Lieberman in Love (1995) User Reviews

Huh?

[MrsMakrel · 6/10 · 8 April 2024]

This won best live action short? I'm so confused over the characters. None were particularly likeable, and the southern accent was grating on me - and I've lived in the South for years!

Overall, blah. The concept was solid. Widower accidentally comes onto a call girl, and the two begin a professional relationship. It's the introduction of a second woman that leaves me wondering what happened. What motivation did the realtor have to keep seeing him? Did she know he had the money to begin with? Does she do this regularly and if so, why is she still a realtor?

Overall, one I'm glad was short and I didn't need to spend much time on.

A Cynical and Very Funny Love Story

[claudio_carvalho · 9/10 · 16 August 2003]

Joe Lieberman (Danny Aiello) meets Shallen (the fantastic and great actress Christine Lahti), a prostitute, and become his preferential client. Later, he meets Kate (the beautiful Nancy Travis), a broker, who helps him to find a new house. Lieberman will fall in love with Kate, and many funny and cynical situations will happen. This short story is a masterpiece of the cynicism: great, outstanding, very funny. Congratulation to the writer, the screenwriter, the director Christine Lahti, cast and crew. I really love it! My vote is nine.

A nicely cynical love story

[bob the moo · 19 July 2004]

Joe Liberman is recently widowed and is finding it very hard to get back out there. He meets a woman at a resort who turns out to be a prostitute but, after trying it once, Joe becomes a regular client of Shaleen. Regaining his confidence Joe then meets a beautiful woman called Kate who sells him a condo. As he continues sleeping with Shaleen, Joe tries to work out how he can seduce Kate away from her husband – producing a very complicated love entanglement.

I saw this film as one of the ongoing 'short story cinema' series all from the same production company. While the series produced many memorable shorts and gave many stars their first job as director, too often the shorts all sound and look the same (small light music and visual feel). Lieberman is one of the shorts that manages to stand out from the crowd and is actually one of the more enjoyable ones. The plot produces a rather clever little story that is romantic but not sentimental – it is sweet but it is very cynical in how it views relationships; certainly what you get here is not the normal sweet lovable romantic coupling stuff.

This is not to say that it is perfect, because it maybe isn't quite as clever or different as it thinks it is, although it is clever and interesting enough to get by. Various twists towards the end help it as well. The cast are good and, as is often the case with this series, contains quite a few well known faces. Aiello is good in the lead as he always is and seems to understand his character pretty well. Lahti is good and manages to make her character a 'hooker with a heart of gold' without actually having a heart of gold; her direction is also good and she matches the tone of the material. Travis plays quite a simple character but is effective nonetheless. They all work well together but it is a combination of them and the material that carries it.

Overall this is a romantic story but it is one that is seeped in the cynicism that most of us feel is the reality of relationship as opposed to the sweet, sentimental stuff that is sold us in most Hollywood films. This may not be perfect but it is clever and enjoyable with a tough edge and carries itself well over its long (for a short) running time.