A Call to Remember (TV Movie 1997) Poster

(1997 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Very Believable Familiar Drama About Traumas of Some Survivals of the Holocaust
claudio_carvalho8 February 2004
In 1967, Paula (Blythe Danner) and David Tobias (Joe Mantegna) are Jews survivals from the Holocaust. They lost their husband, wife and sons (two, each of them) in the war, murdered by the Nazis. They met each other after the war, and got married, not for love, but for supporting each other. In USA, they have two sons: the rebel and selfish Jake (David Lascher) and the sweet Ben (Kevin Zegers). Their income source is a small toy store, where Paula and David works, eventually supported by theirs sons. Jake wants to move to another place and live with his girlfriend Amy, and Jake wants to play baseball, but their very-protective parents do not allow them. Jake wants to join the Army and fight in Vietnam just to upset his mother. One day, Paula receives a phone call from an international non-governmental agency informing that one of her sons is alive. Paula gets excited, sends the necessary money for travel expenses of his son and goes to New York with a friend of her to meet him. There she realizes that the agency committed a mistake, and this event is a trigger that releases many traumas buried in her soul. In the end, the family somehow overcomes these problems and life goes on. Although being a very slow movie, it is also sensitive and hooks the attention of the viewer. The character of Jake is so selfish that has irritated me. This screenplay seems to be based on the true story since it is very believable, having a dedication in the end of the movie. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): `Uma Chamada do Passado' (`A Call from the Past')
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
realistic and true to life
mbg41119 November 2007
I usually don't like historical dramas but this one is pretty good. The story is very interesting, as well as unpredictable. The best thing about this movie are the actors and characters.

Blythe Danner should have won an award for her performance! She was truly convincing as a woman who tried to put on a strong face for her family, but was falling apart inside. Joe Mantegna was persuasive as her loving and loyal husband. David Lascher, one of my favorite actors, turns in a typically appealing performance as the rebellious and troubled son. As usual, Kevin Zegers doesn't hold up his end of the film. There's a reason why he did those "Air Bud" movies! Still, he was good as the naive, innocent little boy.

The movie is very slow paced though. And again, I'm just not into historical dramas. But other than that, the movie is well worth watching.

My vote is 7/10.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A second life after the Nazi horror
Milhaud27 October 1999
This movie gives a good idea of how it must be when your parents lived the Nazi horror but desperately want to bury the memory of it and want "the best" for you as a child. I found the movie longish at times and the ending somewhat simplistic, but the relations between the members of this family are often thought-provoking. A good flick overall. I rate it 7 out of 10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Touching but not gritty or schmaltzy story of holocaust survivors
moviebuffgirl5 July 2000
Kudos to Blythe Danner and the rest of the strong cast for making a touching, believable story of holocaust survivors. 60 members of my family were slaughtered in the holocaust and I generally don't enjoy watching movies about it. However, this story dealt not with the tragedy and horror of that actual experience, but the legacy of survivors. Set in 1960's suburbia, the Tobias' story focuses on their relationship with their two sons. This is no Shine, however. The Tobias' are as loving and highly functional as two human beings could be after what they have been through. Yet their resilience is not overplayed-- their love for their children is sometimes crushing, their fear smothering. And the central conflict of the movie revolves around their difficulties letting go with the past and behaviors that allowed them to survive in the camps, but cut them off from living fully in a peaceful situation. Overall, the story reminded me of Maus meets Ordinary People, somehow escaping the minor key of each. Those looking for a gritty holocaust tale, or high melodrama should look elsewhere. Although the fine acting, sturdy script, and poignancy of the story kept me in a steady flow of tears, this is primarily a life-afirming story. I highly reccomend it!
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Call to Remember- Dial Up for This One ****
edwagreen22 November 2007
To have lived through the Holocaust would provide never ending nightmares for anyone. Here is the story of a holocaust survivor who remarries and begins a new life in America only to discover years later that a son from her first marriage has survived and is being sent to rejoin her.

Could anyone ever imagine having to experience something like this? Blythe Danner gives a wonderful, outstanding performance as the mother and is ably supported by a terrific cast featuring Joe Montegena as her understanding husband.

The film not only depicts Danner's reaction to this miracle of the return of her son but how her "American" children feel about the sudden appearance of a long lost brother.

Naturally, we will all shudder when fate steps in and provides a cruel trick to Danner. How she gets through this and that Bar Mitzva scene at the end are reasons in itself to watch this powerful film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Acting showcase for strong cast
Libretio3 February 2005
A CALL TO REMEMBER

Aspect ratio: 1.33:1

Sound format: Stereo

1967: After rebuilding their lives in America, two Jewish holocaust survivors (Blythe Danner and Joe Mantegna) are forced to confront their dark past when fate plays a cruel trick...

Unusual drama from TV specialist Jack Bender (KILLING MR. GRIFFIN, "The David Cassidy Story", etc.) in which unhappy history has a tragic bearing on the present (in this case 1967, at a time when America had become embroiled in a war no less dangerous than the one in which Danner and Mantegna suffered their worst indignities). Danner takes center stage as the strong mother laid low by an appalling twist of fate, while teenage son David Lascher (TV's "Sabrina the Teenage Witch") represents the viewpoint of a generation untouched by their parents' experiences in occupied Europe. Mantegna is dignified in a crucial supporting role, and there's an early appearance by Kevin Zegers (TRANSAMERICA) as the younger sibling slowly waking to the full horror of Nazi war crimes.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Poignant Movie about the Legay of the Holocaust! A MUST-SEE!
benbrattlover2 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
A Call to Remember, is a BEAUTIFUL made-for-TV movie about the long-term effects of the Holocaust & its legacy on future generations.

I LOVE this Movie! I taped it off TV, but I've watched it so often, the tape is almost worn out! Literally! :)

So I really hope it comes on DVD very soon!

A Call to Remember, is a true story, that occurred to one of the movie's creators. It stars Joe Mantegna and Blythe Danner, as David (Mantegna) & Paula (Danner) Tobias, a Jewish couple living in the northwestern United States with their two sons, 18 year old Jacob (David Lascher) & 12-13 year old Benjamin (Kevin Zegers), during the late 1960's.

David and Paula Tobias are Holocaust survivors whose entire families (including Paula's first husband & two sons, & David's first wife & two sons) were murdered by the Nazis.

After the war, David and Paula met in a D.P.(Displaced Persons) Camp, and married - not so much out of love, but rather a fear of being all alone in the world, and the need for somebody in their lives. As in the words of Paula Tobias, "At that time people didn't think about love, it was better not to be alone."

At the movie's start, the Tobias family are living a relatively normal, typical upper middle-class Jewish-American life. They are busy planning their 13 year old son Ben's bar mitzvah, and though over two decades have passed since the Holocaust, many reminders of the trauma and ordeal they endured still remain, as vivid as ever.

For example, there is a scene where Jake and Ben accidentally discover $20,000 in cash stored in several mayonnaise jars, and hidden behind a secret wall in the basement. It's a clear reminder that even though it's the late 1960's and they're in America now, they are still in "basic survival instinct" mode - living in fear of another Holocaust, and the need to quickly flee.

Another obvious but understandable effect, is David and Paula's over-protectiveness, resulting in their kids, especially their elder son, feeling completely smothered and suffocated. As Jake complains bitterly about his mother to his girlfriend, Amy, "She breathes my air first, to make sure it's okay for me. Do you have any idea what that's like?" Also, the Vietnam War and its military draft is intricately woven into this storyline, with David & Paula's terror that their 18 year old son, Jake will be called up and forced to fight in the war. They're petrified at the thought of anything happening to their remaining children. So much so, that Mr. & Mrs. Tobias enlist the aid of a psychiatrist, Dr. Green (Joe Spano) to write a medical exemption letter to the draft board, which infuriates Jake, further reinforcing his feelings of being controlled by his parents.

Another facet of David and Paula's overprotectiveness, is a total inability to not only discuss their experiences during the war, but to share ANY aspect of their pasts or family history with their children. As Jake, remarks cynically to his brother, Ben, in regards to their father's family, "Don't expect him to tell you what happened. He won't even say what their names were."

Because of Mr. & Mrs. Tobias's reluctance to talk about their pasts, Jake and Ben are unable to fully understand and comprehend the depths of suffering that their mother and father have endured. As a result, the Tobias children, Jake, especially, minimize their parents pain, while exaggerating and overemphasizing the minor discomfort over the petty, insignificant trivialities in their own lives. Like in one scene, when Jake is arguing with his parents about moving in with friends, he says, "I'm drowning!" to which his mother scoffs, replying, "What do you know about drowning? Drowning is when you have nothing!"

So, all these tensions, and long-buried traumas that are just simmering beneath the surface, all come to a head when, out of the blue, Paula Tobias gets a phone call that her son Alec, who it was presumed had been killed during the war, was found alive and well in Poland. This surprising and unexpected call creates a whirlwind of emotions for the entire family from excitement, and joy to skepticism, jealousy, and worry.

Later, when they receive some very tragic news, the entire Tobias family are thrown into a tailspin, and for the first time in their lives they are forced to truly look inside themselves, and reassess everything they have ever known - their values, priorities, relationships with family, friends, and acquaintances, indeed their whole way of dealing with life in general.

In the aftermath of their cruel twist of fate, David and Paula come to realize that if they want to heal themselves and their children, and strengthen their bonds as a family, they must face all the memories that they have been running and hiding from since the war. They slowly accept that the only way for them to survive and move on with their lives is if they deal with the grief that they have postponed for over two decades, and finally mourn for all the deaths and losses that they suffered at the hands of the Nazis.

With this realization, and working to recover from the long-buried traumas of the past, the entire Tobias family are ultimately able to come together happily at the end to celebrate the much-anticipated rite of passage of son Ben's bar mitzvah.

Far from being a dark, and depressing film, this is a beautiful movie about life in general. It has happy moments, sad moments, good times, bad times. Although the theme of the movie is about the Holocaust, and there are sad parts, "A Call to Remember", is not a gloomy movie. It is a touching and poignant tale about the legacy of the Holocaust and its effects on future generations. A MUST SEE!!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Truthful film.
Jack-12531 December 1998
This is a truthful, careful, real film. Deeply satisfying; wonderful to watch. Danner is the best - simply the best. The story, unique though it is, is the universal story about the depth of grief. The director is very careful, very attentive to the detail of the times and of the characters. A 10 for sure.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A family's love can conquer all.
Digger-42 February 1999
A deeply moving movie that touches even the most callous person.

It delves into the world of two overly protective Jewish parents as they raise their sons under the shadow of past horrors dealt to them during the Holocaust. This film is a must see.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed