"Leave It to Beaver" Mistaken Identity (TV Episode 1961) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Beaver Cleaver and Dr. Stockmann: Enemies of the People
pensman12 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
If it isn't' Eddie and Lumpy trying to get Beaver into trouble, it's Beaver's own friends. Gilbert, Richard, and Beaver are trying to figure out what to do: "What do you want to do?" "I don't know, what do you want to do?" Richard suggests they go over to the old McMahon house, but Beaver begs off saying his father doesn't want him there. Ward has something to do too: he is now part of the mayor's committee for the new youth center.

Richard and Gilbert head over and start throwing rocks to break windows. When a cop comes by, he snags Richard who claims to be Theodore Cleaver. And you know where this is going. By-the-way, Wally wants to go on a cross country bus tour for the summer with Eddie (But this goes nowhere in this episode).

Here we go, the police, Lt. Barnes and Officer Medford, call Ward to ask if they can come over. Ward figures it's because of committee work, but it's to report the Beaver for vandalism. It's a good thing the arresting officer is coming over, but Beaver might be in a tight spot: should he tell them his friends had claimed they were heading to the house? Beaver is looking forward to seeing the policemen in the house as a sort of adventure. So is Ward, until the shoe drops. Ward is visually stunned at the news. When he is called to come downstairs, Beaver still thinks he is being rewarded, maybe he won something. Now it's serious. Of course, the officer knows Beaver isn't the boy, but does Beaver know who it was? Beaver doesn't want to implicate anyone; but again upstairs and while talking to Wally, Beaver figures out who did it and has a plan. If Richard (Beaver's choice) see Beaver at school and says sorry, then OK; but if he says, what's new, he will sock him.

But in a discussion with Ward, with Wally on the sidelines, Beaver let's his opinion out. Wally says Beaver had no choice, he couldn't let a guy get away with stuff like that. Richard apologies and is just worried if they will still be friends. Beaver say's yes but points out Richard acting like a rat. And as we close, the boys are back asking: "What do you want to do?" "I don't know, what do you want to do?" And the childhood universe is back to normal.

Again, a very relevant episode as many struggle with the issue of reporting someone they know. At work, it might ostracize you as a whistle blower. In other contexts of fear and retribution, it's "snitches get stitches." In politics, you might be a "leaker." We all know someone who did wrong; but even today, we are unwilling to stand up. Even today, a real dilemma.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Shades of Real Life
ziklag199020 December 2019
This is a typically funny, relatable and semi-serious Beaver episode. What jolted me, watching it this morning before work, is the part where Richard can so easily set up someone else by giving their name. This isn't just TV sitcom stuff; a former acquaintance of mine who was continually messing up black sheep of his family (and had no ID) gave his upright, white sheep brother's (living in another state) name/info whenever he was picked up for drunk in public, petty theft, etc--and no, no one checks at that level of "criminality". It all came up when his Good Brother applied for a high-level job with a gov't agency and was turned down because of "his" record. Even when he proved it wasn't him but his awful brother, he was re-turned down for the job because the agency didn't want an employee with that kind of family drama.

Just an anecdote. Take it as you will.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"Leave It to Beaver" Meets "Dragnet"
In this memorable episode, Richard Rickover frames Beaver for a crime. Richard and Gilbert both amuse themselves of an afternoon by throwing rocks at the windows of the old MacMahon House, an abandoned Victorian monstrosity in the neighborhood. A police officer chases them, but Gilbert gets away and a panicked Richard gives the officer the name of Theodore Cleaver instead of his own.

Ironically, Ward has been serving on a committee to build a youth center for Mayfield, one of the goals of which is to keep kids from roaming the streets! Ward finds himself in an awkward position when the very police lieutenant he had met with on the committee earlier in the day visits his home inquiring about his boy Theodore, who was caught breaking windows!

Now, Beaver is always soft-hearted and reluctant to "squeal" on his pals, even when they get him into deep trouble. This holds true here, but Ward has a typical conversation with Beaver in which he invites him to analyze the situation and determine the right course of action.

The two officers look and sound like they stepped off the set of DRAGNET (says Wally, "I've seen enough television to know a pair of real police officers when I see them!"). The gravitas of their portrayals is enjoyable. It's notable how the men (Ward, the police lieutenant and another officer) rise when June enters the living room with a tray of coffee, after which June tells them "you may sit." A small detail perhaps, but typical of how LITB emphasized good manners and formal behavior.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
THE BROKEN WINDOW SCANDAL!
tcchelsey22 February 2024
How many of us had friends who "borrowed' our name in unpleasant situations? Great episode centered around Beave and his part-time pals Gilbert and Richard, who one fine day start throwing rocks at an old, abandoned house. A window is broken --the cops arrive! --Gilbert manages to get away, BUT Gilbert is caught and promptly gives Beaver's name instead of his own. Not a candidate for friend of the month by a mile!

The story gets back to the Cleaver household, especially to Ward, who just happens to be on one of those honorable town committees that tv fathers seem to belong to. FORTUNATELY, things don't work out too well for Gilbert when the policeman discovers the old switch-a-roo! And Beave is off the hook.

Now it's up to Beaver to right another wrong.

An excellent character study, not all played for laughs, and with some very good acting. Alan Hewitt plays LT. Barnes, whose long career went back to the stage in the 30s, before working steadily in both movies and tv. This role, and a few others like it, may have lead to him being cast as nosey detective Brennan on MY FAVORITE MARTIAN, the copper we all loved to hate! Hewitt frequently appeared on PERRY MASON (generally seen on the witness stand) and ALFRED HITCHCOCK.

The old house in this episode is noneother than the famous MUNSTERS home, which turned up a lot in the background of many other tv shows and movies.

Must see TV. SEASON 4 EPISODE 28 remastered.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting start, then fizzles
vitoscotti24 June 2021
Not a lot of laughs. Beaver again taken advantage of by friend. Get to see the Munster home. Series misses Larry (Rusty Stevens), Mrs Mondello (Madge Blake).
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
With Friends Like Richard, Who Needs Enemies?
StrictlyConfidential21 November 2020
(*Beaver to June quote*) - "Gee, mom, we were proud of dad even when he wasn't anything."

Bored and restless, Gilbert and Richard are messing around the old McMahon house on Grant Avenue (which is supposed to be haunted).

Out of the blue Richard hurls a rock through one of the windows and then takes off in a run. Officer Medford sees this and he nabs Richard before he can get away.

Even though Richard lies (straight-faced) about his name and his address (he identifies himself as being Theodore Cleaver), everything turns out just fine when Officer Medford shows up at the Cleaver home that very evening.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Throw Away the Key
balldave18 November 2023
The soundtrack for Dragnet has a resounding Dum/Dee-Dum Dum inclusion in the theme. It fits well for this Dumb-Dee-Dumb Dumb episode. It takes two policemen to effectively terrorize a child by showing up his house over a broken window in an abandoned building??? Wards self congratulated demeanour throughout the story gets nauseating. He acts more childish than Beaver when the gendarmes come to the house. Leave it beaver, like no other show, bludgeons a topic to death..here it's more about 'the youth centre' than Beaver's possible misdemeanour. The Wally's Party episode is a case in point. The parent's obsession with party preparations is absurd..especially when Ward dismisses Beavers asking his father for help with "Not now Beaver..I need to talk to your mother about Wally's party!"
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed