I Was a Criminal (1945) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Beginning of the End of the Image of German Military Efficiency
theowinthrop17 June 2006
As pointed out on the other comments on this thread, I WAS A CRIMINAL (a.k.a. PASSPORT TO HEAVEN and CAPTAIN FROM KOEPENICK) used to be shown fairly frequently on television. But that was in the 1950s and 1960s. By 2006 it has vanished from the face of television and movie screens. This is a pity, as not only is the story an interesting comic tale (based on truth), but it is important as a record of one of Middle Europe's best actors of the first half of the 20th Century: Albert Basserman.

I suppose that most of us think of two names in movies from Middle Europe (i.e. Germany and the countries surrounding it) from 1920 - 1945 in American/English films: Emil Jannings (in the silent period) and Conrad Veidt. But in the aftermath of Hitler's rise to power, Albert Bassermann joined Veidt in exile. He was Jewish, and found it definitely unhealthy to stay in Nazi Germany (where he had been a leading stage star). Unlike Veidt (but like Jannings) Basserman could not speak English. But there were ways around that.

In 1940 Alfred Hitchcock was casting the role of Van Meer, the "strong man" from Holland, who's kidnapping is at the center of events in FOREIGN CORRESPONDENT. Hitchcock was aware that Bassermann was available for the role, and decided to cast him. Problem was he still did not know English. Like John Barrymore in MIDNIGHT, Basserman's lines were written out of sight on a blackboard. But Bassermann's performance was extraordinarily good. He is the spokesman for the common people in the film, talking about people who feed the pigeons. He refuses to give up the secret clause to the Nazi agents in the film, but they proceed to torture him a bit, and he starts giving the clause in the treaty when the police show up to rescue him. Joseph Goebbels was to later reveal he liked the film, especially since the Dutch statesman did cave in. Bassermann, despite the language problem, was nominated for the best supporting actor Oscar in 1940, only to lose. But he was now established as a good character actor.

In the next decade he would appear in many films - and imprint himself on his contemporary actors: Laurence Olivier would pattern his middle - European German accent on Bassermann's through his last films. Olivier even copied some of Bassermann's body language (his little shrugs).

I WAS A CRIMINAL is based on an incident that happened in the Second German Reich of Kaiser Wilhelm II in 1906. Bassermann plays Wilhelm Voight, a small time ex-con, who wants to return to his old home (in his German state). At the time the German Empire was made up of German petite kingdoms (Prussia, Bavaria, Wurtemburg, Hanover), and principalities (Hesse Cassel, Baden, etc.) and you required special permission to travel back to your native state. But ex-convicts could not get it (for obvious reasons concerning keeping track of them).

Voight was determined. Sitting across from the municipal offices of the local city, he noticed the citizens blind (really blind) devotion to the military - and blind obedience to military orders. He came up with a plan. He went to the small nearby town of Koepenick, dressed in a military uniform of a Captain (which he rented). Within 20 minutes he had the town dancing to his tune, as he tried to get the document he needed to get home. But though everyone was jumping to attention, running at his first rapid orders, none of them had the authority to give Voight the paper. They did give him a sizable amount of money that had to be taken to Berlin. He willingly took it - a mistake as it turned out. To all questions he said he and he alone would be responsible.

Eventually the theft of the money led to the arrest of Voight, but it was not a triumph of German police or justice. For the story showed the worst side of Wilhelmine Germany - the slavish devotion to the army by the people. It held up the nation and the army to ridicule. Within a few months the town's name was briefly a verb, "to koepenick" (meaning to replace authority figures and fool people), and was the subject of a short story by "Saki" (H.H.Munro) in THE CHRONICLES OF CLOVIS. Voight was tried and sentenced to a brief prison sentence, and then deported to his native state - the government had been embarrassed by the scandal. Although it did not end German militarism (it would take two world wars to do that), it lessened the awe most of Europe felt for Germany's army and bureaucracy.

This film follows the story closely, perhaps making Bassermann's character more comic than the real Voight was. But he gives a first rate performance, ably backed by a cast of good character actors. He never starred in another movie (as far as I know) made in Hollywood, so this one has to stand as his best work. One hopes it resurfaces soon.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This is another of those many films that has performers in them who can actually act! - another film that has long deserved to be restored and reissued on DVD.
donsmithers21 January 2002
Why is it that so many films of this quality and with casts of characters that can actually act lie around for so many years without being restored and brought out on DVD? When there is so much mediocrity in recent films and audiences having to suffer all the 'pretty' mannequin's in them that pretend to act, performers like Albert Bassermann and the films in which they acted must be restored if there is to be any hope for the film industry. Perhaps reviewers and distributors do not know that the film was originally released with the title, "Passport to Heaven", and is based on the story, "The Captain from Koepenick", which was originally "Der Hauptman von Koepenick". It is an ironically funny film and strikes to the heart of bureauocracy. It is needed now more than ever in this time we live in. Attention Turner Film Classics:let's see it one of these days, please!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Outstanding
luciferjohnson12 September 2004
I don't understand why this movie is listed as "I Was a Criminal." It was released in the U.S., and shown on television years ago, as Passport to Heaven.

A really outstanding, touching movie that featured a distinguished performance by Basserman. This movie appeared toward the end of the Second World War, and on one level was very crude anti-German propaganda. But its subtext, the yearning for freedom, is universal.

One real tragedy is that this movie simply vanished from the face of the earth. It is not available in any format, DVD or video. A real shame. My thanks to the other commenter for sharing his recollections of the film.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Moving and Funny
melz-17 February 2002
This film used to run on TV in the very early days and is based on a true event. There is a German color version and and earlier version by this same director. This is a small film about a simple man against the state. It is both funny and deeply touching and Basserman gives perhaps his greatest performance. I know it as "Passport to Heaven," but it was released under several titles. It is a shame that this film cannot be found in any format. I remember this:

"I had a dream and a voice said, 'Soon you will take your last gulping breath and stand before God the father. And God will ask you what have you made with your life, and you will have to answer..Doormats...In prison...for all the world to step upon...and God will say, That is not what I gave you life for...You owe me a life....where is it...what have you done with it...Get out..you have come to the wrong department'"

I still remember after all these years...What a shame that you can't see it for yourselves........
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fine film that is completely off the radar
16mmRay28 August 2014
Okay, first let me say that all my observations are based on my personal 16mm print, which is a composite of a Film Classics release made up for military use and a television print with complete original titles. To begin, the reel "slate" says Captain From Kopenick Part 1. This means that, up until the film was completed it was planned and produced as The Captain From Kopenick. When it was finished it was given the more generic title PASSPORT TO HEAVEN. Still, the subject matter was not palatable for distributors and the film languished until Film Classics picked it up and gave it yet another generic title I WAS A CRIMINAL. I have footage of the CRIMINAL main titles as well as the complete PASSPORT main titles.

While the original German talkie was sharper and far more indicting, the American film still carries enough wry satire to be thoroughly enjoyable. It also sports a very early score by Daniele Amfitheatrof. In fact, for an independent production the film has some excellent production credits including cinematographer John Alton and editor Dorothy Spencer. The cast is superb, in particular Luis Alberni, Wallis Clark and, of course, the wonderful Albert Bassermann.

The last owner of PASSPORT TO HEAVEN was National Telefilm Associates so, in theory, the picture should be in the Paramount library. Whether or not they actually have materials is another matter.

I ran the film at CineFest in Syracuse in 2013 and it was very well received. Here's hoping a wider audience gets to see the picture at some point in the future.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed