Tokyo Ghoul: 'S' (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Decent follow-up. Nothing more.
lost-in-limbo10 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Virtually continuing the story that began in Tokyo Ghoul. This time the white doves, and even human characters get little screen time, with the focus squarely on the ghouls. This follow up looks a little more polished and even stylish in the way it was shot (despite some abrupt editing between transitioning scenes), possibly a larger budget, but then again the film holds back on the CGI (although looking particularly better this time around) and action set-pieces which makes you second guess. There are a couple striking scenes, like the opening introduction of the creepy ghoul villain, the ghoul restaurant horrifyingly in full force and film's final ghoulish standoff. Outside of those moments, everything else felt slow and less memorable. Although I did like the constant interactions between Masataka Kubota and Maika Yamamoto's lead characters. Sure there are high stakes, but its more talky and burdened by emotional weight. In some ways it feels more personal and invested in its character's turmoils than the first film, but less exciting and frenetic in its action-thrills. It still provides a WTF, or brutal moment here and there, but the rush is over in seconds.

Kubota's half-ghoul, half-human character Kaneki feels like he took a back-step and in doing so came across much weaker. It definitely shows in the training scene between Kubota and Kirishima early on. He's still battling his affliction, and scared of transforming. There are moments when you think he would break out. Being pushed to the edge, but his character keeps it in check for the majority of the film. Which for me at times became frustrating. He transforms only once, for around 10 or so seconds and that's at the very end. While his trademark mask isn't even seen. It's Nobuyuki Suzuki who steals the show from everyone as Shuu Tsukiyama. A murderous ghoul with epicurean desires and suave fashion sense. He takes real fancy to Kaneki's scent. Tsukiyama truly camps it up, some moments made me chuckle with his over-the-top mannerisms and I don't know if I was meant to either. After while I found his character's actions began to get tiresome in spots, but his gleeful wickedness eventually turns monstrous when he comes to blows in one very long-winded stash with Kubots and Kirishima. His mask design though is of nightmares, and rarely does he take it off when in ghoul form. The other performance to standout was Maika Yamamoto as Kirishima. She really does hold her own, and even takes on more of a role. I found her to be even more cold, cynical and aloof than the actress who protrayed the character in the first film, but her presence was strong enough I thought the scenes without her weren't as engaging. There was pain and sorrow underneath her hard shell, and you see it, via only small cracks and the growth in her character is very evident by the end. In a way I feel like her character is developed and gets a lot more to do especially in ghoul form, even with less screen time than Kaneki. He feels secondary whenever both are on screen. Honestly Kubota is overshadowed by Yamamoto and especially Tsukiyama in every scene they share.

There are some plot points, and minor incidents from the first film that get expanded in this sequel. The first half is its own beast in setting up the players in the ghoul underworld, but come the second half it seemed to follow the same story route as the first film. This occurs when the ghoul who was the classmate that tried to kill Kaneki in the first film comes into the picture along with his human girlfriend. Then it sort plays out in a typical fashion through to the end. Also there's a surprise reveal midway through the end credits.

Tokyo Ghoul S was a good follow-up, although I think I expected a little more from it, yet the performances mainly shine and I could see myself probably liking it more on a repeat viewing.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
worse than the first one
gianmarcoronconi17 March 2024
This is not a real review, it should be understood more as a collection of impressions on the film.

I have to say that I really liked the first film but this one disappointed me ridiculously, everything that was good in the previous film is completely thrown away or ignored here, making this film particularly stupid. In reality it's not all to waste because the violent and fight scenes are really done quite well but apart from that there's nothing good. Let's start with the protagonist who, unlike the first, is completely useless in this film except in the final moments and this is a real shame because in this film he is just a helpless victim of events and so let's say that the management was not at all satisfactory .
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Lackluster
landofthepurplering3 July 2020
The first Tokyo Ghoul was a very solid action/ horror flick. This one is utterly devoid of tension and interesting characterization and full of bits that make no sense, such as an enormous restraint of powers. Were there enormous budget problems? It seems to be actively avoiding any action, let alone the sharp action of the first. Throughout, everything screams "cheap."

Then there was the lack of emotional anything, strong characterization, a compelling plot . . . any music . . . really, this would've made one or two fine 20-minute episodes, but it definitely didn't have any movie material. And it was dull. Just a useless dull nothing of a half-baked film. I'll probably have forgotten it by tomorrow.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great interpretation
arimakishouisnotdead28 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
If you're familiar with the source material, you probably know Shuu can be a very bizarre and exaggerated character with borderline ridiculous lines and scenes, so much that, if you're not careful, your portrayal of him can be weird and cringey. Well, Shota Matsuda stole the show. His portrayal of Shuu was, honestly, fantastic. There is a particular seriousness and dignity in the way he carries himself that makes his trademark scenes really creepy and realistic. The napkin scene was out of this world. No words can describe it. In fact, something that shows up multiple times in his performance is the heavy breathing, which I think he really mastered. The other time in which it is shown is at an added scene of him playing the piano during a stormy night with flowers on the background. He breathes heavily and calls Kaneki's name repeatedly - the beauty of being engulfed in that gray-ish shot is almost like Ishida's gray illustrations with music attached to them. Speaking of it, the soundtrack is great, as per usual. There are multiple scenes where a piano plays and I think it encapsulates the energy of the work. There are many changes from the manga. One of them being Shuu's house and suits, which, while still elegant, are mostly monochrome, hindering his outward eccentricity. When Shuu exits the cafe, we're met with his monochrome suit and his charming demeanor, and then Kaneki comes with his blue flannel and his typical timid aura, setting them apart in multiple ways and, considering that Kaneki is a college student working at a cafe, he's much more relatable, which, in a sense, highlights that peculiarity of Shuu's, I suppose. Another thing they changed about Shuu was his crescent moon mask - in the movie it covers almost the entirety of his head and, imo, kind of looks like a moon, especially since the right (of the wearer) half of it seems darker, so the left side resembles the original mask, even more so when Touka attacks him and breaks a part of it right on his eye (since the grinning mouth rests above the eye in the source material). Masataka Kubota does a perfect job as Kaneki. He's mellow and caring and, when he talks to Kimi on the bench, his reactions and subtle expressions made me stop for a second; I felt like I was really Seeing Kaneki. Kubota's performance is immersive and genuine. Couldn't have been cast better. Nishiki and Kimi's storyline was heartwarming as always. Very emotional scenes, both of their deliveries have a lot of weight and are very natural. Yoriko and Touka's is the same. Yoriko is even cuter than usual and seeing her food fall was depressing. The ending scene of the two of them together at school was adorable. While they didn't have much screen time, the other characters' appearances were very much appreciated! Hide is a very fun character that always manages to make me smile so I love that they added a couple scenes of him being silly. Uta's mask in the post-credits is gorgeous and I will never get enough of it. Helter Skelter had a really nice atmosphere with the green lighting and Itori was kept the little troll she is, especially with the excited confession of purposefully getting Kaneki into serious trouble in the post-credits. Since volume 4 is one of my all time favorites, I can never be satisfied the ghoul restaurant. Originally, everything about it is supposed to be theatrical - from the bathing, fancy clothing, expressive masks, a higher floor for the audience and a lower one for the show to the panicking, running prey being chased and brutally murdered by the scrappers. TG S' ghoul restaurant, however, is one single floor, the lighting is one you'd find at a nightclub, there is no chase, the masks are bland and the food is tied down to a table and the scrappers merely dismember them. Still, it is a decent adaptation and the scene does build up tension. When the CCG barges in, we see them kill a lot of the guests, a shot of Kaneki in a dress shirt covered head to toe in blood with his eyes wide open, a shocked expression on his face (which I found absolutely beautiful) and Shuu with a raised hand debating his next step now that he knows just how delicious Kaneki could really be. The final battle is great. Kaneki and Touka teaming up was very beautifully choreographed. Most of the time, the kagune look really good. Shuu breaking Kaneki's arm and leg was gorgeous. Details like Shuu's mannerism of flicking his bangs, the close up on the scars on Yoshimura's hands during his speech, the Anteiku fridge filled with human meat, Shuu's disgusted expression at Nishiki and his anxiously organizing the cutlery on the table on the background after they fell added incredible depth to the characters and the world around them. Furuta's several short appearances were very entertaining! He does take the Souta mask off in the post-credits scene and talks about his "precious... precious dragon". I don't particularly believe this delivery was amazing, since his spilling of the whole drink Itori poured him prior to that felt corny to me. I am also unsure if implying Furuta is the main antagonist right around that time is a good move. While it does set up his grand plan decently, I think having seen his face and knowing he's with the CCG takes away a lot of the shock value of his story (which normally feels like 20 punches to the gut). If they do make more movies (which I would love to watch), I'll be looking forward to how they handle Furuta's characterization. He's a really complex character and I believe they could do a great job with him like they did with Shuu. Overall, I think it's a good movie. There are changes that may make it weaker in comparison to the manga, but, if you consider the movies alone, they are actually really good. Some things are difficult to adapt into other media and I think they made the right calls. Shuu stole the show and things do make sense in-universe. I don't think it's fair to remove stars because of my own expectations of what the ghoul restaurant should look like (that's my main issue with the film). The special effects were mostly good, the only thing that really irked me being the shallowness of the bites. Some camera angles and the speeding up of the characters (and... floating??) were weird. I also wish there had been more gore. Since there wasn't all the throwing up from the first movie (which I liked a lot), I wish they could have put a little more detail into the wounds, make them deeper and uglier, make things a little more brutal. But, yeah, it's actually a really good movie; some people just want to see the manga word-for-word and I don't think that's fair. So I'm just taking out one star because the gore could've been better c:
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Shuu and Touka
hoangyen_kimsa29 July 2019
New touka and i very like shuu in anime, in live action shuu still funny and crazy
4 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed