The Fourth Commandment (1927) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Rare Drama
Maliejandra4 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The Fourth Commandment is "honor thy father and thy mother." This film is based on that concept. A man and a woman meet and fall in love, winding up getting married and starting a family. Virginia (Belle Bennett) decides she is fed up with being a homemaker and wants to go back to work. The couple invites his mother (Mary Carr) to come live with and keep house for them. She cares deeply for Sonny (Wendell Phillips Franklin) and the two form a strong bond. Virginia gets jealous and starts acting out, even though her mother-in-law cares for her and means no harm. Virginia gives her husband an ultimatum: either his mother goes or she does. In a desperate and dramatic scene, Virginia leaves.

Years later, Sonny is grown up (Robert Agnew) and finds a wife of his own (June Marlowe) but they bicker often because both of them want more out of life. It seems his past may be influencing his future.

The story is predictably melodramatic, but the characters are compelling and we feel invested in their happiness. Although the cast listing on IMDB would have you believe otherwise, Bennett is undoubtedly the star of this film. She ages through it, carrying the bulk of the action. She is a capable dramatic actress who is best remembered today for her role in Stella Dallas.

The cinematography is lovely. Outdoor scenes show off the splendor of nature with the decorous touch of the 1920s. Effective use of dissolves illustrate when items are out of place in the home, and represent the passage of time.

This film ran streaming online as part of Cinecon's 2020 online edition. It is quite rare, the only complete print known to exist. It was transferred to digital by the Library of Congress.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Turnabout Is Fair Play
boblipton15 March 2024
Belle Bennett never knew her mother, but she found a loving mother-in-law with Mary Carr, and a hardworking and loving husband in Mrs. Carr's son, Henry Victor. But the confines of the house are too much for her, when she sees the wealth of her neighbors. She goes back to work for rich man Robert Elliott, who offers to marry her. She convinces herself that Mrs. Carr has retained the primary love of her son, and now her grandson, so she flees to Elliott's arms. But the years go by, Elliott is found to be an embezzler. He kills himself, Miss Bennett is stripped of her wealth, and goes to live with her son and his ukulele-playing wife. Soon history repeats itself.

This sort of weeper, in which people cut off their noses to spite their faces and then go around crying because they have no nose is not my cup of tea. Nonetheless, there is no disputing the strength of Miss Bennett's performance; even if the material and direction is nowhere near the level of STELLA DALLAS, her issues are understandable, her actions, if not forgivable by anyone save the saint-like Mrs. Carr, are also understandable.

A kind word must be reserved for the unnamed make-up team who convincingly aged Victor and Miss Bennett. I cannot really recommend this movie, since Miss Bennett's character brought all of her suffering on herself. But for what it does, it does it well.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed