Review of Girl

Girl (1998)
3/10
A poor excuse for a film adaptation....
26 March 2005
Do yourself a favor and read the book before you try to watch this movie. After watching it I felt like they tried to turn this incredible and moving work of fiction into an episode of My So-Called Life. The book this screenplay is loosely based on is so much more powerful than this bland film version. The main character was heinously miscast, she brings no depth to the role whatsoever. You end up being annoyed by her, instead of identifying with her in any meaningful way. And you never find out enough about the supporting cast to understand what's going on with them. In my opinion the entire point of the novel was completely missed. I was terribly disappointed.
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed