despite being made in one of Fleischer's better overall periods (with exceptions such as the later toned down Betty Boop cartoons). It is cute, well made and scored but also somewhat bland and routine with more energy and humour needed, making for a pleasant enough effort but nothing special which as said is the general standard that the in between "Color Classics" cartoons have.
Once again, the animation and music are the stars. The animation is vibrant, atmospheric, meticulously detailed and fluid, the background art being especially good and the snow is very strikingly used. The music is lively in character and the lushness and clever instrumentation is very pleasant on the ear. Oh and the song is very catchy. It is cute without being too saccharine, does have its charm and there are a few inspired and amusing moments. Like with the fire. Part of me was not expecting the ending either.
The penguins could have been more distinct from each other in personality but are pretty adorable and amuse, compelling enough characters. Jack Mercer has done better in the individuality department but still does solidly.
However, the story is very thin and feels rather run-of-the-mill with not enough surprises, making it come over as very predictable as well. More consistent energy wouldn't have gone amiss too. 'Peeping Penguins' is not completely without entertainment value, but the gags could have been more in number and only a couple of them are properly inspired, competent but not much more.
Despite good intentions, the moral could have been handled with much more subtlety, for my tastes it was laid on too thick.
In conclusion, nice but unexceptional. 6/10