Review of Stardust

Stardust (1974)
7/10
Memorable but flawed
20 September 2004
I managed to catch this on TV again recently, having not seen it for many years.

Rather surprisingly it doesn't look particularly dated, and the storyline still packs a punch. Both David Essex and Adam Faith are good in their roles, and there's never a dull moment on screen. But whatever happened to Ines des Longchamps who played Jim's girlfriend? (Not much, according to the IMDb!)

Two very big flaws however stand out on this viewing.

Firstly, the songs which apparently sold millions for Jim Maclaine and the Stray Cats just aren't very good or very memorable. The story is obviously based on the Beatles' rise to fame, and for them as well as for every other pop group of the day, it wasn't just a pretty face but catchy, hummable songs that took them to the heights. Jim's are either covers or very weak.

And as someone has already mentioned, the crowds at the 'Pollwinners concert' clearly weren't 1960s young people. Obviously the filmmakers just rounded up a crowd when they made the film in 1974 and got them to come and see David Essex. Presumably it would have been far too expensive to dress them in the fashions of a decade before.

These two flaws apart, it's a good film, if not your standard popcorn-munching Saturday night fare.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed