I really don't know what to score this series as i've never been so hooked and so disinterested in any show. The premise is based on the real life case of the watcher (including some of the key case details) where a family moves in to a home and starts receiving threatening letters and this is basically a series of them trying to find out who 'the watcher' is (along with some other largely inconsequential side stories).
The show reminds me so much of the first season of AHS (albeit a much less graphic version) from the neighbour who seemingly has access to the house, to the random characters who suddenly appear and you only find out the details about them after, to the ending 'scares'. This perhaps shouldn't be that surprising considering Ryan Murphy's involvement in both but it does feel like lazy writing to have such obvious similarities and my opinion on this is largely the same as with my opinion on all the AHS series i've seen, the first few episodes draw you in, then you get some filler episodes to bulk it out and the ending feels a little anti-climatic.
The show did have me hooked as i was curious as to who was sending the letters and they definitely do a good job at making the other characters as creepy and as suspect as possible. I loved the private detective character and she was key in keeping the story moving at a good pace initially. Although i have to say i found it less intriguing as the story goes on (Episode 4 is basically the tipping point), the twists or 'reveals of evidence' become entirely predictable, the characters start to make more and more stupid, irrational decisions and on top of that the things that they do seem to just get forgotten by the next episode.
**Minor spoilers in this paragraph** One such example of how inconsequential everything is: (minor spoiler (not related to the main storyline): The daughter accuses her father of being racist online, this leads to him having a meeting with his boss and being shunned by the country club, but she apologises at some stage and all is seemingly forgotten (by everyone). Another (again minor spoiler) is when the wife finds out about a phone call having been made from inside the house, this is enough evidence to raise her suspicions of her husband but he never admits it was him and as such why does she seem to instantly forget about it (or was she fine with somebody random making calls from inside her house whilst she was away).
Ultimately it's okay and has some redeeming qualities but the ending is very unsatisfactory and without giving anything away does make you feel like you've wasted your time somewhat.
The show reminds me so much of the first season of AHS (albeit a much less graphic version) from the neighbour who seemingly has access to the house, to the random characters who suddenly appear and you only find out the details about them after, to the ending 'scares'. This perhaps shouldn't be that surprising considering Ryan Murphy's involvement in both but it does feel like lazy writing to have such obvious similarities and my opinion on this is largely the same as with my opinion on all the AHS series i've seen, the first few episodes draw you in, then you get some filler episodes to bulk it out and the ending feels a little anti-climatic.
The show did have me hooked as i was curious as to who was sending the letters and they definitely do a good job at making the other characters as creepy and as suspect as possible. I loved the private detective character and she was key in keeping the story moving at a good pace initially. Although i have to say i found it less intriguing as the story goes on (Episode 4 is basically the tipping point), the twists or 'reveals of evidence' become entirely predictable, the characters start to make more and more stupid, irrational decisions and on top of that the things that they do seem to just get forgotten by the next episode.
**Minor spoilers in this paragraph** One such example of how inconsequential everything is: (minor spoiler (not related to the main storyline): The daughter accuses her father of being racist online, this leads to him having a meeting with his boss and being shunned by the country club, but she apologises at some stage and all is seemingly forgotten (by everyone). Another (again minor spoiler) is when the wife finds out about a phone call having been made from inside the house, this is enough evidence to raise her suspicions of her husband but he never admits it was him and as such why does she seem to instantly forget about it (or was she fine with somebody random making calls from inside her house whilst she was away).
Ultimately it's okay and has some redeeming qualities but the ending is very unsatisfactory and without giving anything away does make you feel like you've wasted your time somewhat.
Tell Your Friends