The Indian Scarf

A rich man is bumped off and it is made to look like a heart attack. His possible heirs must spend 7 days in "peaceful coexistence" before his will is read.As usual the heirs are strangled one by one(with an Indian scarf).The finger of suspicion points to anybody and everyone. Is it the lawyer? Or wife; the son; the dope addict (Klaus Kinski intense as usual); the clergyman etc. Well this film drowns in red herrings and the ending is off the wall and irritating. I'm a big fan of this series and this disappoints. Only the acting and settings gives this a 4.

What legendary author wrote the best murder mysteries/whodunits; - Agatha Christie or Edgar Wallace? For me, personally, the answer is undoubtedly Agatha Christie! And not just by a small mile, but with lightyears ahead. Nonetheless, I'm also a big fan of Wallace, and I'm eternally grateful to him, because his work kickstarted the German Krimi-films, and eventually the Italian giallo-boom.

"The Indian Scarf" is very reminiscent to Christie's most famous story, namely "And Then There Were None" aka "Ten Little Indians". It's the same old and traditional plot of greedy family members gathering in a gothic castle for the reading of a will, but then naturally get killed off one by one by someone whirling around scarves. It's a prototypic, but amusing and reasonably fast-paced Krimi, with familiar faces in the cast (Klaus Kinski, Eddi Arent, ...) and clichéd twists in the script. Whenever one of the characters is suspected by the others of being the killer, the suspect is killed him/herself. You know; - that sort of twists. I don't think I've ever seen a castle/mansion with SO many secret passageways and hidden doors, though...

Oh, and Eddi Arent - as the dry sarcastic butler - has a fully automated breakfast trolley, which results in a handful of subtle but hilarious comic-relief sequences.

It was a super entertaining watch, I enjoyed especially the humor indicating home gadgets a lot, that served the story. The oversized beethoven statue that holds some murder weapons, the tea wagon following Eddie Arent without a leash, the mysterious secret doors leading to cupboards, the weird clay statue of a stupid handyman, the oversized horse... set design in these Edgar Wallace adaptions in Germany is a real GEM and often overlooked. For me, the humor and the set design are a major plus point for the film experience, together with an EXTREMELY exciting cast, such as Eddie Arent, Heinz Drache and Elisabeth Flickenschild. Really fun, fast paced and easy going entertainment!

When a wealthy man dies, his avaricious relatives look forward to inheriting all his money. However, he leaves a provision in his will that they all must spend a week together in his castle before they will be able to inherit anything. At the castle (which is cut off from the outside world), the relatives soon begin to be killed off one by one, each strangled with an Indian scarf.

Nicely shot Agatha Christie-esque stylistic German thriller that is a spin on the "ten people get bumped off a la And then there were none" storyline, however there's a freshness to the story mainly due to the self-aware humour, a wide cast of characters who are quite barmy and creepy, especially Kinski's character who is seen as a suspect, POV scarf strangling, a painting with peephole nipples, and the dense-like Gothic atmosphere. It's quite Fun, but then I am a sucker for the "ten people in an isolated castle getting bumped off by an unseen killer" story, and the identity of the killer came as a surprise. The Butler is quite hilarious with his one liners.

The term "Krimi" refers to a genre of movies made between 1959-1967 in what was then West Germany. All of the early Krimis were shot in black and white and resembled the American "film noirs" of the 1940s and early 1950s. They are basically crime dramas although most also contained mystery elements, and were based on the works of English writer Edgar Wallace (1875-1932). Most of the stories are set in England but were shot in Germany using German actors and feature German and English soundtracks, although the latter are all dubbed and, as is usually the case, not very well.

There were 32 Edgar Wallace movies made, and all by one company, Rialto Films. Another company, CCC Films, produced a series of movies based on works of the writer's son, Bryan Edgar Wallace. The principal director for the Rialto series was Alfred Vohrer who directed 14 of the 32 films which were produced. DAS INDISCHE TUCH (The Indian Scarf), the 14th film in the series, is one of the better ones as it contains all the classic mystery elements with comic relief provided by series regular Eddi Arent who usually appeared as an aloof butler or a self-effacing sidekick.

The frequently recycled plot features several greedy relatives who have gathered for the reading of a will hoping to inherit a rich man's money. However the will stipulates that in order to inherit any legacy they all must spend a week together in his castle. This allows one of them the opportunity to bump off the others as the week progresses...but which one of them is doing it? Almost all of the characters are unsympathetic and exceedingly avaricious so they get, in celebrated old dark house fashion, what's coming to them. Nothing new there. The twist (pun intended) comes from the film's title as all the victims are strangled with a silk Indian scarf.

The cast of German actors includes the dependable Heinz Drache who was usually a stalwart leading man for many European productions during the 1960s. Here he plays the lawyer who not only reads the will but he also winds up solving the mystery. Then there is the one and only Klaus Kinski who brings his celebrated brand of intensity to the role of a temperamental sculptor who may also be a drug addict. Veteran actress Elisabeth Flickenschildt is given the showy role of the widowed matriarch who harbors a dark secret while Hans Clarin is her artistic son who has dreams of being a concert pianist.

The murders are committed from the killer's point-of-view and we are treated to a scene of a scarf being rolled tight in front of the camera before something happens. The film is well made and manages to be spooky and tongue-in-cheek at the same time. The end sums up the movie perfectly. Although SCARF isn't a great film, it holds a special memory for me as I first saw it with my mother, who was a great fan of mysteries, on board a German liner during my one and only jaunt to Europe back in 1964. I was 12 year old at the time and this was the first subtitled movie I'd ever seen. This disc is one of the fully restored EDGAR WALLACE series which was released back in 2004...For more reviews visit The Capsule Critic.