So You Want a Television Set (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Small Screen vs. Big Screen
redryan6422 February 2016
WELL NOW, JUST where do we start? This episode of the MC DOAKES Series may well be dated in many respects, but so what? It's now over 62 years old. That's to be expected. While lacking all of the modern amenities that we now expect, the short is energetic and is an excellent vehicle for taking us back to those "innocent" 1950's. (a time which a "Baby Boomer" such as Schultz and me can recall quite well)

THE OPENING SCENE and central premise are all too true in their presentation of "how things were." From the cessation of hostilities in both Europe (V E Day) and in the Pacific rim (V J Day) until the mid '50's the knew medium of television finally emerged and took center stage. It had been waiting patiently in the wings all during World War II, but it gave the impression that it had emerged magically from nowhere in 1945. (actually the first commercial TV stations of the U.S. were licensed in 1940, with those in the U.K. having preceded them by few years)

NOW, GETTING BACK to this short, it was perhaps the most "lavish" Mc Doakes installment in some time. Number of cast members, complex shooting of what are supposed to be television programs and old movies would most likely have been too costly for a one reeler movie short. So, what happened? Well we'll never tell. Watch it and see! BUT, BEFORE WE sign off for the night, let us make just a few more observations about this edition.

APPARERNTLY THE STUDIO felt that George O'Hanlon's stock had risen some; evidenced by his always getting credited for co-writing the shorts. There was also a "kinder and gentler" Joe depicted in the first title card following their sensational "Behind the 8 Ball" opening.

IT FEATURED AS w have already intimated, a large cast of supporting players. Phyllis Coates (Alice) and Rodney Bell (Marvin) were regulars. Additionally, we have Gail Bonney, Ralph Brooks, Steve Carruthers, Fred Kelsey (semi-regular), Jack Mower (also semi-reg) and Mabel Smaney (Marvin Wife # 2). Unusual participants included Phillip Van Zandt (from CITIZEN KANE and many others) and Pro Wrestler Tor Johnson (known in the Ring as "The Super Swedish Angel").

IN FURTHER CASTING, it presented us with a couple of other non roster players ("Uncredited" to you, Schultz!) in Miss Doris Day and Mr. Gordon Mac Rae. They were present to give a little publicity for their then current feature film, BY THE LIGHT OF THE SILVERY MOON; which just (not so) coincidentally was also from Warner Brothers.

AS AN ADDENDUM to what we thought was the final words, yet another observation struck us. Now the way that the new Television Set caused problems in the Mc Doakes household, as contrasted with the manner in which Joe's trip to the local movie house and relative peace, quiet and good fortune is portrayed; one would think that maybe the Brothers Warner were sending us a message about the movies being superior to the small screen in your living room.

NO, THEY WOULDN'T pull a stunt like that, would they, Schultz?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Owning a TV set gets skewered in this short!
llltdesq17 July 2015
This is one of the shorts in the Joe McDoakes series. There will be spoilers ahead:

George O'Hanlon (probably best known as the voice of George Jetson in The Jetsons) starred in a series of one-reel live action shorts as Joe McDoakes, a man continually getting himself into situations as a result of either his own stubbornness or his wife's prodding.

Here, O'Hanlon takes the opportunity to take a few semi-good-natured pokes in the ribs at "the enemy"-television, which was making inroads into the movie business. Joe McDoakes is sitting at dinner and reading the paper when his wife asks him for a television set. He argues against it, she begins crying, he caves and she unveils a set already in the house, allowing O'Hanlon to do a "take".

Joe and a buddy "install" the TV, allowing for several mishaps. The bulk of the short consists of Joe and his wife trying to find a program they both want to watch, with all the standard jokes about TV being trotted out-limited programming options, bad reception, annoying commercials and so on. The obligatory reference to pro wrestling is prominent.

They finally settle on a movie when the first of the visitors arrives and basically take over the living room and the TV. Joe tries to be a bad host, but his wife is all to happy to entertain their guests. As more people show up, Joe gets madder and madder, until they start fighting over which program to watch and soak Joe in beer, at which point he blows his top and stomps out to a movie theater.

In contrast to his evening at home, his theater-going experience is a dream come true. The film he goes to see is By the Light of the Silvery Moon, which is probably why this is an extra on the DVD release of the film. There's a hilarious ending, featuring two cameos. I won't spoil it here.

This short is well worth watching.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
McDoakes and Lobo
Michael_Elliott24 February 2009
So You Want a Television Set (1953)

*** (out of 4)

Joe McDoakes (George O'Hanlon) gets bugged by his wife (Phyllis Coates) to get a new television set, which eventually turns into a disaster. This comedy works not only for the series but also on many other levels including having an attitude about television sets that were probably quite popular back in the day. Joe, a radio man, doesn't see the need of a television and resents being forced to watch commercials and these jokes aimed at that are all very funny. Other funny moments happen when the neighbors wants to come over and eventually get into a fight over what to watch. This whole negative attitude from McDoakes is perfectly done by O'Hanlon but we also get a wide range of supporting guests. In this movie Joe goes to see By the Light of the Silvery Moon (which is the DVD this short is on) and runs into Doris Day and Gordon MacRae in the theater. This is a very funny cameo and another interesting one is when Tor Johnson, from various Ed Wood films, shows up on the wrestling match on television.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
When owning a TV was status ...
dweilermg-14 December 2018
Many of us old enough to remember early 1950s recall that owning a TV, even just a B&W console, made you a local neighborhood celeb of sorts. I remember other kids coming to our home to watch shows such as Ding Dong School and Howdy Doody with me as well as the prime time shows I watched with Mom and Dad. ☺ ... .
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Interesting time capsule blends with timeless humor
ronnybee211221 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I doubt that anyone that didn't witness it firsthand can really imagine what a huge social phenomenon television was in it's early days. Having a TV,any TV at all was a BIG deal! If you had a color TV,you could accidentally become a neighborhood celebrity! Think about that a minute. The wife of Joe McDoakes buys a TV and next thing you know,the whole neighborhood is using the McDoakes' living room as a 'community TV room'! The uninvited guests start requesting refreshments and Joe quite wisely claims that the fridge and cupboards are bare. His wife doesn't catch the hint but instead she corrects Joe and announces that there is a fridge full of beer and a bunch of snacks! Obviously this is not a sustainable situation,eventually something has to give,right? Interesting and rarely-seen view of the bad side of being "The first kid on your block..."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A rather self-serving edition of Joe McDoakes
planktonrules30 October 2017
The story begins with Mrs. McDoakes insisting they have a television...although she had already bought one before she even asked Joe about it. Soon, their dopey neighbor arrives to mess things up and when the television is actually working, lots of moochers show up to watch TV.

"So You Want a Television Set" seems to be an incredibly self-serving installment in the Joe McDoakes series. After all, the short film is all about why having a television set is lousy and overrated. And, at the end, there's a cameo by Doris Day and Gordon McCrea in order to promote their latest film! Because of this and the lack of big laughs, I'd consider this among the weaker entries in the series.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed