Won by a Fish (1912) Poster

(1912)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Just For The Halibut
boblipton30 September 2018
Dell Henderson goes fishing every day and can't catch anything larger than a sprat. Edward Dillon teases him about this. Angered, Dell tells Dillon he may not see his daughter, Mary Pickford (credited here, at the elderly age of 20, as "The Woman"). The next day, on their way to plead for their love, they find Dell asleep at the rod and an immense halibut for sale in a fish shop.

Before he was lured off to form Keystone and his own career as a film magnate, Mack Sennett spent a four-year apprenticeship at Biograph, working for D.W. Griffith as writer, actor and director of eighty or ninety short comedies. They were not wild slapstick comedies, but far more genteel efforts in which normal-looking people would do almost normal things to get what they wanted -- in this case, Eddie Dillon and Mary Pickford. Under the direction of some one like Griffith, movies like this one could be charming, effervescent and even telling in some way of society's problems. Mack admired Griffith, he learned from him, he respected him and throughout his life referred to him as "The Master." He just didn't want to make that sort of movie. He wanted to make people laugh, and the best way he knew was by being outrageous.

This this movie is interesting in showing this stage of Sennett's development. It's interesting to see Mary Pickford in a movie where she is upstaged by a dead fish. It's just not terribly funny once you've figured out the one joke that is available in half a reel of film.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting Use of a Box Camera and A Fish
jayraskin18 November 2023
This is a funny tale, about a suitor (Edward Dillon) and his sweetheart (Mary Pickford). Mary's father (Dell Henderson) comes home after a bad day at fishing and throws out the suitor. The rest of the 9 minutes is about how Mary and Edward find a way to get revenge on Dell and get him to approve their marriage.

Director Mack Sennett does a good job of keeping the action moving. Mary, as always, gives a good performance as does Dell Henderson as the father.

It thought the use of a box camera to take photos of a fish with both Dell and Edward was a clever part of the story. Edward and Mary trick Dell into thinking that he caught a giant fish that they bought at a fishing shop. After bragging to all his friends how he caught the giant fish, Dell, to maintain his reputation as a great fisherman, must allow the marriage he had denied previously. But for the fish, and their photography trick, Edward and Mary would not have married. Thus the title "Won by a Fish" I'm sure at least the fishermen in the audience enjoyed the movie, as well as young men and women looking for tips to trick their parents into giving permission for marriage.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed