Sam was very obviously in the right yet Carly acted like a brat about it the entire time and then cries when Sam doesn't take her to a concert that she said she didn't want to go to. This episode was so annoying and hard to watch. Also, the Spencer story was so annoying and obnoxious. Unironically one of the worst episodes of tv I've ever seen.
3 Reviews
Total failure
codyspeaks19 August 2009
I hated this episode so much. It was so childish. On the fifth anniversary of their friendship, Carly makes an iCarly t-shirt and gives it to Sam as a gift. Sam trades the shirt for tickets to Carly's favorite band. Carly gets mad about it and her and Sam get into a fight with each other. They stop going on iCarly with each other. During one of their web-casts, Freddie gets the viewers of iCarly to vote on which one of them is right. This episode was so stupid. Carly and Sam got into a fight about something that wasn't a big deal. And besides, Carly could have just made another shirt that she could give to Sam. The humor in this episode was annoying. This is definitely not an episode that any iCarly fan should see.
Why did you care when Sam was crying?
bluedivadesi30 January 2023
Carly why do you care that Sam was crying after you 2 were mad at each other, you were not crying when you pulled each other's ponytails on icarly web show. I want Carly to cry as well and why don't you blame nevel for all of this you should not be mad at each other, try being mad at nevel. Nevel made you do this. Carly tell Sam to stop that crying because you are mad at her you should be mad at Sam for crying after the angry web show. You should pull pigtails not ponytails. Maybe you should blame nevel and not each other. I want to see tears in both of your eyes when you pulled each other pigtails and both cry not just Sam.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
