It's hard to believe one man with a reputation as a gun man can cause so much panic to a whole town of people who have no reason to fear him.
To be fair McGraw does show he is still fast and handy with the pistol when accosted by two would be robbers one his way into Dodge. He makes his entry into Dodge with two bodies slung over the saddles. What better way to strike terror into the hearts of the town folks? There is a great deal of mystery regarding McGraw and he does little to dispel the suspicions of the townspeople. His behavior only serves to fan the flames of fear and apprehension.
He takes to courting the love interest of a young man named Dave who may or may not be involved in criminal enterprise. Is McGraw truly interested in the girl or in Dave? And what could his motive truly be? The girl is very attractive so it is no stretch to think he may really be interested in her. That aspect is easy to believe. But where Dave is concerned the mystery deepens.
McGraw is straightforward, not the least bit sneaky or underhanded which only serves to make people even more suspicious of him. The whole town is guessing, "Who did he come here to kill?" "What is he up to?" There is a pretty convincing knock down drag em out fight and a great surprise ending.
Enjoy!