First of all, an introduction is required. I am (at 78) the eldest grandchild (12) of Ruth Chrisman Gannett, the illustrator of My Father's Dragon, Elmer and the Dragon and The Dragons of Blueland. The author Ruth Stiles Gannett, the author of all three books, is my aunt and my father's only sibling. We were full of anticipation for this adaptation. Our (step-) grandmother's book My Father's Dragon is a whimsy tale of such charm that it became admired the world over, especially in Japan. No wonder, it is about a boy Elmer Elevator, his friend Boris the Dragon and assorted memorable characters on an island. Its charm lies in the feel-good moments of all characters and the illustrations which bring them to life. Segue almost three-quarters of a century from their introduction to today's childhood world. Might there be a big change in what entertained children back then to today? Maybe but probably not. The film's director Nora Twomey took extreme liberty with her interpretation for this question. Sadly, she supposed lightening, volcanic-like activity and mayhem would enthrall audiences. What a mistake she made! Expectations quickly plummet as the original story line dissolves and Nora's emerges. This is why readers and listeners of the past 75 years are abysmally disappointed. The story is Nora's, not Big Ruth's and Aunt Ruth's. Today's audiences would have adored Elmer and Boris as they were in books. Those who rate highly this film have very obviously not read the books. Those who treasured the books will continue to do so and mourn the missed opportunity for faithful character adaptations in a recognizable plotline. - Michael Ross Gannett, Jr.
Review of My Father's Dragon
