Maigret (TV Series) The Mistake (1960) User Reviews

Excellent example of Maigret psychology

[Sir_Oblong_Fitzoblong · 9/10 · 26 February 2022]

One of the best. Excellent scripting and acting (mostly) in an episode which really plays to the strengths of studio-based drama by being a good play instead of trying and failing to be a TV event.

The episode consists of a simple plot and an examination of character and human nature by Maigret, including his own. This description doesn't make it sound up to much but the way the two are combined with Maigret's detective instincts (excellently played as ever) makes for a gripping story.

The one black mark is an instance of our old friend the am-dram hysterics at a key moment which is more than usually disappointing given the quality of the episode overall. Without this lapse I would have rated the episode a 10.

The Mistake

[Prismark10 · 6/10 · 5 March 2022]

A body of a young pregnant woman is discovered. She lived in an apartment owned by an eminent surgeon, Professor Gouin.

Gouin is a respectable married man. He is also a philanderer. He might had been the father of the child the dead woman was carrying.

A younger musician with a criminal record is also in the frame as a possible father.

Maigret needs to use psychology to draw out the real murderer. In the frame is Gouin's wife, sister in law and a female doctor who is in love with him.

Although Sgt Lucas is involved in a chase scene. This story involves a lot of talking and interrogating.

It is clear that some people adore Gouin, others despise him as cold aloof and narcissistic.

The episode is a bit of a slow burner but draws you in.