The Time Squad gets sent to the time of the great musician Ludwig van Beethoven, who is now a pro-wrestler. Instead of dumping tea into the Boston Harbor, the Sons of Liberty are having civilized tea parties.
After a mission to fix Russian Czar Ivan the Terrible, Tuddrussel sneaks Ivan back on the satellite and keeps him as a pet. Buffalo Bill is now a crazed conspiracy theorist with his own tabloid magazine that no one reads.
The Time Squad goes on a mission to stop Harry Houdini, who is using his illusions to commit crimes. The Time Squad has to try to get the West Virginia hillbilly families the Hatfields and the McCoys to start feuding.