(2000–2001)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A clever parody
enochsneed17 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"We Are History" sets out to spoof both historical popularisers and the TV programmes they make.

In this case we are in the company of David Oxley (B.A.) who obviously fancies himself both as an intellectual and as a communicator. A real 'wannabe' who believes that programmes whose titles end in an exclamation mark are automatically dramatic and interesting, and that by bellowing at the camera he himself is dramatic and interesting. Unfortunately his limited knowledge undermines his intentions: finding a 'Greggs' bakery in modern day Pudding Lane in London he announces "Could this be the *very* bakery where the Great Fire of London actually started?!" (Enters shop, comes out 2 seconds later) "No! It couldn't! Because this shop has only been here for five years!" David is also big on re-enactments to show the 'relevance' of his subject matter. He stages a re-run of the Spanish Armada (the Spanish side wins) and the Fire of London (the fire-brigade has to be called).

If you don't know the originals this might appear very silly, but when you have heard a TV historian describe 9th Century Northumbria as "a sort of Dark Age Vietnam" (I never realised a Communist insurgency was responsible for the downfall of a Viking kingdom), it is pretty well on the money. Very nicely done indeed.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
History - the budget version
Svlad_Cjelli7 May 2004
I wasn't quite sure what to make of We Are History. First of all it is a take-off of the many UK history shows (you know, Elizabeth I, the wives of Henry VIII, that kind of thing). Second, well, the humour is a cross between absurdist and slapstick. Third, a key feature is the use of real life locations and volunteer participation by enthusiastic members of the public in recreations of famous historical events. The episodes are about 10 minutes long, and the history is the concise version with gags.

So does it work? When it works it works well, but when the jokes fail they fail dismally. As a distraction between main event programming the show works well, but I doubt it could be promoted by itself.

I recommend it to anyone with an insane sense of humour, or, alternately, anyone watching late-night weekend programming (that's when the show normal airs here on Australia's ABC) who's had a few drinks.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed