There are few horror movie villains more memorable than the unhinged, chaotic, and oddly charming Stu Macher from Scream. Matthew Lillard’s portrayal of the knife-wielding goofball-turned-killer made him a fan favorite, even though he met a very definitive end in the 1996 classic.

With Scream 7 on the horizon, rumors are swirling that Lillard might be making a return, despite the fact that Stu was, you know, very dead. But let’s be real, death has never been a dealbreaker in horror movies, especially in the Scream universe, where meta-madness reigns supreme.

Matthew Lillard as Stu Macher in Scream | Credits: Dimension Films

So, could Stu actually return? And if he does, how could it possibly make sense? Well, it would definitely be wild, but fans found four ways that a Stu comeback could actually work, even if they’re completely ridiculous. Buckle up, Scream fans, because we’re diving into some seriously bonkers territory.