"Wanted: Dead or Alive" Passing of Shawnee Bill (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Double Crossed for an Admirable Cause
GaryPeterson6712 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Another excellent episode, due in large part--pun intended--to Alan Hale Jr. as Bill Poe aka Shawnee Bill. While this side of the 1960s we see Hale as the Skipper on GILLIGAN'S ISLAND, to 1958 audiences Hale was just coming off his one-season series CASEY JONES and was primarily a Western star. He plays the part well in his corduroy jacket, handlebar mustache, and authentic beard stubble.

Minus the minor roles played by the poker player, bartender, and sheriff in Trinidad, this is a taut three-man story featuring Randall, Poe, and Galt. Poe dominates the story, and deserves credit for pulling a successful con job on Josh--no mean feat.

Double crosses and cons play a big role here. Shawnee Bill cons Josh into advancing half the reward money, then later Josh cons Galt by using Bill's corpse strapped to the horse as a distraction. I was surprised Josh shot Galt in the back, but perhaps he felt he had no choice with so skilled a gunman. The surprising conclusion finds Josh learning just how outsmarted he was, losing the reward money plus thousand dollars, though earning the town's gratitude and helping support a five-year-old orphan. Small consolation, it seems, as Josh rips up the wanted poster with resignation.

If only Shawnee Bill had shared the full story of his family's woes with Josh instead of trying to trick him, the results may have been less tragic. But such soul-baring was not standard operating procedure in the Old West.

Incidentally, Poe implied Josh cheated in that poker game, having three kings up his sleeve. Josh never denied it. Perhaps Josh was originally envisioned as a card sharp a la Bret Maverick?

Galt, the half-Indian tracker who dogs Josh and Bill was played by Lewis Charles, who I initially mistook for Gerald Mohr, knowing Mohr would be turning up in an episode. Charles was good as Galt, having that hardbitten, trail-wearied look to him. John Galt was the protagonist of Ayn Rand's 1957 bestselling philosophical novel "Atlas Shrugged," and I wondered if that was the source of the name (though the pocket Galt had Josh and Bill holed up in fell far short of Galt's Gultch!).

This would be Hale's sole appearance on WANTED: DEAD OR ALIVE, which is a shame since he and McQueen enjoyed an appealing chemistry. Hale's calm and cool nature contrasted nicely with Randall's intensity, especially evident in the scene where Poe watches the stagecoach pull away and declares the game over. Lewis Charles will turn up a couple more times as will David Lang as scripter. The series achieved liftoff from its opening episode and was soaring to great heights even this early in the first season, with this and the next episode providing proof positive.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Skipper Gets What He Deserves
Johnny_West26 December 2023
The Skipper (Alan Hale, Jr.) from Gilligan's Island cons Josh Randall into a really dumb deal. Randall agrees to pay the Skipper half the bounty for wanted man named Shawnee Bill. Randall should have gotten suspicious when he read the poster and it described somebody fitting the description of the Skipper.

After the Skipper cons the money out of Randall, he puts it on the Pony Express to his wife, and then laughs at Randall and tells him "he is a big boy" and to pound sand.

Randall should have taken the Skipper out of town and blasted a giant hole in his guts and taken the dead body to any of his sheriff friends to sign an affidavit that he killed Shawnee Bill, and collect the bounty. That would have been better than to listen to annoying Skipper tell him how he would never get him back alive.

Unfortunately, we get to spend a whole episode with Alan Hale, Jr. Trying to "Little Buddy" Steve McQueen. The good part of this is that you get to watch the Skipper roll down a hill with a bullet in his guts, and the other bad guy gets some too.

Thanks to the writers' wanting an ironic ending, Randall gets the body to Skipper's home town, and finds out that he is a local hero, and sent $1000 to his sick wife, who happened to die the day before. So the money goes to their orphan daughter, and Randall got robbed by a dead Skipper.

If Randall had tried collecting by affidavit from another sheriff, and buried Skipper in some random town, he would have gotten his $2000 reward. One of those episodes where the writers wanted to show how Randall tried to be a nice guy and got screwed (but only because he was not smart about it).
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed