"The Love Boat" The New Love Boat - The Newlyweds/The Exchange/Cleo's First Voyage (TV Episode 1977) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Third Time's the Charm
wwgrayii3 November 2016
It took three tries, but they finally got it right. Not good, mind you (The Love Boat could never be "good."). But taken on its own terms, this pilot hits the right notes.

Kopell, Grandy and Lange were all wisely held over from The Love Boat II, while Gavin MacLeod and Lauren Tewes are piped aboard as the third captain and cruise director. As cruise director Julie McCoy, Tewes provides the same level of acting ability as Diane Stilwell from The Love Boat II (that is, they're both good actors), but she has real chemistry with the rest of the cast, something Stilwell couldn't manage. MacLeod nails the captain role. Ted Hamilton (captain number one) is too stiff, while Quinn Redeker (captain number two) is too serious and dramatic. MacLeod is the only one of the three who seems to understand that he's in a situation comedy. So while the basic outlines of the role are the same (tough ex-naval officer), MacLeod brings some real warmth to the part, along with an always present twinkle in his eye. He makes all the difference.

As for the rest of it, pretty much the same in tone and structure as the second pilot, but ABC didn't put as much money into this one so it's only 90 minutes long (including commercials) and has no real cruise location footage, just a few shots on the deck of the (docked) Queen Mary and a few on and around the (docked) Pacific Princess.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Three times must be the charm.
planktonrules14 November 2022
Before "Love Boat" became a weekly series, it had some teething problems. The first pilot episode was abysmal...with annoying characters and an entirely different crew. I cannot find the second pilot, but know that a few of the series regulars were in it, such as Ted Lange, Bernie Koppel and Fred Grandy. The Captain and Cruise Director were played by relative unknowns. But the third pilot, well, that's full of stuff very familiar to fans of the series...and apparently they finally got the formula right!

When I began watching "The New Love Boat", I could almost immediately notice two big changes from the first pilot. First, the show seemed filled with one-liners...like some comedy writers were hired to punch things up. Second, and NOT welcome, is a laugh track....which serves to continually remind the viewer that this is a light comedy.

There are three main stories. One is about an idiot (Georgia Engel) who stows away on the ship for nor particular reason. Another is about an old guy (Phil Silvers) who seems ready to die (complete with laugh track). And, the final involves a not particularly attractive honeymoon couple who are afraid to sleep together following their marriage.

In most ways, this is THE "Love Boat" people expect...for good or for bad. I didn't love it (mostly due to the laugh track) but it was a HUGE improvement over the first pilot...which was amazingly unfunny and far from enjoyable.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed