A bit better than the series standard but still very much a TVM (SUGGESTIVE SPOILERS)
17 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
When senior CSA boss Alana Delvin is shot in her office by one of her own team, the motives seem nonexistent. Things are made even more complex by the agent himself having no memory of shooting her or any idea why he would. Of course with such a mystery in play, special agent Cathy Davis (aka Jane Doe) is called in to consult. With links to an experimental series of CSA protocols working on the subconscious minds of the agents. Cathy tries to work out if this theory holds water but also who would have the access to use this programme to their own ends. While she investigates though another similar assassination occurs within the CSA and Frank Darnell himself starts to be plagued by nightmares about a war he was never in.

The Jane Doe series of films isn't great; lets just agree that right now. They are not pushing Spielberg out of the multiplex, they don't get sold via Cable Box Office and they generally seem happy to be filling the afternoon schedules of safe, family television channels. So it is perhaps important not to come to the films thinking that you are walking into the favourite for next years' Best Picture Oscar. However this does not mean that you have to just accept whatever slop is served up to you and even those accepting this as a TVM standard are "allowed" to take issue when it is poor. I do watch this stuff with this in mind but, for example, the Mystery Woman series of films has become lazy and bland to the point of pain and the same thing can happen with Jane Doe.

This film does at least try to prevent this slide into total mediocrity and here manages to at least have an interesting concept at its core, one that in some ways reminded me of aspects of both version of The Manchurian Candidate. Of course the quality is much lower across the board but it did just about enough to hold my interest and this is what prevents it from just being pointless and bland. Is it endlessly exciting, intelligent well of course it is not. The movement of characters from the back to the fore gives the game away, even if the various red herrings are used well enough to fill the time. As per usual the family side plots are pointless and just seem like they have been edited in from somewhere else like bad stock footage. Here we have Jack trying to win a job with an unpleasant property developer while his son wins thousands playing poker against other kids; of course it is nonsense and it is a shame that the film uses this stuff as the big finish. I suppose at least Jack knowing about his wife's job makes a bit of connection (she can talk about the plot to him – making the scenes serve some purpose at times) but still you have to wonder why they don't really put the work into making a strong mystery because I cannot imagine that anyone is tuning into these things to see what is happening to Cathy's snotty cute son.

The cast offer TVM safety but nothing special or noteworthy. Thompson works best in her undemanding moments but here she is handed two or more moments where she has to express stronger emotions and frankly she cannot do it. For example she has to lose it with the developer, being stern when preparing to confront the suspects or being disgusted when the guilty party is exposed – all of these are laughable. Penny is his usual solid self despite some silly action/dream scenes. Moses and his acting children drift around the edges like soft shapeless ghost of tirelessly jolly people.

Lets be clear - this is far from a brilliant film but as a TVM it works just about. You can see the areas where effort has been made to reduce the failings of previous films and to arrest the slide into mediocrity and utter blandness that this series and some similar films can easily get into. The mystery is OK and just about offers enough to move things forward even if the usual flaws are all evident to some degree.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed