Winsor McCay, the Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and His Moving Comics (1911) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
19 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
First Expressive Character Animated Movie
springfieldrental15 March 2021
Winsor McCay was a newspaper cartoonist for the New York Herald, drawing such famous comic strips as "Dream of the Rabbit Fiend" and "Little Nemo In Slumberland." He was a super fast drawer who displayed his skills on the vaudeville circuit, performing what's known as chalk talk, entertaining his audience with jokes while quickly drawing detailed art on his canvass.

His son brought home some flip books containing a series of drawings. When skimming the pages from front to back, the combined drawings would show its drawn characters moving. McCay felt he could do the same thing on film and took the challenge to create a movie cartoon of his characters. His result was April 1911's "Little Nemo," the first character animated short film in cinema. The movie's full name," Winsor McCay: The Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and His Moving Comics," combined live action with his cartoon. The 11 minute movie shows McCay betting his colleagues he could create a cartoon made up of 4,000 drawings within one month. A later scene has McCay with a stack of drawings in his office being disrupted by a curious kid. Finally, McCay finishes and presents his cartoon.

Originally, the cartoon was black and white. When McCay took the cartoon on his vaudeville circuit, the reception he received was overwhelming. He decided to paint the film frames.

The title of the longer version claims McCay's cartoon was the first in the world to make animated films. As seen, there were a handful of earlier animation drawings that used simple "chalk" white on black lines to show movements of nondescript characters. In McCay's "Little Nemo," he uses what's called expressive character animation, transferring his newspaper strips' characters who had personalities of humans onto the cartoon. This was a first in cinema.

McCay's laborious composite of 4,000 drawings onto rice paper would be one of the few times an animated cartoon required to have a drawing for each film frame photographed for the stop-motion camera technique. Other animators would soon come up with shortcuts such as using "Cels" and registration pegs to speed up and simplify McCay's individual hand drawings.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Absolutely Amazing Early Animation
gavin694221 January 2016
Cartoon figures announce, via comic strip balloons, that they will move -- and move they do, in a wildly exaggerated style.

Is this the greatest cartoon you will ever see? No. But it deserves high praise for the work that went into it, especially so early in the realm of cinema and animation. Apparently it took up to four month for these images to be colored an drawn, which is a fair amount of time for only a few minutes.

Strangely, I don't think Winsor McCay is a known name today. With his comic strip (Little Nemo) and animation (Gertie the Dinosaur), he should be seen as a film pioneer, but he does not get the same sort of recognition that Melies or Edison do. (I mean, I wouldn't put him that high, either, but who else was doing animation this early on?)
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Master
Puppetmister12 February 2002
McCay's cartoons are all beautiful. This was his first. Typically, the animation exists as a sort of meta narrative, while McCay himself appears in a miniature framing story where he is challenged to produce moving drawings in a certain amount of time. The same device appears in most prints of Gertie the Dinosaur. McCay was a lightning sketch artist and did performances of his swift drawings, so moving picture animation was really an extension of the idea of rapid sketching providing dynamic impressions of motion in his work. Restricted from travelling with his shows by the newspaper that didn't want to lose his cartoons from its pages, it also meant that he could diffuse his talents internationally despite being confined to New York for long periods at a time. The drawings in Little Nemo do not tell a story as such, but instead show characters delighting in their freedom to "stretch and squash", elongating their bodies to demonstrate the malleability of the medium. When Disney studios established its basic principles of animation which would be common to all of its anthropomorphised animal characters, "stretch and squash" was one of the variables which could be applied to a character to give it a distinctive movement. In Disney, the more comedic a character is, the more stretchy and squashy it will be. For McCay, the elasticity of the characters is a way of displaying their triumph over the usual physical laws governing organic bodies. McCay was not concerned with simplistic comedy, as can be witnessed most strikingly in 'The Sinking of the Lusitania'(1918). In the early days of animation, there was no rule which said animation had to be deployed solely for childish comedy, but the industry gradually forced into that pigeonhole to suppress its more (potentially) subversive elements. Kristin Thompson writes superbly on this subject if you're interested. A video and DVD is available featuring all of McCay's animated cartoons. Anyone interested in the history of animation, or early cinema in general, must see it all.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply marvelous--a must for fans of early animation and cinema
planktonrules7 September 2006
This is a very early cartoon, but it starts off in a most peculiar manner. The cartoon's creator, Winsor McCay, is shown talking to a group of friends about his creations--explaining a little about the process. Then, the camera goes to his studio and he shows some of the steps needed to produce an animated cartoon. Then in the final portion of the film, his cartoon comes to life and there are some amazing (for their time) animations that are also hand-colored. While none of this stuff will make you forget Looney Tunes or Disney, it is an amazing insight into the process and as such it's an item of extreme historical importance. Cute and watchable--even today.

By the way, when I saw the film again, I noticed that the very famous John Bunny was one of the people in the beginning of the film. While practically no one today would recognize him (other than cinema nuts like myself), this rotund man was perhaps the first comedian in film. Sadly, most of his movies have been lost over the years and he died rather young in 1915. I've seen just a few of his remaining films, but his round face is hard to miss in this film.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Moving in two senses
someguy88916 June 2004
Winsor McCay, The Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and his Moving Comics was a 1911 short I saw as part of the Landmarks of Early Film DVD. It was by far my favorite, beating out even the more popular Voyage to the Moon and The Great Train Robbery. This movie is simply perfect. A cartoonist is hired to draw thousands of pictures in order to make them into moving comics. Moving is used in two senses: the pictures actually move (animation), and they are surprisingly poignant. The comics that Winsor McCay makes are fantastic. Again, fantastic in two senses: They're weird, magical, and are fantasy. They're also funny and wonderful. This was the only short I watched twice. It was just so great to see the rigorous process of drawing a cartoon film by hand. A sort of educational film, catapulted into awesomeness through the light touch of the (in two senses) moving comic.

Hurray for Winsor McCay My Grade: 10/10
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Dynamite Performance
Prof_Lostiswitz10 September 2002
This is a really ingenious combination of vaudeville and cartoons. It starts with Winsor McKay making a bet that he can produce a moving picture within a month; then we see him loading up with giant barrels of ink, boxcarloads of paper etc., the whole slapstick routine. At the end, we see his drawings gradually come to life and we get a genuine little animated cartoon. Anybody who enjoys a good laugh will get a kick out of this one; it's a surprise to see that cartooning could be so sophisticated in 1911.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Impressive even now, for all the progress made since its creation
llltdesq29 November 2002
Watching this short, it is still quite fascinating to see what Windsor McCay was able to do almost one hundred years ago. The action is still quite good and it entertains even without a story line. The "plot" is that McCay is going to make a cartoon-drawings that move. The animated short had its beginnings in the work of Windsor McCay and others. McCay's work of course is of historical importance, to be sure. But most of what I've seen holds up well today, particularly bearing in mind when it was made. Worth watching. Recommended.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Back when Nemo still was an actual clown
Horst_In_Translation12 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
and not a fish. This is a 7-minute black-and-white short film from over 100 years ago and it features Winsor McCay in front of and also behind the camera. His approach to film was a mix of live action and animation. However, everything that worked so well in his film about Gertie stays pretty uninteresting here. Nemo does not get a proper introduction and thus stays fairly uninteresting for the entire film and the live action story is also fairly random and forgettable. I certainly did not enjoy this one as much as I hoped I would. It feels like a raw unfinished version of Gertie without the heart and with another lead character. Still the good thing about this one here is perfect evidence of how McCay steadily improved over the next years. Sadly I cannot recommend his take on Nemo.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting & Creative
Snow Leopard6 December 2002
This is an interesting and creative little feature showcasing the work of animation pioneer Winsor McCay. There is a mini-plot built around McCay and his drawings, and the story is itself good for a couple of smiles, but the real highlight is in the animation displays themselves. There's no telling how fascinating this must have been to its original audience, and it is still entertaining to watch as you see the way that his ideas come together. All in all, this is an interesting historical curio that is definitely worth seeing.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Breathtaking...
Musidora19 June 2004
Suddenly seeing Little Nemo and his friends from Slumberland come alive took my breath away and almost brought a tear to my eye. This is pure cinematic magic: ingenuous, fantastic, and charming. Like peeping into a world of harmless ghosts and fairies.

As someone else has pointed out in this forum, the action of LITTLE NEMO unfolds unrestricted by narrative conventions. Nemo and Flip stretch as if they're waking, and for a viewer today, that's where the marvel is. Nemo wakes in 1911 into the world of moving, hand drawn pictures and, after so many years of neglect, he wakes, again, for us.

Well, I could just go on for days expressing my enchantment with this jewel from the past.

Musidora
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This short of McCay's animation beginning is essential
tavm4 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
If there was a very good reason Winsor McCay was considered the father of animation, watching this, his first animation test, and a humorous recreation of events that made this happen should clue you in why. As the film begins in live action, McCay is at a table with fellow cartoonist George McManus, film comic John Bunny and a few others telling them his plans to make drawings move. Fascinated, they agree to see the results a month later. In between, there's a humorous scene of deliverymen bringing tons of ink barrels and boxes of paper to his office. Then at his desk with piles of paper stacked high up, a curious onlooker keeps coming in and browsing around resulting in many of those stacks to fall down. Nevertheless, at the exhibit we become fascinated as McCay's comic strip character, Nemo, and his supporting cast start elongating their bodies in various shapes while standing still. Nemo then draws a princess who comes alive as a dragon passes them by. He stops with his mouth open as Nemo and the princess ride on his tongue seat as they wave goodbye and the dragon turns his back on us. Then we see a couple of Nemo's buddies riding in a car with the word "honk" on each door. Then as the car also turns back at us, it explodes, the end. And all this was done in awesome hand-painted color! McCay truly fascinates with his painstaking eye for detail and movement in this experimental film. So for anyone who really is fascinated by animation history, this short is essential viewing.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Marvelous!
jluis198427 July 2007
While better known for his enormous influence in the history of comic strips and comics in general, the now legendary American artist Winsor McCay also played an important role in the development of animated films in the U.S. when he began to put his talents in animated movies, creating classics such as 1914's "Gertie the Dinosaur", where he interacted with his animated dinosaur in ways that precede what Walt Disney would do decades later in "Song of the South" and "Who Framed Roger Rabbit". Winsor McCay's first encounter with the movie industry happened in 1906, when his comic strip "Dream of a Rarebit Fiend" was adapted to screen by Wallace McCutcheon and Edwin S. Porter. Fascinated with cinema, McCay produced his first movie in 1911, the autobiographical short film titled "Winsor McCay, the Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and His Moving Comics", the movie that would contain his first 2 minutes of animated work.

In many ways, it could be said that "Winsor McCay and His Moving Comics" is a short biopic about McCay's decision to enter the field of animated films. The movie begins with McCay (playing himself) debating with a group of friends and colleagues (John Bunny and George McManus among them) about the possibility of using cinema to create animated movies. McCay explains them the process and his ideas to make it work in a way that the drawings move realistically. To his surprise, his friends laugh at the idea, thinking it's too laborious and complicated to create enough drawings to animate a cartoon the way McCay wants it. However, this only makes McCay more determined to prove he is right, so he bets that he can do a short film in a month. At Vitagraph studios, McCay works without rest, creating the four thousand drawings that will give life to his most famous creation: Little Nemo.

Written by Winsor McCay himself, the frame story for this wonderful "Little Nemo" animation is loosely based on McCay's real experiences with animation. While of course the plot about the bet is an exaggeration, McCay did face a certain degree of skepticism about the way he was planning to animate his drawings. It's not that animated films were new at the time, but the kind of movies McCay wanted to make were considered too difficult to create. In fact, even when McCay does joke about the amount of ink and paper used to make the animation, he really had to draw a lot to create the marvelous 2 minutes that make the last segment. Like in his comic strips, the "little Nemo" animation is a surrealist marvel in which McCay makes a brief introduction of his popular characters: Nemo, the Princess, the Imp, and of course, Flip.

While the animation segment was of course McCay's creation, the frame story was directed by J. Stuart Blackton, former employee of the Edison Production Company who in those years was one of Vitagraph's top directors. Knowing that the movie's highlight was the animation at the end, Blackton keeps a restrained style through his movie, although this doesn't mean he refuses to have fun, as he adds clever visual gags that keep the viewer's attention as McCay's story is told. His handling of the cast is also very good, although the credit for the film's natural and realistic performances must definitely go to legendary comedian John Bunny, who plays himself as a friend of McCay, and together with writer George McManus are McCay's main costars. Bunny's aid was certainly instrumental in helping McCay and McManus to look believable.

Now, as written above, McCay's animated segment is simply a masterpiece of animation, as he achieves a level of detail in his drawings that still few animators attempt to achieve. As in his comic strips, his use of perspective is remarkable, and the fact that here we see it animated just feels as if his drawings were alive. While short, 2 minutes are enough to present his characters, and he offers a small glimpse of what "Little Nemo" is about: a magical fantasy where like in dreams, everything is possible. A great detail about the animation is the fact that the same drawings he made during the frame story are the ones that eventually end up in his animation, enhancing this feeling of drawings coming alive by the magic of cinema. Even now it is truly a fascinating work of art.

"Winsor McCay, the Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and His Moving Comics" is an amazing mix of biopic, documentary and animation that definitely is an obligatory viewing for everyone interested in the history of animated films. It is truly amazing how more than 90 years after it was made the movie still looks beautiful and impressive. No wonder why Walt Dinsey liked McCay's work so much that it inspired him to make animations. It is truly a film that must be seen to be believed. 9/10
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
There at the Beginning
Hitchcoc23 April 2019
This is a breakthrough film. It deals with the skeptics and the naysayers who get in the way of progress. Little Nemo was already a familiar character, but giving him life in the face of doubt was a great accomplishment. This is a very entertaining ten minutes and it shows the incredible work that would ensue when it came to putting animation before the public.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Magnificent animation and drawing
Lirazel6 July 1999
In the world of comic strips, Winsor McKay was easily one of the greatest artists of all time..and as an animator, his work is comparable. He was firmly convinced that he invented the animated cartoon, and although this is not the case, his work does stand alone. Take a good look at the work he did on the Lusitania sequence, and you will find that only the Fleischer Bros. Superman cartoons approach the realism in illustration, the light simulation, and the smooth, full animation. Also, you get a chance to see George McManus, creator of the "Bringing up Father" strip and a fantastic artist himself. If animation is your metier, it's required viewing..brilliant clear through.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
We Dare You, McCay!
redryan644 August 2014
Warning: Spoilers
ALTHOUGH THIS SHORT film is well known in the annals of the animated cartoon, much of it is live action. Featuired in the non-animated portions of the film are the cartoonist/creator Mr. Windsor McCay (himself), the famous George McManus (writer/illustrator of Maggie & Jiggs in BRING UP FATHER) and John Bunny (stage Actor and the first film comedy star).

THESE ABOVE MENTIONED men, along with some others, are present to set up the dare or bet made by McCay with McManus, Bunny & Company, that he could in one month deliver 4,000 drawings; to be used in creating an animated cartoon by the Vitagraph Film Company.

BEING THE PRE-EMINENT cartoonist/draftsman that he truly was, Mr. McCay is portrayed busy in his studio; which is set up in much the same mode of a cartoon panel. Huge boxes and containers are delivered and artistically placed around and about the room.

TRUE TO HIS word, Windsor delivers the goods on time and under budget. The fine, hand coloured images of Little Nemo and two or three other characters follow.

THE NUMBER OF 4,000 drawings is no case of runaway hyperbole; as the artist did at least that number of full page illustrations. We must realize that this was prior to the use of background paintings, with the characters being drawn on a clear plastic cell. Everything, be they background or character, had to be redrawn in every page.

IN ADDITION TO the live action sequence's being an introduction and set-up for the later animation, the scenes featuring McCay, McManus, Bunny and the others had a connection to reality. Some have said that it was this sort of friendly ribbing each other and even, perhaps some wagering that led to the dare.

IT WAS ALSO an opportunity for the cartoonists to ham it up on the screen and be seen by their adoring public.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Movies Begin
Michael_Elliott11 March 2008
Winsor McCay, the Famous Cartoonist of the N.Y. Herald and His Moving Comics (1911)

*** (out of 4)

This first Winsor McCay film is certainly more interesting for its historic purpose than pure entertainment but film buffs will certainly want to check it out. The film opens up in live animation as McCay is in a club with his rich friends who laugh at the idea of his drawings coming to life. McCay goes away to his studio and comes back a month later to win his bet that his Little Nemo character could actually move like a real person. This film actually works as both a documentary as well as an animation piece. The documentary point works well because it allows us to see McCay doing some of his drawings and it gives you a nice idea of his drawing style. The animation bits are truly magical once they happen and it really makes you wonder how impressive they must have been in 1911. The best way to describe them is to compare them with the SeptaTone to color in THE WIZARD OF OZ. Once the animation jumps off the screen it just brings a real freshness to the material and it hasn't dated one bit.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting animation
Tornado_Sam18 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The version I saw of this is 7 minutes, and rendered in Black & White. The film is interesting, and the animation done well. McCay's talent is clearly demonstrated, and while there is a story it sets up the animation which comes later.

The story begins with Winsor McCay making a bet with his friends that maybe he could make his cartoons move. They laugh at him, and to demonstrate his talent Mr. McCay draws some figures for us. A month later he shows his friends what he has accomplished, which is when the animation makes its way into the film. It is a simple story, but is well done and is overall worth seeing.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
it was very good
rrclsk15 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Winsor Zenic McCay was born in Spring Lake, Michigan, on 26 September 1869 (this date, found on his tombstone, is debated—his New York Times obituary states 1871).[1] He was the son of Robert McKay (later changed to McCay) and Janet Murray McKay; Robert at various times worked as a teamster, a grocer, and a real estate agent. Winsor's exact place and year of birth are uncertain — he claimed to have been born in Spring Lake, Michigan in 1871, but his gravestone says 1869, and census reports state that he was born in Canada in 1867. He was originally named Zenas Winsor McKay, in honor of his father's employer, Zenas G. Winsor. He later dropped the name Zenas.

In 1886, McCay's parents sent him to Cleary's Business College in Ypsilanti, Michigan to learn to be a businessman. While in Ypsilanti, he also received his only formal art training, from John Goodison of Michigan State Normal College (now known as Eastern Michigan University). Goodison taught him the strict application of the fundamentals of perspective, which he put to significant use later in his career.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
charming little cartoon
didi-523 April 2004
Winsor McCay says to an incredulous John Bunny (the jovial comedy Vitagraph star) he will use four thousand drawings for a moving cartoon, and we see some of this process through the live action bit of this short: the best of course is the sequence where we watch the animated characters take on their own personalities, in turn disturbing, hilarious, poignant, and boisterous.

There have of course been many advances in animation over the years, but we can also learn from and appreciate what has gone before. If you only know 'Gertie the Dinosaur' you'll like 'Little Nemo'; if you're not familiar with McCay but like animation, give it a go. I reckon you'll be surprised how far techniques had progressed even ninety-plus years ago.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed