The Mechanical Butcher (1895) User Reviews

Think Star Trek Food Replicator

[PCC0921 · 7/10 · 11 September 2023]

This film can also be found in its original French title, La Charcuterie mécanique (1895). This is another extra Lumière film, produced in 1895, that probably didn't get shown to a paying audience until 1896. It probably kept the 1895 tag, because it was shown to a test audience that year. The Mechanical Butcher (1895), does harbor close to being the first science fiction film ever made (at least in futuristic terms), when a pig is turned into all the known sections of prepared meat, found at your local meat market, sliced to perfection, complete with some of the wrappings. Think Star Trek food replicator. The Mechanical Butcher (1895), was an odd choice of a subject, for being one of the first movies ever made. It must have been a stage act, that the Lumiere brothers decided to film. Looking at it from a 21st century perspective, it looks odd, but maybe made more sense to audiences in 1895. It was still a history making moment and only 43 seconds long.

6.9 (C MyGrade) = 7 IMDB.

Of historical interest only

[jamesrupert2014 · 5/10 · 17 June 2019]

A machine is demonstrated that supposedly instantly turns pig into pork at the turn of a wheel. The film, created by the pioneering Lumière Brothers, is about an imaginary 'technology' but there are no 'special effects'. Calling this ancient one-joke short the first science fiction film, as some do, is a bit of a stretch, but as there is no obvious 'first' for the genre, this is as likely as any of the contenders. The film spawned a number of knockoffs in which various animals are turned into sausages. As there were rumours that such things were happening, these films may have been meant as satire as well as entertainment. Ironically, the 'la charcuterie mécanique' foreshadowed modern meat-product production facilities, which involve considerably less 'hands-on' work than 19th century butchers could have imagined.

First science fiction film?

[petteri-kalliomaki · 4 July 2003]

In Phil Hardy's encyclopedia of science fiction films, this 50-second movie by Lumière was celebrated as the first science fiction film ever. Why not? It is the first time there was given a cinematic form for fear of technology. Here the theme is dealed with humour. There is a big box with circulaw saw in it. A pig is put in and it comes out as sausages and other kind of meat products.

Of course, you can't seriously talk about science fiction films as a genre before the 50's, but "La charcuterie mécanique" has certainly a scifi-angle in it.

Anyway, this is the funniest film by Lumière I have seen, and least dated of his fictitious subjects.

A bit undecided on this one

[Horst_In_Translation · 4/10 · 12 October 2013]

While I don't approve of the killing of any animal for reasons to eat it, I have to say that this short film had quite some wit. A pig is lead to a mysterious box, forced in there and at the other side of the box, another person gets out a whole bunch of sausages, meat specialties and more porky results of slaughtering the animal. It's a bit of a magic trick as we, almost 120 years later, still have no mechanisms that work so efficiently and quickly in the food industry. The steam coming out of the machine adds nicely to the atmosphere of the short film and as whole I recommend it to silent film enthusiasts, at least the non-vegetarians among these.

An interesting idea

[Ararat-Tempest · 10/10 · 21 October 2023]

Many people ever dreamt about machines. But the machine in this movie really shines at the standard of 1890's.

If I was one of the audience in the cinema watching this movie, it'd give me a whole range of ideas, or maybe purely a brainstorm. After watching this, I tried to recall the scenes and thought about more scenes for the animation! So I'd say this movie even opens a new door of multi-media. Things not just sci-fi but also include stuffs of fantasy, magic, etc.

Well, I think I could make a dream about "famous scenes" of short movies during 1870-1900 like this and put all the ideas into a feature length movie. Or you can make it happen for me, Mr. Director.

Butchered Pig

[Michael_Elliott · 21 July 2015]

The Mechanical Butcher (1895)

*** (out of 4)

Louis Lumiere directed this rather clever film that has a butcher putting a large pig into a magical box where when he opens the other side, he pulls out all sorts of pork and sausage links. THE MECHANICAL BUTCHER is called the first science fiction film by a lot of people but I'd say it's more of a trick film than anything else. I reckon you could get away with calling it sci-fi but I think you're really pushing for that. With that said, there's no doubt that this is quite entertaining and you can't help but smile and laugh at the various types of pork that gets pulled out of the box. At just 40 seconds this was obviously shot in one take and you have to wonder if this was it or were there outtakes or other issues that happened.

First sci-fi film ever--even before "A Trip to the Moon"

[Tornado_Sam · 9 January 2018]

Louis Lumiere, the director of this roughly 45 second short, was more known for his actuality films with which he began his career--street scenes, babies being fed, trains arriving, etc. But, and this is one of those exceptions, sometimes Lumiere would turn out a comedy or one-gag film that was a bit of a step up from his old material. "The Mechanical Butcher" is believed to be THE first Sci-Fi film ever in film history. I could see why they say that, too--primitive, but nonetheless a Science Fiction topic.

A fat old hog is shoved into a box with a wheel operating it. After a couple secs, the other side comes open, and out comes what's left of the pig--pork products, all ready for people to eat. With a final burst of steam the film ends. For a Lumiere movie, it's about as fictitious as they got. And despite it's age, it's actually a lot more enjoyable to watch today then most of their other movies.

I can't say that this is sci-fi...more comedy or fantasy.

[planktonrules · 10 February 2019]

According to several sources (including IMDB) this is the first sci-fi film. Well, I don't consider it that...it seems more like comedy or fantasy.

Like all films from 1895 or thereabouts, the film is very, very short. During this era, most films were 30-120 seconds long...that's it. And, lengthy narratives simply were not even considered.

In this film, you see a giant contraption and a pig is led into it. The folks begin turning a crank and out comes sausages and other cuts of pork. That's it...nothing more to it.

There was another film made not too long after this that expanded the idea much more...and used dogs instead of pigs. It was much better...but it wasn't first...though I can't see an sci-fi about either one.