Say Hello to Yesterday (1971) User Reviews

"Pick your flowers carefully, my dear..."

[moonspinner55 · 5/10 · 22 July 2009]

May-September romance, this time with the woman in her autumnal years. "Prim and proper" housewife Jean Simmons, apparently stuck in a stale marriage to a stocks analyst near London, is chased madly all over town by gregarious younger man Leonard Whiting, who fancies her. Once she relents and they get to the bedroom, Whiting tells her, "You're Mata Hari, Candy, and Barbarella all rolled into one", and yet we never sense that. Director Alvin Rakoff, who also co-authored the script with Peter King, hands us characters on a meet-cute platter with hardly any exposition. Usually that's fine with me--the less talky introductory material, the better--however, in this case it backfires. We don't see the attraction between these two people, and when Simmons suddenly starts defending her husband and his prowess in bed, it feels like a cheat. Whiting, then a hot commodity following Zeffirelli's "Romeo and Juliet", is convincing as a carefree youth longing for non-conformist kicks, but when the scenario grows solemn--as with a confusingly presented trip to the hospital--Whiting laughably stiffens, becoming melodramatically misty. Rakoff also does the handsome Whiting a disservice in the final act, staging a serious discussion between the lovers while keeping Whiting ridiculously wrapped in a tangerine-colored bed sheet! Simmons does what she can with a sketchy character, but there are few surprises from the actress (who had played this type of role too often before). The age difference is brought up but not examined; Rakoff seems more intrigued by Simmons' distaste in the young man's unemployment status--definitely not a reaction the audience can warm up to. Riz Ortolani's pretty music and Geoffrey Unsworth's cinematography help keep the film interesting and tolerable, but by the end it has become laborious. ** from ****

Say goodbye to reality.

[mark.waltz · 3/10 · 29 August 2020]

We've seen this premise many times, and sometimes it works but many times it does not. This time is one of the later, simply because of the way that Leonard Whiting stalks Jean Simmons throughout the first 20 minutes of this film, which would have him arrested for sure. Even with hidden snickers of amusement on the train while avoiding his attentions, it's obvious that Jean Simmons for the most part is annoyed by him.

But after the incident on the train, he follows her around to various shopping places and before long, she's putting on a fashion show for him and he's picking out clothes for her to try on. They then end up at the home of her mother's (a terrific Evelyn Laye) and then in one of his acquaintances Apartments, where everything between them explodes into passion and later anger.

Whiting is charming for sure, but his childish antics would annoy any serious adult, even one in a troubled marriage like Jean's. It only begins to make sense briefly when they are at her mother's, and Laye indicates that she too had her own flings which shocks her daughter. This is basically the two leaves and a few smaller parts, and it gets frustrating to watch Simmons keep trying to leave him and later returned to his arms. She is certainly gorgeous, but this wasn't the happy continuation of her success after her Oscar nomination the year before for "The Happy Ending".

Even though she is only on screen for 5 minutes, it is the 1930's leading lady Evelyn Laye who walks off with e film, especially when she gets Whiting to dance with her. In spite of how I hated the first 20 minutes of the film, I couldn't completely dismiss it with the later sequences, and those terrific London locations are quite stunning. There is also a nice musical theme that results in a beautiful, melancholy song that accompanies the bittersweet ending.

Deservedly forgotten

[malcolmgsw · 2/10 · 18 October 2016]

Maybe it's a coincidence that the film careers of the leading players Whiting and Simmonds were brought to an end after this film.In the case of Whiting he made the decision,quite wisely from this appearance,to concentrate on the stage.In the case of Simmonds age caught up with her and she subsequently divided her time between the stage and TV movies.The problem with this film is that the characters and the story is just unsustainable.Whitings character is an excruciating bore.When he is on screen it is like someone is drawing their nails down a blackboard.Simmonds is a bored housewife who is more likely to give him a kick were it hurts rather than play along with him.The films only moment of interest is when they go to the flat of Simmonds mother who is played by Evelyn Laye.Also note at the beginning there is no snow at the beginning of the film.At Cobham station it is thick on the ground,and when the train arrives at Victoria there is no snow.

Exceptionally underrated but well crafted and acted British film

[alan-1141 · 9/10 · 3 November 2010]

One of the most underrated British films that was produced on the cusp, between the end of the swinging sixties and the beginning of the hippy seventies. Leonard Whiting (Romeo from Franco Zeffirelli's Romeo and Juliet) plays a young dreamer who is trapped in a working class existence: living in a council house with a father who has no horizon higher than working in the local factory. Jean Simmons is the mature woman, living in a leafy Surrey house with her stockbroker husband and two children, but desperately unhappy with her life. When the two unlikely lovers meet on a train to London, Whiting ignores the come-on from Susan Penhaligon by saying 'today I am going to climb Mount Everest,' and so begins his charm offensive of the mature woman across London's 1970s landscape. Beautifully written and with expert filming by Geoffrey Unsworth, Say Hello to Yesterday is one of the most insightful films ever to deal with the thrill and inevitable puncturing of the balloon that signifies the love affair between these two protagonists.

Jean Simmons in 'The Happy Ending Part 2'

[HotToastyRag · 2/10 · 30 July 2022]

Normally I don't go in for May-December romances when the man takes the December slot, but for the sake of Jean Simmons, I decided to give Say Hello to Yesterday a shot. Really, though; does anyone really want to see Romeo seduce a woman old enough to be his mother? Leonard Whiting is supposed to be young and Romeo-ish forever. Instead, in this movie, he's weird and obnoxious, and tumbling around in a hotel room in the afternoon.

Thanks to The Happy Ending (which is thanks to Life at the Top), Jean Simmons got typecast as a bored housewife who isn't happy in the bedroom. It's a far cry from her typecast in the 1950s as Sister Sarah! So, in this movie, she goes out for the day and suddenly has the desire to cheat on her wealthy, devoted husband. There's really no reason, no intense chemistry, and no meaningful bond between them. She just sees him acting silly on the train, and she allows his inappropriate behavior to get out of control.

Most of this movie is very silly and very 1970s, but Jean does have one extremely well acted scene. It makes up for the lack of realism, but it doesn't actually turn it into a good movie.