Worldly Goods (1930) Poster

(1930)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Truncated film gets a truncated rating from me
AlsExGal28 February 2016
Warning: Spoilers
If there had been more of it, I might have rated it higher. It was a poverty row film all of the way, yet it does not have laughable art design. Nothing looks like cardboard or a toy model. This was a blind buy for me, and I don't regret the purchase or the viewing. The problem is it just ends with no wrap up, plus there is no build up or motivation for the extreme changes in all three main characters.

The opening scene has John C. Tullock, industrialist, being told that the government is unhappy with the performance of his planes. He says "They meet spec don't they?". The answer is "Yes" and he ignores the complaint. Jeff, a WWI pilot, crashes in one of these "Tullock coffins" as they are called, lives, but is blinded by the head injury. Jeff has his best friend meet Mary, his fiancée, at the docks when their boat lands. He tells Mary Jeff died on the way over, because Jeff does not want to burden Mary with a blind man.

Jeff ironically ends up working at an airstrip owned by Tullock, all the time vowing revenge upon the industrialist responsible for his blindness. Mary is rooming with a party girl, and begins accompanying her party girl roommate to some of these parties, all the time retaining her freshness and positive attitude despite her turns of bad luck.

I'll let you watch and see the rest of this, but these three characters - Tullock, Mary, and Jeff all have their lives intersect in such a way that there could be dozens of interesting denouements. The main transformation is that of Tullock from a money hungry tyrant into someone who genuinely does good works for the right reasons and then does something that nobody would say he owes the human race or anybody in it. Then the film just ends abruptly.

The performances are really quite good, and I rated it a five not for mediocrity but for truncation.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
This film recently discovered!!!!!
yrkconnors-123 January 2015
About five months ago a friend purchased prints at an estate sale and this was one of them!! THIS MAY CONTAIN SOME SPOILERS!!!!! A young flier, blinded in the war, has his girlfriend informed of his death, returns home and takes a job at an airfield. Harboring a great hatred for the industrialist who built the plane he crashed in, he often speaks of someday being able to kill him. When a chance meeting with a wealthy man forms a bond which eventually leads to an operation which restores his sight, the boy then learns who his benefactor is--but also finds out that the older man's new wife is the boy's former girlfriend. The acting is a bit static. James Kirkwood, who had a long career in films, plays Tullock the industrialist and gives a decent performance as a man who has everything, but at the same time, nothing. Ferdinand Schumann-Heink plays the blinded boy. Heink had a 20 year career in films, playing a large number of uncredited roles. All in all I'd give this one a 6 out of 10. But anytime you can erase a title from the "lost" list, it's a good thing. Bob Connors (yrkconnors@yahoo.com)
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Material Worth
kidboots1 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
If ever an actress's face proclaimed "sweet young thing" it was Merna Kennedy's. She made her debut in Charlie Chaplin's "The Circus"(1928) - the one people don't really talk about, then she was given a good role in Universal's film of the year "Broadway"(1929) but, unfortunately, it was all downhill from there. She had a similar look to Marceline Day and, if anything, she was a blander actress but she was perfect for "the girl" roles, especially the "very good girl" roles. It was amazing that she was still being starred as late as 1932 - even though the studios had names like Tower and Continental.

This movie stars James Kirkwood as John C. Tullock, a man who has his grip on many industries - railway, shipping, oil. He is ruthless however, with his eye only on the next dollar and questions are raised about the standards of his planes during the war. The workmanship is shoddy with many of the planes shot down proved to be defective and one young pilot who is blinded in a crash is determined to make him pay for the death of his buddies who didn't make it. And just to make the movie even more complicated Jeff tells his mate Jimmy to inform his girl Mary (Kennedy) that he didn't return and of course she is heart broken.

Jeff runs across Tullock who, under the original name of "Smith" admires the blind man's guts and determination and offers to pay for an operation to restore the young aviator's sight!! Meanwhile Mary throws herself into a round of parties "to forget" and meets Tullock who at first says "that ladylike stuff doesn't go over with me"!! but Mary's friend Cassie (Shannon Day) convinces him that she is a girl who's on the level!! He changes under Mary's influence and starts to use his money for charity and good. Jeff's sight returns and "Smith" instantly tells him the truth - that he is Tullock but is a changed man and Jeff accepts that...but when Jeff is invited to dinner to meet the wonderful girl responsible for the change will he be able to bear it??? I wonder......
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not bad for its kind. Too bad the plot doesn't wrap up.
mark.waltz4 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Industrialist James Kirkwood has everything he wants except one thing. A lifelong companion. He has to get it in the most unscrupulous of ways, paying party girl Myrna Kennedy to marry him. it takes some doing though because Myrna is actually a good girl, grieving for a lover ( Ferdinand Schumann-Heink) whom she believed died in World War One. In reality, he was in a plane crash and left blind, ordering his friend Eddie Featherston to keep his survival secret. Kirkwood discovers that malfunctions in his equipment caused Ferdinand to crash and under an assumed name, pays for Ferdinand's eye operation. It's inevitable that the truth will come out, and how it is dealt with doesn't really leave the audience with any conclusion.

I could have dealt with another real of this film to see how the two men, becoming close friends in spite of the odds, dealt with a conflict at hand. Kennedy is very good as she realizes that a marriage of companionship is better than a lifetime of grieving. As her best friend, Shannon Day is better than any of the stars, making her play for Kirkwood but realizing the sincerity of his feelings for her friend. she perfectly emulates the party girl with the Heart of Gold that might see gold in a wealthy man but her own goodness prevents her from taking it any further. The two men are rather staid in their performances which didn't leave me any feelings for them as people. Schumann-Heink's motives for pulling an Enoch Arden aren't believable either and the coincidence which leads to the reunion with Kennedy is never played as emotionally as it should have been. Still, I was drawn into the story and was more disappointed by the fact that it never really left me satisfied with how it was or wasn't resolved.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed