"McDonald & Dodds" The Fall of the House of Crockett (TV Episode 2020) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An enjoyable light-hearted murder mystery
Tweekums2 March 2020
This the first instalment in a new ITV murder mystery series opens with a man being fatally shot in a large house in the City of Bath. The next morning a man, Max Crockett, and his pregnant wife return home and discover the body. He is dressed very similarly to the dead man; as he gets his wife to call the police he sets about making it look as if somebody broke into the house through a rear door. He also disposes of the man's phone and takes a valuable item from the house to suggest a robbery.

Investigating the case are DCI Lauren McDonald, a high flier who has just transferred from London, and DS Dodds, an officer who hasn't worked a case in over ten years whose superiors are hoping can be pushed out of the force. Our duo soon start to believe the answer lies within the Crockett family but Max is a leading local entrepreneur with powerful contacts who urge other lines of enquiry.

This is a by the numbers murder mystery; we have a mismatched pair of detectives, an attractive location, an obviously suspicious character with an alibi and a number of suspects. As such it doesn't immediately stand out in a crowded field but if you enjoy the genre it is worth watching. The two leads are solid, although at this stage it is Dodds who is the more interesting. The central mystery was interesting; we may know that Max Crockett is doing things to sabotage the police enquiry but his motives aren't obvious for some time. There are slight echoes of 'King Lear' as he plans to give his business to one of his three daughters but won't initially say which leading to some family tension. The final revelation is perhaps a little far-fetched but not too much for a light-hearted mystery. A minor gripe is that the murder weapon is a Colt 1911 pistol, it is suggested that this could be a stolen army weapon; the British Army never used that model they use 9mm Browning Hi-Powers. The cast is solid; Jason Watkins stands out as the understated DS Dodds; Tala Gouveia is good as McDonald, a character who is initially a bit irritating and Robert Lindsay is fun as Max Crockett. Overall I enjoyed this and will certainly watch the next episode; whether it will grow to be an ongoing series remains to be seen.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Disappointing
Vindelander9 April 2020
Despite a good cast in theory with Robert Lindsay and Jason Watkins it's rather a let down. Poor plot and hammy acting but at least the backdrop of Bath as the filming location was a plus.

Rather like a poor episode of Midsomer Murders I'm afraid.
10 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Such a disappointment!
philpotts-612352 March 2020
Thank God for Jason Watkins, who I have admired for 29 years. His was, by far, the only decent performance in this disappointing opener. Bath is a beautifully City and looks fabulous. The remainder of this abysmal production was a tragedy. Including Lindsay's performance.
8 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Light hearted detective show
recurvata29 September 2020
Reviewing first episode here. Basically a semi-humorous murder take on King Lear, I'm a Yank, so maybe it's even more humorous for Brits. Some of the humor is pretty dry. Show was a bit uneven in the rhythm between serious and comic, but still entertaining. Breaks no new grounds, needs to find its feet, But overall, a pleasant way to while away an hour.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good entertainment
blueandwhite112 March 2020
Excellent light entertainment with great interaction between two very different detectives with an element ofColumbo thrown into the mix. A nice amount of humour plus a plot to easily follow. Beautifully filmed in Bath Expected a two hour show to be too long but wasn't Looking forward to episode 2 ( unfortunately of two)
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lovely Sunday Evening viewing.
martin-6283 March 2020
Light, gentle, amusing crime programme. The two leads promise an entertaining relationship. It is the sort of entertainment that has been missing from our screens for a while. It makes a pleasant change from the gritty, sinister, sordid dramas which have become fashionable lately.
16 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
King Lear was never this contrived!
DoctorStrabismus21 September 2022
It's the King Lear set-up. Wealthy, powerful man has three daughters, two of them horrible grasping individuals, who are desperate for his inheritance, and one a kind, sweet person, who is not. Megan is obviously Regan, and which ones are Goneril and Cordelia is not too hard to figure. But then, despite a fair smattering of genuine Shakespearean actors, it all goes so badly wrong.

A murder mystery is supposed to be just that, with the least likely person often turning out to be the eventual culprit, and that's OK. But we had a storyline in which the murder plot was so contrived, so unlikely, so utterly dependent upon precise timing and coincidence, that it left a "What on Earth!" response, with a hollow feeling at the end. Maybe this is because we all want to do our own sleuthing and try and figure out the clues, but in this one you would have needed a crystal ball to do so.

The characterisations were good, and the development of the completely unlikely detective partnership was genuinely intriguing, but of course they simply had to throw in that terrible old worn cliché of the Chief Superintendent being a complete arrogant fool. He was more concerned about not upsetting the rich and powerful of the city than about solving the murder.

For a series pilot, it did enough to make us want to watch the next episode, and so a slightly generous 7/10.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good start
evans-154755 August 2022
Amazing 1st episode the 2 stars seem so comfortable with each other and had instant chemistry and with these shows that is the most important element,the plot was a little stretched but the stars kept you interested.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lightweight entertainment
musickrev19 August 2021
Having moved forward with other episodes in this show, I can look back on this uncertain beginning and say enjoy this but don't go any further. The plot is pretty ludicrous but actually put together with some aplomb here, something that cannot be said for subsequent episodes. It's a shame, really, there is potential that doesn't pan out, not least because the stereotypical portrayals that can just about be borne for a single episode become unsustainable over the series. I like the lead actors and it's clear they are working hard but you can only go so far with indifferent writing and direction. I would call this a missed opportunity.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great start
rondroz24 September 2020
What's not to like. Cast,script,music and production values top notch. Let's have many more episodes.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Confection perfection
lisbethinsydney27 August 2023
Borrowing from King Lear for its first plot, McDonald & Dodds aims high and sails through to the denouement with flying colours.

In introducing the title characters, we see the no-nonsense McDonald's respect for her nondescript partner go from a shaky 1 to a begrudging 100 while Dodds is shaken awake by the whirlwind pace to find his new operational role in "this detectivey stuff".

Highlights include McDonald's meltdown in the library - Dodds's second home ; her gale-force takedown of the killer and Dodds's instinctual suspicion early on of the family patriarch, played with crafty gusto by Robert Lindsay.

The script fizzes and sparkles as South London meets the city state of Bath. The Mozartian orchestral music comments delightfully on the action. The casting is superb. We're in heaven.

This is my favourite episode by far and sets a high bar for the series to follow. Maybe the creators need to watch it again to get this refreshing series back on track.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The fall of Sunday night quality drama.
Sleepin_Dragon1 March 2020
After last week's glorious, exquisite episode of Endeavour, ITV give us this. I really wanted to like it, and I genuinely went into it with an open mind, but this was disappointing.

If you're familiar with Shakespeare and Hathaway, imagine an episode of that, but thinly stretched over ninety minutes, and without any of the fun. This lacked grit, and any real sense of drama.

I didn't care for the main characters, maybe they'll get better in the next episode, there is mileage here, but this was hard work to watch. 4/10
13 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Mixed feelings.
worldwidewhere3 March 2020
Clumsy writing for a "who dun it". And an unrealistic portrayal of its location.

I'm from Bath and I didn't enjoy the affluent characters being well-spoken and the workers having a strong accent. How often does someone need to say "This is Bath"?

Hopefully the next instalment shows Larkhall, Snow Hill, Twerton, and Whiteway.
7 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The Fall of The House of Crockett
Prismark103 March 2020
The reasons I enjoy the BBC afternoon crime dramas are because they are stories told with great economy, fun and an easy watch. The BBC reached an agreement with Equity so that the actors get paid less than the going rate as long as the programs are shown on daytime with no primetime repeats.

McDonald & Dodds tries to catch that essence. You can tell from the music, it had some good shots of Bath but it is shown in primetime and the first episode had Robert Lindsay as the guest star who is not going to do it cheap.

Lindsay is entrepreneur Max Crockett who returns home with his pregnant wife and finds a dead man. While he sends his wife out to call the police, Max makes it look like a break in to steal a valuable statue.

Leading the investigation is a high flier from London, DCI Lauren McDonald (Tala Gouveia.) She is saddled with DS Dodds (Jason Watkins) who has been sat in an office for 11 years and his superior hope he can be shuffled out of the force.

Although Crockett's behaviour is suspicious he might not be the one who shot the man believed to be a homeless vagrant. However Crockett keeps changing the motive, a robbery gone wrong soon becomes himself as the intended target.

It is Dodds who finds things do not add up. He spots that it was raining outside but no wet footprints in the house. Crockett quickly realises that Dodds is no pushover.

This is Father Brown mixed with Shakespeare & Hathaway mixed with Colombo. In fact Lindsay plays Crockett like a typical villain from Colombo.

What let this down was that it was too darn long and there was a lack of chemistry between McDonald and Dodds. It also needed more humour.

Lindsay was outstanding, I would have loved to see him play Dodds. I particularly loved the way Crockett talks about his company being modern and diverse, yet under pressure he is reduced to thinly veiled racism towards McDonald.
6 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
'Disappointing and An Expected Clichè'
carmenjulianna31 October 2020
What a disappointing 1st episode of a 1st series. What has happened to credible actors these days? After the beginning of the opening credits, (especially with Robert Lyndsey) somehow, I believed we were in for a new mystery treat. What a croc... The character McDonald is so annoying and seems so out of touch and dis-connected. If the character Dodds had been paired with a more seasoned actor, it may have worked. A No to the n3xt episode. A thumbs down for this I'm afraid..👎
6 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Should be on at 2pm on a tuesday
piecottage1 March 2020
Heavily cliched and reeks of daytime fodder. Cast are wasted and direction totally lacks tone.
6 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What a cliché fest, avoid it.
pat-41510-218561 September 2021
OK, so every murder mystery has to have a mismatched pair of cops. One old, one young. Or one smart and the other kind of slow. Maybe one female and one male. Or black vs white. I know, lets have every one of these, a young aggressive city slicker black woman and an old passive rural hick white dude. Surely if we have every possible cliché at once, it will be better.

Clearly a filler, poorly written and over acted. At least the scenery and country house were pretty.
4 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed