Till Human Voices Wake Us (2002) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
49 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Much to do about Nothing (But Beautiful)
dansview25 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
OK. It was a beautiful film. But holy jeez. It was so long, slow, and boring. I nearly went crazy.

They depicted a teen summer romance effectively, and also the aura of romance that permeates a teen life in a rural area. That was nice. Interestingly, the boy restrains himself from sexual advances. That's certainly unique for such a story.

But what the hell was wrong with the girls legs? Was it polio? So he takes her braces off and she is somehow treading water while holding his hand. Then she breaks away and drowns and he doesn't even notice or can't find her? What the hell? I guess they needed a talent like Pearce to convey the sadness of our protagonist with facial expressions. But that's pretty much all there was all film long. Sadness conveyed.

Cut it shorter, add a little more background and dialog, and ease up on the schmaltzy music.

Again, this was a visually beautiful film, but excruciating to get through.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A sad tale of lost love
MattyGibbs9 June 2013
I am a big fan of both Guy Pearce and Australian cinema so I was pleased to chance upon this film recently. Pearce plays a psychologist Dr Sam Franks who is haunted by a tragic past. A chance meeting with a stranger changes his life.

This a slow moving but engrossing story which flits back and forth from Sams childhood to the current day as we get to know what shaped him into a lonely and tortured soul. The film works equally well in both time periods as the pieces are put in place as it builds to an emotional ending.

The acting is excellent from all parties. I'm not Helena Bonham Carters biggest fan but she does a good job in this. Also impressive are the younger actors especially Lindley Joiner as the young Sam.

Till Human Voices Wake Us is a tragic tale of lost love and how this can deeply affect all of us. It won't appeal to everyone but for people who like well written drama this is well worth watching.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beautifully boring
=G=2 August 2003
"Till Human Voices Wake Us" tells two parallel stories at the same time, interleaving scenes. The first is of a man (Pearce) returning to his boyhood home in Australia to bury his father and, with the help of a mysterious woman (Bonham Carter), bittersweet memories of his childhood. The second story shows us the boy and the events which created the memories which haunt the man. Beautifully filmed but tediously told and wholly unsatisfying, this lovely bit of tripe treads the paranormal having left itself nowhere else to go. (C+)
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Beautiful, Beautiful Film
michlam11 September 2002
I am not one to write comments on films on many occasions but I recently saw this movie and it touched me so much that I felt compelled to comment on the film.

"Till Human Voices Wake Us" was beautiful in it's imagery and cinematography, music, acting and writing. It had so many themes which resonated with me on such a deep level. Themes such as look at how we deal with traumas in our life and how they impact on who we become as an adult. Themes about looking at the patterns of behaviour passed down from generation to generation and the huge difficulty in breaking those patterns. Perhaps most important to me was the message that you have to work through your past in a positive way so that you can be free to live your future.

The characters were so beautifully created and the subtlety of the performances was just so moving. It's amazing how a glance or a breath can convey so many words and feelings.

I thoroughly loved this film and its images, themes and lyrical beauty have come back to me again and again since seeing the film. Thank you to all involved for providing me with such a wonderful experience.
33 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Helena Bonham Carter Aussie Accent - A Class
jdfilmtv10 December 2005
The most amazing thing I found about this film was Bonham Carters impeccable accent. As an Australian I am often subjected to attempts at our accent, and while some are better than others I have never in my life heard someone from another country, even New Zealand, be able to replicate it flawlessly. Until now.

I've had this conversation with people from all kinds of countries with all kinds of accents and it seems that there's a certain level of agreeance regarding how comparitively difficult the Austalian accent is to copy.

I'm looking forward to Johnny Depp in Shantaram giving it a go. HBC is co-starring so he should have some good tips to get him started.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Boring and Pretentious
reel_emotion26 April 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Okay, just about everybody here seems to like Till Human Voices Wake Us. Maybe admitting that you didn't like it is admitting that you are stupid, don't know much about poetry, or can't understand artsy fartsy movies. Well, maybe I am just that. Oh yeah, I did get the whole movie was the guy's dream--not that the character of Ruby is the reincarnation of his childhood girlfriend, which is the movie's literal translation.

Guy Pierce is one of my favorite actors--and he is good here. Human Voices starts out promising enough with Pierce as a psychology professor giving a lecture about repressing memories. But Human Voices slides downhill from there. The pace is boring. I had the feeling if some scenes were added or edited, this could've been a good movie.

Pierce's emotionally cold father dies, and he goes back to his hometown to bury him--against his father's wishes to be buried in Melbourne. You never know why Pierce's dad was so distant--and do we really see the effects on Pierce's character because of that detachment? I also wanted to know what happened to his mother, but I didn't hear anything about her.

Pierce flashes back on his childhood and his handicapped girlfriend. She would sit on the sidelines reading T.S. Elliot while he would swim in the river. The two friends become romantic, but the movie is particularly slow getting there. On one tragic night, he helps her into the river holding her, but after awhile, she lets go of his hand, drowning in the murky water. But the adult Pierce saves the drowning Ruby, played by Helena Bonham-Carter, as she jumps off a bridge in a suicide attempt. Ruby has amnesia and seems to be the reincarnation of his childhood girlfriend. But how can that be? It must be a dream as Pierce says that he is like many psychoanalysts and doesn't dream because the subconscious doesn't like to be found out.

Human Voices sounds interesting, but it is not. It is tedious which is sad because it has an interesting concept. One of the few good scenes is the sex scene between Bonham Carter and Pierce because it seems to resolve much of the conflict in the movie. But it was still one of the many sub par movies I sat through that weekend.
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Touches us...
Heavy_Storm17 July 2004
I can't understand exactly why this movie seemed so good to me. It doesn't have a very elaborated plot. But the movie somehow speaks to us.

The way the director tell such a dense story is marvelous. Movies like this leaves us breathing deeply when it ends. You will fall in love for the characters, and pity them.

The movie suffers from a certain lack of complexity. In some minutes you can easily understand what's happening (and, if you read the box summary, then you will get it in no time at all). Still, it's pretty, and adorable.

The musical score is perfect. It draws us into the movie most of the time, and makes our hearth pounds together with the scenes.

Till Human Voices Wake Us is a poem. Simply as that.
25 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
the only good thing about this film is Helena Bonham Carter's Hairstyle
FilmMan4710 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
till the human voices wake us 2002 is a bad boring film no matter what version you see cut or uncut i don't even know what version i sit through but this film was nonsense.

the story is terrible i like romance,dialog oriented & tragedy films but this was a let down it was just a wannabe tearjerker to put it simply or just for sake of asking sympathy for shallow characters.

i am a fan of both of these actors Guy Pearce & Helena Bonham carter just what in the blue hell these two were doing here is beyond me there is no chemistry between them at all.

the films editing is terrible,pace is slow i don't want the backstory just show me the characters & take the story forward unfortunately main lead actors make a late entry in the film & i lost interest maybe i expected a different film like some slow burning suspense thriller of two lovers with extreme romance & lots of hot sex,none of it is here this film is about 2 people who like each other as kids they go their own ways when they grow up they meet again and their romance begins again & ends on a dull note with a sad ending or rather stupid one.

this could have been turned into a great erotic horror flick if the script was changed as the title name sounds great.

if i have to say one good thing about this crap it just gotta be Helena Bonham Carter's Hair style oh yes she looks crazy in the role but dressing & long hair is spot on,Helena did try her best here but the script sucks there was nothing for her talents here she did better films in 80s & 90s.

this film sucks i failed to enjoy it not even a single memorable dialog comes from this over depressing junk film my rating is 3/10.Skipp It and please don't be tricked by the cool stylish poster.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Amazing cinematography and lighting
derekbradford18 November 2004
As one who would like to make films some day, this film blew my mind as an example of superb cinematography and lighting, as well as balanced and subtle acting. Guy Pearce was a little rigid, but i haven't seen him in anything else, so that may have been an affectation of the morose and sombre character he was playing. Bonham Carter would be a dream to work with. She's a master of the art and has a sly dark, sexuality that i can't resist. I haven't yet, but i'll be searching out the cinematography and lighting credits and looking for more of the work of those fine technicians. Good work on a difficult and slow paced psychological drama.
14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What happened here?
beccagoesbananas28 September 2003
all right, so maybe it was because I was on an airplane and wasn't paying that much attention, but did this movie have a plot? It was sooo predictable and it seemed to barely scrape the surface. Also, I have NO idea what happened at the end. I was so lost and it left me with more questions than answers. Don't bother watching it. I wish I hadn't.
3 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A dream taking over a life
HariElwingShaym1 December 2004
I watched this movie on television while it was running several times one month. The first time I watched it, I got antsy and changed the channel back and forth. I wound up watching it in its entirety several times later on. It is a haunting, intriguing film. Guy Pearce, of course, is extraordinary and so is Helena BC. I see it as a portrayal of a tortured soul who is still in shock from a momentary incident which altered his existence forever. One moment he is an innocent boy and the next he is suppressing a nightmare he cannot come to terms with for half his adult life.

Once he allows himself to live the entire scenario with all the memories and the what if's, when he allows the ghost to be free, the tortured soul is also released. A beautiful, poetic and memorable film.
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Film had real potential
rosscinema28 May 2003
This is a very good looking film with wonderful actors but it fails to deliver any real emotion. I just didn't feel any real passion in the way the story was told. The story is about a young doctor named Sam Jones (Guy Pearce) who travels back to the home where he grew up at because his father died. One night he meets Ruby (Helena Bonham Carter) who tries to kill herself by jumping off a bridge and drowning but Sam saves her and brings her back to his place. After she wakes he discovers she has amnesia and he tries to help her get her memory back and in the process he gets to reflect on a horrible incident that took place when he was a teenager. The film uses flashbacks to see that young Sam (Lindley Joyner) and his handicapped girlfriend Silvy Lewis (Brooke Harmon) had a very special relationship and then she drowns one day tragically. This has haunted Sam up until the present and then discovers that Ruby is actually a reincarnated ghost of Silvy. Its not a horror film, far from it. But its then he gets a chance to come to grips with the past. Pearce and Carter do their best with this material and they're both such interesting performers and they keep the film from being a total bore. We understand right from the get go what's going to happen and the film relies on emotions and a sense of artistic posturing to tell its story. The title of the film comes from the T.S. Eliot poem "The Lovesong of J. Alfred Prufrock". This is a film that needed a sense of overpowering immediacy and passion like the Nicolas Roeg film "Don't Look Now". Unfortunately, this is just an excuse to go through the motions.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Perfect Elegiac Dream Film
robert-temple-112 March 2008
This is a magnificent triumph of film-making. Why is it that five years later, the writer and director Michael Petroni has not made another feature film? Is there no justice at all in the world? Everything about this film, the mood, the pace, the beautiful and sensitive cinematography, the music, the writing, the direction, and the acting are uniformly superb. No one with any sensitivity could fail to be moved by this dreamlike excursion into memory, remorse, and loss. This film deals with 'atonement' more profoundly than the film of that title which has just been made. Helena Bonham Carter gives one of the most memorable and inspired performances of her entire career in this film. Guy Pearce, who was so wonderful in 'Memento' (2000), here is even better. The teenaged boy and girl are played by Lindley Joyner and Brooke Harmon respectively, and they are spellbinding and delightfully refreshing and charming. (The boy has never made a film since, and one wonders why.) The boy's father, a man paralyzed in his emotions, is played with total conviction by Peter Curtin. His silence is eloquent, and so is Guy Pearce's. This film deals with silence, with dreaming, with visions, with memory. It is not in any way a 'supernatural film' in the conventional sense, and anyone hungry for poltergeists and demons should look elsewhere. This film is very sad, because it deals so profoundly with guilt and loss. It touches the deepest reaches of our psyches, it is a true work of art, and has a master's brush strokes on every frame.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
About as close as you can get to a complete waste of time
hhfarm-120 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
What is this movie about? It's mostly a sentimental flashback to a time when the protagonist was a teenager and let his crippled girlfriend drown. That's not enough though: we see him upset at the death of his mom; we see how cold and distant his dad is; we see him pull a calf out of the mom with a rope.

We mostly see the adult thinking back to his adolescence and the relationship he had with a girl in braces. He thinks much about this. To help him think, windshield wipers sweep slowly across a wet windshield giving partial but revealing glimpses of something; he stares at the moon in the water; he stares at the moon itself; he picks up leaves and dust and, yes, stares at them.

Then he flashes back to his boyhood where his teenage self thinks while he stares at the moon up and down in the water; and has heavy new-agey conversations with his girlfriend; and then thinks some more.

At one point I thought I some kind of Disney-produced Hardy boys movie that happened to be made in Australia.

My guess is that the producer(s)/director saw some European movies and thought it would be cool to use the same kind of pacing. Problem is, you need a story, a focal point, some good dialogue, and some cleverness to pull off this kind of thing. This movie has none of that.

To experiment, I rewound and then FF'd at 2x and 3x speed. It was amazing: the movie is just as vacuous and boring at high speed.

There are numerous swimming, wading and floating scenes. I thought "Great, this is Australia. A 20' croc is going to come up and snag the girl. Maybe it will thrash and roll around a lot before being shot by the local hunter. Maybe we'll see a snapping turtle tearing flesh off the girls head." No such luck though.

Pearce seems to be a nothing actor. HB Carter is as always: strained, wispy, frail, intense, wispy, strained, punctuated, precocious, wispy and frail. Her range is about 1".

The truly amazing thing is that Brannaugh left the brilliant and intelligent Emma Thompson for HB Carter - who doesn't even have big t*ts.

Avod this at any cost unless you want some background noise while you read a magazine.
2 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Absolutely beautiful.
"Let us go then, you and I,

I have seen them riding seaward on the waves Combing the white hair of the waves blown back When the wind blows the water white and black. We have lingered in the chambers of the sea By sea-girls wreathed with seaweed red and brown Till human voices wake us, and we drown."

This excerpt from the poem 'The Love Of J. Alfred Prufrock' by Eliot is our theme for a film called Till Human Voices wake us, a film I've owned on DVD for almost two years and only got around to watching last night. I have a whole gigantic stack of films that number in the hundreds which I still have to conquer. Some are dodgy movies and risky looking indie muck that I picked up because they have an actor or actress I really love. Some end up being absolute gems that I wish I got around to far, far sooner. This is one of those. It's such a beautiful story, an atmospheric, airy glance into grief, regret, life after death, guilt and redemption. It stars Guy Pearce as Sam, an emotionally constrained professor of psychology who travels back to his town of origin in eerie, ambient Australia to bury his recently deceased father. The very moment he arrives he is flooded with memories both glad and sad, permeated deep to his core by a past that he perhaps purposefully numbed over with time and tide, revisiting the lost events of a youth painted by wonder and first love, and tainted by aching tragedy. We see in flashbacks his younger self (Lindley Joiner) barely a teenager in the lonely rural outback. He spent his days back then with his beautiful friend Sylvie (Brooke Harmon), and the two fall deeply, sublimely in love in that affectionate way that only two youngsters who are both experiencing it for the first time can profess. Tragedy strikes though, resulting in Sylvie's death and Sam's withdrawal from his life in the that town, and eventual flight from Australia, not to return until over a decade later, much older yet still plagued by the loss. Upon returning, he meets a mysterious girl named Ruby (Helena Bonham Carter) who he saves from jumping off a bridge. All she can remember is her name. Nothing else like who she is or what she was doing up there. Sam takes her in and tries to help her figure out who she is, and perhaps unbeknownst to him, who he is these days as well. Together they meander through meadows memories, exploring each other's thoughts, perceptions and feelings, gradually coming to some third act revelations that really shouldn't come as a surprise to any viewer with an ounce of intuition. The surprise comes not in being taken off guard by plot turns, because I certainly wasn't. No, the film never sets out to try and surprise you, and guessing what's going on before any reveal I suspect was part of its plan. What it floored me with, though, is the level of emotion and heights of pure crestfallen sadness that we need to sit through. I say need because this is a film about coming to terms with ones own past, hard parts and all. Sam has bottled up the loss of Sylvie for quite some time, and his character arc lets it all tumble out in some scenes that hit hard. It's never ugly or despairing though, and gracefully makes itself only as sorrowful as it needs to be. Pearce and Carter are painfully good in the leads, quietly devastating work for both. It's Harmon and Joiner who complete the song as young Sylvie and young Sam though, two young actors who are uncommonly good on camera and vastly skilled at imparting the raw, reckless and romantic nature of youth, particularly discovering love for the first time, and subsequently losing it in heartbreak that strikes far too soon, like an early summer storm. This is one I'm imagining not too many people have heard of, and one I might have gone a few more years without seeing if I hadn't randomly decided to watch it last night. I'm glad I did, and you should too.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This film hit close to home for me
joeestlinbm18 February 2005
Warning: Spoilers
The beautiful Helena Bonham Carter as usual played her part to perfection.

When I was young a girlfriend of mine drowned while we were swimming, so in a remote way I can relate to this movie.

I of course never met the ghost of the girl that drowned, but I can relate to the feelings of the boy. This movie was rather a fantasy, and I was very impressed with Miss Carters performance. DR Franks seemed to have difficulty in believing she was who she was, So he hypnotized her to find out for sure, and he convinced himself I believe to an extent. The ending was a little disappointing, but it would have been hard to come up with another one I guess, so we'll have to be satisfied with this one. I watched the movie because Helena Bonham Carter was in it. You can watch it because it was a beautiful watchable movie.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This is a mental/emotional movie - not meant for action-lovers
suzannadavi3 May 2004
I was reading some of the previous reviews and realized that not everyone would get or like this movie - it is not one I would recommend to many friends, but I loved it. Painful, real, acknowledging of life's moments to regret- it made me think of the line from the Big Kahuna when Danny Divito says you have lots to regret, you just don't know it yet (paraphrase) - another great non-action movie. I saw nothing of the paranormal in this movie - I think that is an interpretation by those who do not get it. Beautifully done and tenderly told, I heartily recommend this movie to a small handful of special people which included my 15 year old daughter.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sweet, sad movie that is surprisingly haunting.
sweetiejay9 October 2004
This movie is an under rated film that blends the past and present. It focuses on what is and what might have been, and what life would be like if we had the chance to correct our mistakes. Dr Sam Franks is a man who returns to his home town to bury his somewhat estranged father. On the way he rescues Ruby, an unknown woman who cannot remember who she is or why she is here. He takes her in, and she makes him remember memories he had tried to forget. We are revealed through painful, and sad flashbacks of terrible memories, what it is he had tried to forget. In the end it seems as though she was brought here, just to make him remember, so he could forgive and move on. A sad film, but beautiful at the same time. A line that would sum this film up would be - "She never was."
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
a very memorable film, very highly recommended
Pantdino18 November 2004
Warning: Spoilers
If you have just opened this page to decide whether you want to rent this film, I recommend you not read ANYTHING about it. See the film with no preconceptions and discover what it means to you. As each viewer will bring his own life experience and beliefs to it, you may perceive a different story than other viewers. For me, it is one of the most memorable of films.

After you have viewed it, come back to see which reviewers saw the same story you did.

SPOILERS BELOW:

Some reviewers have panned this film for being a lame and predictable ghost story. I don't think that's what it is, possibly because I don't believe in ghosts but do believe in the power of past events in our minds. It occurred to me early on that Ruby may not be real, but as I had read nothing about the story before seeing it I maintained this as a hypothesis rather than as a fact.

As I watched the film I concluded that the protagonist was delusional. The memories jarred by his visit to Genoa, by staying in his boyhood home, were just too painful--the father who was distant to the point of nonexistence, the love he had lost as a teen, the guilt he felt related to Sylvia's death. Most of us can look at past events and see ones we wish had turned out differently, but these events go beyond that. These events he has repressed and they have held him prisoner. Ruby is a creation of his tortured mind, a way to try to reconnect with Sylvia.

And it worked for him. He saves her from drowning in the same river, they talk, she tells him she loved him, they make love; things that would have happened had he not taken her into the water years earlier. Things he needs to have happen, even if only in his mind.

In the closing scenes he is not surprised to see she has disappeared. He accepts that and is ready to begin healing.

Of course, he could also just be dreaming and will soon awaken. But that ending was overused long ago.

A truly beautiful and memorable film.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Moveing
boingo-8365513 March 2019
I've never written a movie review, here or anywhere. I felt I needed to now. I'm an action/sci-fi guy by habit, the lower brow the better. This movie is absolutely sublime, expertly directed and performed. The idea in modern cinema seems to be that true emotion is sappy. And, while I watched it 17 years after release and by accident, I felt for the characters. The idea of love and loss is older then Shakespeare, but this film made it feel fresh. Simpley, I loved it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Imaginative remake of Wild Strawberries
anita_baxter7 April 2004
The supernatural seems to be real in this poetic film about a repressed Australian psychiatrist who revisits his boyhood home. Thereafter, the film becomes a long dream sequence as he deals with a terrible trauma from his youth. The beauty of the Australian countryside makes the dream world seem possible.

Ingmar Bergman's film Wild Strawberries has a very similar construction, without the ambiguity. Perhaps a direct influence?

The pace and music are deliberately slow to evoke a sleep-like world, so don't lose patience. Just enjoy the idyllic scenery and the wonderful acting, especially by the teenage actors.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What a beautiful, poetic film
LadyBeth101 May 2012
I just came across this film on The Movie Channel this morning. I'm home sick in bed, and there's not much else to do. Wow, am I glad I did. I don't know what other movies this writer/director has made, but believe me, I will look them up. I've only read other user reviews, and if the critics panned it, then I don't care to read theirs. Sometimes films that are not easily categorizable, get lost in the modern film market. Whether it is a ghost story, or a psychological gestalt is left up to the viewer's interpretation. I rarely come on here to post, but this film compelled me to do so. This film brought me to tears, both happy and sad. Like a beautiful poem, it unfolds slowly and heartbreakingly. The writing, direction, acting, cinematography, and score are excellent. I'm so glad I DVR'd it, because I'm watching it again. It does remind one of Bergman and some of Kurosawa's more personal films in it's intimate construction. But this filmmaker stands on his own. It haunts you and is absolutely unforgettable.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Into the Heart of Suffering
galaxywest15 April 2006
There are things that happen to an unfortunate few people that are so painful, so full of guilt, that recovering from it seems nearly impossible. "Till Human Voices Wake Us" tells the story of Sam Franks and his spiritual journey out of the dark and back into the light. But, who is the young woman that is helping him? Apparently, this movie did not impress very many critics. Why, I'm not sure--because it is truly a wonderful, nearly perfect story about salvation. And where that salvation actually comes from.

I hope that Michaell Petroni will be able to make many more movies, because it would be a shame if such a talented and sensitive film maker were not able to continue.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A film like no other
snafu-42 February 2004
i had no expectations before watching this movie. I've heard very little about it but what i have heard was it was just plain bad. I honestly just watched it because Guy Pearce was in it, but if there is one thing we've learnt from watching Pearce's films is that he takes the complex unoridinary films and this is no exception. Firstly lets start with the plot. From reading other reviews you already know Pearce is a doctor and his leading lady has amnesia, but the film is so much more then that. Pearce's character goes back to where he grew up to barry his father and goes on a journey to recover the past that he never dealt with. It's truley an amazing story about the tragedy one boy experiances in his youth and how it has affected his life thus. Don't take my word for it and don't listen to all of those who have said the movie was bad or made no sense, watch it for yourself and you will see this is another one of Pearce's masterpeices.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Moving, Beautiful, Sadness
iyc_blu9 January 2007
I haven't seen such a beautiful movie in a while, it's tragic and it's romantic. This movie is haunting, there are some truly poignant moments of a man having to deal with and let go of a lost love. The location is beautiful, the acting is great, the cinematography and the story really takes you on a journey. It's subtle and real. It left a good impression on me. It's a superb Australian film. Credit goes to the beautiful Helena Bonham Carter who managed to pull off a convincing Australian accent! The music is good too, it really creates the mood. The dancing in the water scene was so romantic. It makes you think about the relationships you have with other people. See it if you haven't all ready!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed