Through ground breaking computer restoration technology, filmmaker Peter Jackson's team creates a moving real-to-life depiction of the WWI, as never seen before in restored, vivid colorizing & retiming of the film frames, in order to honor those who fought and more accurately depict this historical moment in world history.Written by
Curtis Medina
Voices of the soldiers in the restored footage were added by professionally reading their lips, and then (for the sake of accuracy) hiring voice actors from the same area of Great Britain that the soldiers had hailed from. One bit of footage that had been used often in prior documentaries, of an officer reading a statement to his troops, would not yield to this method (likely because of the officer's mustache), but Peter Jackson was able to find the text of a candidate statement in the archives of the regiment involved. He recorded it at various speeds himself, and it proved to match the footage. See more »
Goofs
While British tanks after 2016 were painted brown/tan, the film is explicit that it does not name a battle, or a year that the various segments came from. Since the specific shots are not listed as being from a specific date or battle, they could be of either green, or tan. In addition, the Mark V tank at the Imperial War Museum, is green. See more »
I needed some time for this to sink in before commenting on it. This was equal parts funny, exciting, moving, harrowing, horrifying, upsetting.
Firstly, it's not a glossy documentary. There are some harrowing scenes in this that will, and should, upset you.
The first 25 minutes are of original black and white, speeded up footage with the original voices of troops telling their story over the top of it.
Then something amazing happens. The screen widens, the footage smoothes out, the colours shines through and in an instant your and seeing everything in so much more detail.
That said this was the first time I've seen footage from The Great War that didn't feel disconnected. It feels real. Seeing the colour on their cheeks and eyes, the dirt, the mud, the blood brings the old footage to life. Occasionally the colourisation takes on a slightly animated feel but never enough to draw you out of the engrossing scenes laid out before you.
Then the frame rate adjustment is amazing. Having computers generate the missing frames to adjust the variable 15-18fps to the regular 24fps is a visual butter knife that smoothes out the jerky footage.
Having the soldiers talk sounds like a mistake but it's done in such a subtle and sensitive way it never feels false. They've been lip synced perfectly and apparently even with the right accent for the infantry units depicted.
This was powerful viewing. Computers and technology being used for something so important, to allow 100+ year old footage to look so modern and yet not feel sanitised is amazing.
This should become compulsory viewing for every one, all schools too.
With footage thats this accessible there's no reason history should be forgotten.
102 of 107 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you?
| Report this
I needed some time for this to sink in before commenting on it. This was equal parts funny, exciting, moving, harrowing, horrifying, upsetting.
Firstly, it's not a glossy documentary. There are some harrowing scenes in this that will, and should, upset you.
The first 25 minutes are of original black and white, speeded up footage with the original voices of troops telling their story over the top of it.
Then something amazing happens. The screen widens, the footage smoothes out, the colours shines through and in an instant your and seeing everything in so much more detail.
That said this was the first time I've seen footage from The Great War that didn't feel disconnected. It feels real. Seeing the colour on their cheeks and eyes, the dirt, the mud, the blood brings the old footage to life. Occasionally the colourisation takes on a slightly animated feel but never enough to draw you out of the engrossing scenes laid out before you.
Then the frame rate adjustment is amazing. Having computers generate the missing frames to adjust the variable 15-18fps to the regular 24fps is a visual butter knife that smoothes out the jerky footage.
Having the soldiers talk sounds like a mistake but it's done in such a subtle and sensitive way it never feels false. They've been lip synced perfectly and apparently even with the right accent for the infantry units depicted.
This was powerful viewing. Computers and technology being used for something so important, to allow 100+ year old footage to look so modern and yet not feel sanitised is amazing.
This should become compulsory viewing for every one, all schools too.
With footage thats this accessible there's no reason history should be forgotten.