6/10
A bit over rated
18 March 2007
A bit over rated, this one, I think. It certainly takes a while to get going, is a bit sentimental and has plenty of plot holes. However, this is an early noir and being of lasting influence was certainly one of Mr Lang's traits.

Some of the shots are as stunning as they are surprising and things are not overly explained, it's just that some stretches seem a little flat. Whilst I can see much of the early scenes are to make the later consequences more poignant but seventy years on these can appear ponderous.

Take nothing away for the last twenty minutes or so, though, plus the superb and heavily ironic prison yard scene.
10 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed