Giallo (1934) Poster

(1934)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A real curio from the 30's
Red-Barracuda20 April 2013
This is something of interest for sure. Not only is it a very early Italian talkie but also a really old example of the Italian giallo tradition. I have seen loads of 30's American mysteries from the Poverty Row studios and, in the main I haven't exactly been too impressed. Most of them rely on lame comedy characters and seem to revolve around a large group of people inhabiting old dark houses with secret passageways and sometimes men in monkey suits. They are pretty interminable on the whole. So it came as a pleasant surprise to discover that this Italian 30's low budgeter didn't play things quite so inanely. Don't get me wrong, it still has the sort of plot-line that you could imagine the Poverty Row studios making a dozen quickies with but it is done with less stupid humour and contrivances.

The story is about a woman who discovers evidence that suggests that her husband murdered his previous wife. Her and one of his associates – a man who is in love with her – then start to suspect that they are next in line to be killed.

It is very interesting to see that the giallo tradition went back considerably further than the early 60's when Mario Bava kicked things off with his Hitchcock influenced The Girl Who Knew Too Much (1963). But before fans of the sub-genre get too excited it is worth pointing out that, as was previously thought, Bava's film actually is the first giallo movie proper. This film merely shows that the literary roots of the giallo went back much earlier in the 20th century. Giallo (1934) is a product of this; it doesn't have the stylistic features that typify the screen variant of the genre. Nevertheless, it's an extremely early indicator of the Italian fascination in low budget thrillers based on those famous yellow books, one which would go into hyper-drive over forty years later. The film itself is held together with some decent performances from Assia Noris as the fearful wife Henriette and Sandro Ruffini as her husband. It still has a light feel, which only goes with the time period and it isn't really very suspenseful to be honest but neither is it tiresome like so many of its American counterparts. Its Italian presentation definitely gives it something different and it is a very fascinating rarity that is definitely worth catching up with.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Early artifact poking fun at a pop culture craze
melvelvit-126 May 2014
In 2012, the IMDb genre listing for Mario Camerini's GIALLO was "comedy" but it's since been changed to "thriller" which, unfortunately, is a surefire setup for disappointment. In a nutshell, "comedy" was correct since the film clearly pokes fun at "gialli", a pop culture craze sweeping Italy at the time.

As most already know, the term "giallo" (Italian for "yellow") originally referred to a series of extremely popular mystery novels (by authors like Edgar Wallace, Agatha Christie, and James M. Cain) which were published in Italy by Mondadori beginning in the late '20s and were distinguished by their yellow covers. The heroine here -an avid giallo fan who "reads too many mysteries"- is convinced her husband is a notorious wife-killer intent on doing her in and at one point a character is actually seen reading an "Edgar Wallace super giallo". Based on a playful play by Edgar Wallace, it's definitely an amusing footnote in the Italian horror sub-genre's genealogy (it can legitimately claim to be "the first") but don't get too excited -there's a zero body count and bears no resemblance to the "giallo" of the '60s and '70s. An "historically significant" curio at best but a fun one, nonetheless.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The first ever Giallo?
morrison-dylan-fan6 May 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Taking a look at a thread on IMDb's Classic Film board about movies that people have recently seen,I noticed an IMDb'er mention that they had recently stumbled upon,what might be the first ever film from the Giallo sub-genre,from 1934!

Being very interested in seeing,what may be the first ever step for the sub-genre,I decided to go on a search,in the hope of tracking down this long forgotten origin tale.

View on the film:

Adapting a play by Edgar Wallace, (who would decades later kick off the long-lasting Euro mystery era with the creation of a German cinema sub- genre called Krimi) the screenplay by Mario Soldati creates an extremely rough sketch of the gialli,with Soldati starting some themes that would be expanded upon 30 years later,in the films 68 minute running time,from the mystery involving the inhabitants of an upper-class mansion,to Henriette (played by a cute Assia Noris) being revealed by Soldati as someone who is just a little bit too much of a fan of Edgar Wallace murder-mystery novels.

Whilst director Mario Camerini does take a restrained approach for most of the movie,Camerini does thankfully show a stylish flourish in some of the most memorable scenes of this Giallo,with Camerini using an out door hunting party to show that the suspect killer could attack at any moment,and also giving the ending a nice Gothic chill by having the lights go out,as Henriette prepares to find out her husband's motive,in a Giallo whose near 80 year old yellow cover has not completely faded away with time.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Lovely mystery comedy.
HumanoidOfFlesh22 January 2015
Henriette(charming Assia Noris)is obsessed with giallo novels of Edgar Wallace.She suspects that her husband Giorgio murdered his ex-wife and mother-in-law in Canada.I would not classify Mario Camerini's "Giallo" as the first giallo movie ever made.This film is more similar to Old Dark House films from Hollywood and subtle murder mysteries with comedic touches.Still "Giallo" is a very enjoyable paranoia film with stylish opening and nicely created Gothic atmosphere during storm sequence.I loved the acting performance of beautiful Assia Noris and I would like to see more movies with this Russian-born beauty.Now I need to find and see "Delitto al Luna Park"(1952)by Renato Polselli.7 foxes out of 10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed