1/10
So bad it's laughable
22 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Disclaimer: Only saw the first half we couldn't stand to watch any more.

Truly truly rubbish.

Claims to be based upon reality. Not sure "who's" reality they're talking about, but my guess is that it's some weird alternative reality.

Spoiler alert ================= To comment on a few issues:
  • Deciding to try to fight a sub in a merchant ship (I guess it's possible, but not by choice)
  • In the movie, the depth charges were fired. In reality, they were rolled off the back
  • Part way through combat with a sub, the liberty ship slows to "dead slow". Is that to make themselves an easier target?


  • Seriously rubbish dialogue, hardly any of which sounded even vaguely accurate
  • A crewman looking out of the front of the ship, "u-boat at 2 o'clock". Really? Well that's on your right then
  • In brilliant calm weather, only spotted a u-boat at 800 yards. In return, the u-boat hadn't even spotted the bloody huge great bit merchant ship
  • The "88" on the sub morphes into an auto-cannon when firing
  • Why are the deck guns pointing at the sky at a range of 800 yards or less?


Etc.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed