Some movie buffs like to compare various films of the comedy mystery group that William Powell made. Most reviewers focus on the chemistry between Powell and his female co-star, and on how well the co-star handles her role. The prototype for comparison is the role Myrna Loy played as Nora to Powell's Nick Charles in the Thin Man movies. Of course, it's OK to do that. But, recalling the variety of movies Powell was in and looking at the list of his work in the 1930s, I think Powell and movie makers were experimenting. "The Thin Man" was made in 1934, and the next one of that series didn't come out until "After the Thin Man" in 1936
But in the meantime, Powell starred in some other comedies, a couple musicals and a couple of dramas. One of those was a comedy mystery with another star. In 1935, Powell made "Star of Midnight" with Ginger Rogers. So, was it possible that Powell, and/or some movie moguls were looking for the best match with Powell to continue the Thin Man series? I wonder – especially since "Star" and "The Ex-Mrs. Bradford" both were made by RKO.
After these two comedy mysteries at RKO, Powell returned to MGM and picked up with the Myrna Loy match for more Thin Man movies. I enjoy all of those films, and I think there was something special about that pairing. But, it doesn't take anything away from these others films or the co-stars performances with Powell.
So, here we have a film with Jean Arthur, who became known for her comedy roles; but, who also was very good in dramatic roles. Arthur had a trademark high-pitched and sometimes squeaky voice that takes some getting used to. But, it only takes one film to do that. Some think she plays a ditsy blonde, but I think she comes across as very sharp, but a little naive and silly at times. And, those are endearing traits for her character, Paula, in this film.
Nick's role as an M.D. – Dr. Bradford ("Brad") is part and parcel to the mystery and plot of this film. He and Arthur have very good supporting help from a number of other actors. At the top of the list is Eric Blore who plays Stokes. I don't think anyone has ever played a better butler role than Blore in comedies. While maintaining his proper respectful poise in his speech, Blore is fantastically funny in his facial expressions and mannerisms. This is a fine example of how supporting roles can really add to the quality and enjoyment of movies.
Other reviewers discuss the plot, so I'll share some favorite lines form the film. Paula, "Oh good, dinner." Brad, "This is hardly the occasion for a banquet, but, uh Stokes, lock up the silver." After dinner, Paula, "Brad, I've come to a terrific decision. I'm going to marry you again." Brad, "Paula, that's the thing I like about you. You're so subtle." Paula, "Well, I was only doing it for your sake, so you wouldn't have to pay me the alimony." Brad, "Oh, trying to bribe me, huh?"
Brad, "Say, what is this, a frame-up?" Paula, "Well, you know, great minds " Brad, "No. I don't know any great minds."
Dr. Bradford examines jockeys before a race. He tells them to come forward one at a time and give their name. The first one steps up, "Ray Torro." Brad checks his heart, "OK, next." The second jockey says, "Al Torro." Dr. Bradford says, "Brothers?" Al, "No, he's my old man." Dr. Bradford, "Where's your grandfather riding?" Al, "Havana." As Brad finishes and leaves, Paula meets him. Paula, "Did you inoculate him?" Brad," With a little difficulty." Paula, Oh, I thought you used a hypodermic."
This is a most entertaining film all through. Watch for the classic scenes where Paula tries to help Brad in a couple of scuffles. You might guess what happens. Very funny, indeed.
But in the meantime, Powell starred in some other comedies, a couple musicals and a couple of dramas. One of those was a comedy mystery with another star. In 1935, Powell made "Star of Midnight" with Ginger Rogers. So, was it possible that Powell, and/or some movie moguls were looking for the best match with Powell to continue the Thin Man series? I wonder – especially since "Star" and "The Ex-Mrs. Bradford" both were made by RKO.
After these two comedy mysteries at RKO, Powell returned to MGM and picked up with the Myrna Loy match for more Thin Man movies. I enjoy all of those films, and I think there was something special about that pairing. But, it doesn't take anything away from these others films or the co-stars performances with Powell.
So, here we have a film with Jean Arthur, who became known for her comedy roles; but, who also was very good in dramatic roles. Arthur had a trademark high-pitched and sometimes squeaky voice that takes some getting used to. But, it only takes one film to do that. Some think she plays a ditsy blonde, but I think she comes across as very sharp, but a little naive and silly at times. And, those are endearing traits for her character, Paula, in this film.
Nick's role as an M.D. – Dr. Bradford ("Brad") is part and parcel to the mystery and plot of this film. He and Arthur have very good supporting help from a number of other actors. At the top of the list is Eric Blore who plays Stokes. I don't think anyone has ever played a better butler role than Blore in comedies. While maintaining his proper respectful poise in his speech, Blore is fantastically funny in his facial expressions and mannerisms. This is a fine example of how supporting roles can really add to the quality and enjoyment of movies.
Other reviewers discuss the plot, so I'll share some favorite lines form the film. Paula, "Oh good, dinner." Brad, "This is hardly the occasion for a banquet, but, uh Stokes, lock up the silver." After dinner, Paula, "Brad, I've come to a terrific decision. I'm going to marry you again." Brad, "Paula, that's the thing I like about you. You're so subtle." Paula, "Well, I was only doing it for your sake, so you wouldn't have to pay me the alimony." Brad, "Oh, trying to bribe me, huh?"
Brad, "Say, what is this, a frame-up?" Paula, "Well, you know, great minds " Brad, "No. I don't know any great minds."
Dr. Bradford examines jockeys before a race. He tells them to come forward one at a time and give their name. The first one steps up, "Ray Torro." Brad checks his heart, "OK, next." The second jockey says, "Al Torro." Dr. Bradford says, "Brothers?" Al, "No, he's my old man." Dr. Bradford, "Where's your grandfather riding?" Al, "Havana." As Brad finishes and leaves, Paula meets him. Paula, "Did you inoculate him?" Brad," With a little difficulty." Paula, Oh, I thought you used a hypodermic."
This is a most entertaining film all through. Watch for the classic scenes where Paula tries to help Brad in a couple of scuffles. You might guess what happens. Very funny, indeed.