"House M.D." Occam's Razor (TV Episode 2004) Poster

(TV Series)

(2004)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
"I'm Doctor Gregory House. You can call me Greg."
MaxBorg895 February 2010
After the pilot, this is the second episode of House directed by executive producer Bryan Singer, and it's easy to see why he chose to call the shots on this one: like the series premiere, Occam's Razor serves as a perfect introduction to the twisted world of Gregory House.

The diagnostics case of the week is that of a 16-year old boy (Kevin Zegers) whose unusually low blood pressure doesn't respond to IV fluids. While the team tries to figure out what's wrong with the boy, House also has to deal with clinic duties: patients include a woman whose leg hurts after running six miles ("Who knows? Could be anything.") and a boy who has used his MP3 player in a strange way.

Aside from the thrill of the medical/mystery blend (the solution is, as always, original and intriguing), this episode stands out because of its wonderful sense of humor: Chase, Foreman and Cameron casually chatting about sex after the patient's girlfriend suggests she might have, uh, done him to death, Wilson and House discussing the latter's "appealing" smugness (absolutely right) and, of course, the protagonist convincing several clinic patients they ought to wait for another doctor thanks to a wonderful monologue that begins with the apparently harmless "You can call me Greg.". In other words, 40 minutes of great television.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
House's interest to solve a case even when it is over
eunbi053030 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I remember when I first watched this episode, overall it is a good episode, but what makes it an even better episode is when House isn't satisfied with the solution he came up with and tries his previous theory going to the Hospital pharmacy and trying to find if the cough pill looks similar to the gout pill and we get to see both the patient and House find out that the former was indeed given the wrong medicine by the pharmacist and he got worst because of that and House was medically satisfied to know he was right all along.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Occam's Mislabled Medication
holy_big_sandwich23 January 2023
After a decent pilot and strong second episode, we get boy's internal organs falling apart after some heavy petting with his girlfriend.

The diagnosis goes back and forth, while House obsesses with the crux of mislabeled cough medicine. This is where Occam's Razor comes into play, instead of chasing every possible other infection or cause, House finds the simplest solution to be the cough medicine/lying patient. Nested in his own logos that everyone is lying all the time.

Overall decent episode in a very decent season 1.

House Quote: "You've got a hundred other idiot doctors in this building who go warm and fuzzy every time they pull a toy car out of a nose, you don't need me here."
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
excellent loved it so much.tried to explain it in words.
sbkosamiya9 April 2017
loved the way the mystery goes, the way it was presented, the cinematic experience, all the characters,involvement in last 15 minutes was really exciting,after all House is House, !!Occam's razor said that simplest explanation is the always true then the complex.yet this one is the rarest case.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
'Sex could kill you...It's violent. It's ugly. And it's messy. And, if God hadn't made it unbelievably fun, the human race would have died out eons ago.'
scorfield-5171111 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
With Bryan Singer back in the director's chair, our maverick MD is enticed by the case of a young male whose low blood pressure doesn't respond to treatment by IV fluids. What's more, the young college student is presenting with five other symptoms, amounting to a persistent cough, a rash, fever, nausea, and abdominal pains to add to low blood pressure, for which no one diagnosis will fit. In analysing with his team what could be the cause, House caustically berates Forman after slamming a heavy tome medical dictionary in front of him: ++"If you're going to list everything it is not, it might be much quicker to do it alphabetically'++ This precipitates a diagnostic 'joust' between the two characters which ultimately permits a solution to be found.

On a lighter, more uncomfortable note, this episode, if mirroring the style of 'Friends', would be entitled 'the one about sex'. The question of sex comes to the fore, as the patient and his college fiancé's strenuous sexual gymnastics open proceedings and end with the former's lack of response and apparent coma-like status. Later, Dr Chase ridicules the patient's girlfriend's concerns that she 'rode him to death', while Cameron acerbically and glibly challenges that Chase should have explored these claims more seriously. With his response of 'Have you ever taken a life?', we have the first frisson of sexual attraction between the two characters. This is also picked up by Foreman, who warns Chase of the pitfalls ahead of any relationship with a professional colleague.

In the continuing, secondary, light-hearted thread to each episode's storyline, House himself continues to seek any opportunity to distance himself from any direct clinical work and contact with patients. In this episode he brilliantly sets out to become wholly unapproachable by announcing to all the gathered patients: 'I'm Dr Gregory House; you can call me Greg. I'm one of three doctors staffing the clinic this morning. I am...the only doctor currently employed at this clinic who is forced to be here against his will...if you're particularly annoying, you may see me reach for this: this is Vicodin...i do not have a pain management problem. I have a pain problem. But, who knows. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe, I'm too stoned to tell.' Unsurprisingly, he has no takers, and all raise their hand when he asks if they would rather be seen by the other doctors. This sub-plot also contains its own cringe-worthy brush with sexual practices when House establishes that a young male patient's discomfort at sitting down is due to his having utilised his MP3 player for sexual gratification.

Once again series creator, Shore's storyline offers significant medical intrigue. After a course of antibiotics cause the patient's blood pressure to further decrease, his lungs to fill with fluid, and his creatinine levels to rise, a seventh symptom of kidney failure is added to the list. House posits a million to one possibility that our college student has had the misfortune of suffering from a combination of two conditions simultaneously. However, his suggested treatment then leads to the patient's immune system crashing.

Omar Epps was by far the most familiar name of those actors cast to portray our trio of interns, having made memorable performances alongside Tupac Shakur in 1991's 'Juice' and in John Singleton's 'Higher Learning' four years later. His casting as Dr Eric Foreman was the second occasion he would star in a notable medical drama, having appeared in Season 3 of the 'ER' as downtrodden Dr Dennis Gant. Here Epps' character is far more assured, arguing with his colleagues' unquestioning stance towards House's arguments. This is the first episode where Foreman's confidence to challenge House's opinions comes to the fore. As he puts it: 'So is that our job? House's puppet's. He comes up with an insane idea, we get to pretend it's not?' He even borders on suggesting the other two have a 'Stockholm Syndrome' reverence for their obstreperous lead.

For those of us who love House as a flawed anti-hero, one of the best scenes surrounds Wilson's sarcastic observation at how attractive a quality is House's smugness in informing Foreman that he knew they would be in the lab trying to prove his theory wrong, as opposed to observing the patient's condition, which had visibly improved, proving him right. House retorts: 'It was either that or get my hair highlighted. Smugness is easier to maintain.'

Yet, Foreman is ultimately proved right, having been the first to quote 'Occam's Razor' that the explanation most often correct is that which requires the fewest assumptions. A simple near-miss in House picking up the wrong phial of tablets from the hospital pharmacist leads to him solving the case. As House declares, seven thousand people a year die from pharmacy screw-ups, and here it appears the patient was wrongly given gout as opposed to cough medicine.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The show gets better and better with this episode sharp as a razor blade
Horst_In_Translation23 November 2023
Warning: Spoilers
"Occam's Razor" is the third episode of the first season from "House M. D." and this one runs for over 44 minutes, so it is one of the longest, even if they are all approximately this running time, but not all make it past 44 minutes. Anyway, I think the series started so well with the first two episodes, but this one here really took it to the next level or at least came really close to. It is the one where I first thought about giving it a perfect rating, but in the end it comes just a little short. One reason why I liked it so much was that it was maybe the first time where I enjoyed the dramatic story at the middle of the action more than then comedic inclusions linked to the not-so-sick people coming to get treated by Dr. House. Or rather here we really see through their reactions that they would have preferred to get treated by somebody else. We also get the thoughts again that a doctor without emotion who cures your loved one is better than a doctor who feels with and for you, but cannot cure said loved one. Sex is also a vital component in this episode or maybe calling it that would be too much, but it is a factor in this episode. Linked to the patient with how the episode starts but also two of the doctors. Or four even if we include House and Foreman who make one or two comments about what is going on between Chase and Cameron.

Anyway, this was an episode that I found really interesting from the medical perspective too, like the idea how a patient has so many symptoms that they cannot be explained through one illness alone. Or can they? House comes up with the explanation that if something like this happens, then somebody must have screwed up. Maybe more than one. He is not wrong there. The last shot may put a smile on your lips. Maybe it was funnier to me even because of how annoyed the hospital's pharmacist was there and also on previous occasion. The most dramatic moment was probably when the patients heart stops during an examination or maybe you can even call it a surgery. They dealt with this pretty quickly though I must say. Only a few minutes later they (or rather House) found the solution. Of course, you can wonder why the patients did not tell the doctors that he took drugs as it was a relevant aspect of course and he must have known that they would not be allowed to tell it his parents or so. Speaking of the parents, their reaction behind the (then) closed curtain, i.e. The mother's tearful breakdown, were also a bit on the heartbreaking side and added further emotion to the episode overall. We as viewers surely want to experience it while watching and we definitely do with this episode. This first season. This overall series. It was a bit interesting for me because I did not find the patient likable, so did not really care too much about him getting healthy. I rather cared for his parents and fiancée not feeling the pain of losing him I guess. And while this episode is such a success from the drama perspective, there are still moments that will make you smile, mostly resulting from House's brief comments. Like the one about Foreman's tie or what he has to say after Cameron's comment about how men should behave. I am not surprised to see Singer, who also directed the pilot episode, return here for this one after being absent for the second episode. Screenplay is of course once again by David Shore, Experts united. Oh and you will also get a nice video game recommendation if you watch this one. And you will see the stunning Alexis Thorpe. And you will learn what not to do with your MP3 player.

Back on the serious side again, there was also one moment during which Dr. Foreman described a medical process or something like that that was really haunting. I am not even sure why, but there was something different compared to what those moments were otherwise. Of course, at the same time, we once again saw what he was talking about like he usually does. During another scene, when House was thinking about what was wrong with the boy and staring at the sheet with the symptoms, we hear a nice little melody that was very catchy, even if it covered only a few seconds of silence before characters were talking again. So yeah, this episode really had it all. One of the very best from the entire series. I have to dig deep to find flaws with it. Maybe the sex parts did not interest me too much or the small cases this time or also the solution happens a bit too quickly in the end. Or maybe I am just saying this because I liked the episode so much that I wanted it to run a little longer. The good was so much more frequent, also Cuddy's sarcastic comment about House's disability or at the start House's initial reaction to Wilson telling him about boy's medical condition and how a lack of a reaction sparkles his interest. In any case, after writing all this, you won't be surprised that I give this episode a big thumbs-up and highly recommend the watch. The entire first season is pretty much something you don't want to miss out on. But this one here (1.3) is an even bigger standout. See it!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Occam's Razor
michaellaney1519 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
House and his team of doctors try to figure out what is causing a young college student's illness. They draw up all sorts of diagnoses and tests just to find out that the young college student was receiving gout medicine for his cough causing all sorts of complications. In this case the simplest explanation really was the best. This was a very interesting episode with a simple message; don't over analyze things too much.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The One With The College Student...
taylorkingston16 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
I liked this episode. It's not one of my all-time favorites, but it's a pretty good continuation, and a pretty good third episode.

In this episode, a college student comes in (after having sex) with low blood pressure, which doesn't respond to IV fluids. So of course, this is going to get Dr. House's attention, and interest. Meanwhile in the clinic, a woman doesn't believe her cold is gone, a man has a sore throat, and a woman whose leg hurts after running six miles. Of course it's going to be sore.

Best part of the episode: The clinic cases.

Worst part of the episode: Nothing in particular.

Diagnosis: The college boy was mistakenly given a gout medication for his original cough.

Overall, I give this episode a 6 out of 10, which in my ratings book is: Good.
1 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed