The Bra (2018) Poster

(2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A cinematic experiment
ready-player-one14 February 2019
Nurlan drives his train every day through rural Azerbaijan and a suburb of the megacity of Baku. There is so little space in this slum that the residents hang up their clotheslines over the railroad tracks.

During one of these rides, a nice blue bra gets caught on the train from Nurlan. Who in the district is the owner of the laundry? Nurlan sets out on an unusual mission to find the woman and maybe love.

The film by German director Veit Helmer tells the warmhearted story in quiet pictures and without dialogue. A bold cinematic experiment, only visually we follow the Protagonist on his extraordinary quest - experiment succeeded - highly recommended.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
2 words 6 letters = Quirky realness.
zalfunk31 March 2020
Quirky. Real. Real quirky. Don't listen to negative reviews. Try it. Glorious depiction of a boring life turned around, for just a minute. Some cruelty, strange passages and events. Modern day Cinderella with some quirky realness. Don't be afraid. Try it.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Cinderella with Eastern European boobs
Horst_In_Translation12 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"The Bra" is a co-production between Germany and Azerbaijan and the latter is where the film plays. Actually, the location is not too surprising taking into account that writer and director Veit Helmer, who turned 50 the years this was made, has worked on many movies long and short with an Eastern European background during his prolific career. And most of the actors you will see during these 1.5 hours here are some that Helmer has cast in other films as well in the past. I am of course talking mostly about Lavant and Khamatova, not sure about lead actor Manojlovic. But if he has not, then he should cast him again because the latter really carried the film nicely and no words were needed. Another approach where it is not the first time that Helmer takes it. But it makes for something different in a pretty interesting way. And to be really precise it needs to be said that we do hear humans here. We hear them crying, laughing, making sounds, screaming, even saying a name here and there when a character is called by another. But that's it. Other than that, the film relies completely on sound effects and the sound track of course too and both fields were handled with precision and attention to detail. If there was one thing I did not like too much about this approach, then it would be the noises some of the women make at times, which seemed a bit too quirky for my taste here and there. But these are not bad either and overall this idea adds great charm too the film. Now as for the story, we have an old train driver who is fairly lonely and has a tendency to get into contact with people by getting their stuff that gets stuck on his locomotive and bringing it back to them. This especially happens after the young boy runs along the rails telling everybody to make space and I kinda like this recurring theme. Now everything changes for the old man when one day he finds a bra on his train. After his sidekick (Lavant) plays a bit around with that, we find out quickly how serious a matter it is for our protagonist. So he goes from one apartment and house to the next in hope of finding the one it belongs to. I kept wondering he knew where it hung outside or did he forget, so why didn't he remember, probably didn't see it. Anyway, the problem with him going to all these women is not only that there are way too many, but also that the husbands are usually not amused if they see him. The result is a wild chase on more than one occasion and the sound one of the husbands makes was kinda funny in a comical way.

But there are also more serious moments. One would be when we have the man at the lake when he is retired and wants to catch some fish, but is bullied by the other men there and their sons, one annoying son in particular and this scene shows us that our "hero" really does not fit in with them without kids on his own. Sadly, he is not the strongest one physically either, so his marriage proposal to a woman who likes him gets rejected by her mother. So he goes on the search afterwards for the one the bra belongs to. And honestly I was surprised how friendly most women reacted and did not think he was a creep too, perhaps because some of them found the man also interesting and hoped to get in a relationship with him. But if the bra won't fit, then no luck for the girls, some of them attractive, others not so much, but one young lady really stunning in fact that he would never have met if he did not follow the old lady after he opened that bra selling shop as a disguise to find the right one. Really surprising he did not react to the girl's interest and the small breast size cannot just have been the only reason. I think by that point he was already somewhat in love with the one he was looking for, almost like an obsession. Oh yeah, another serious scene is when near the end, the husbands catch up to him and tie him to the rails, but the young boy I mentioned earlier has become a friend at that point and maybe he will go fishing with him someday. For now, he helped him save his life and untie his chains, so that the train would not roll over him and kill him. This newly-found friendship also had the protagonist care less about the woman he's been looking for. I still think it was a bit unrealistic that int he end he did not care at all who may live behind this door, even if she was not home at that point anyway probably, but still a bit more feel-good ending as realistic that eventually had me go for the lower rating. I considered 4 out of 5 stars for a while because it was a really funny movie at times also with how politically incorrect it was. I am sure some snowflakes and hardcore liberal feminists will not be able to enjoy the film or like the main character with him climbing up in the woman's bedroom (well it was the boy's idea admittedly) or how he tricks all the woman with his cancer research studio at the end into showing him their breasts. Or simply for the fact that also as a hetero male, you had no reason to be embarrassed for staring at each and every single female character's breasts to see if it could fit. And despite knowing it wouldn't, maybe stare for a little longer still. So overall, thanks to Heimer and Manojlovic, this was quite a fun watch and I recommend checking the film out. The good thing is also you won't need any subtitles no matter where you are from and which languages you speak for reasons I mentioned earlier. And by the way, there are also some truly mesmerizing video recordings and cinematography moments included in these 90 minutes, like the shots of the mountains, but others too. Maybe my favorite film from the director at this point. I recommend checking it out.
13 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
many gifts
Kirpianuscus24 October 2020
The first gift of the film is Miki Manojlovic. The fans of Kusturica know why. The second - in my case- Maia Morgenstern. The secod gift - the atmosphere, and the simplicity of story and flavours of so many books, films, near reality fragment. Not the last - the special poetry proposed by the absence of dialogue and the cinematography. And, sure, the boy, the great small boy. So, many gifts of this not ordinary but profound touching of Cinderella story.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Full of promise, then takes a big nosedive (spoiler toward the end)
logan0312 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I knew very little of the director before seeing this film as part of the Berlin & Beyond Film Festival in the Bay Area, California. I had seen the trailer for the film and was intrigued by what I saw, especially the idea that it was all done without any dialogue. The Bra certainly contained some beautiful outdoor photography, along with the assorted quirky characters that I look for in films. The director was present at the showing of the film and we were looking forward to hearing him, asking questions, etc. He also found a very interesting assortment of actresses from different countries to play key roles (from Spain, Romania, etc.) while the story was set in and around Baku, Azerbaijan. So, these were all major pluses the film had going for it. The premise was that a retiring train operator snags a bra that is drying in the sun - he then sets out on a very determined journey to find the owner, just as the prince set out to find the owner of the glass slipper in Cinderella. Some very hilarious moments, along with the obvious nudity to be expected when women give it a try with the bra. Here is the spoiler - although the whole idea of finding the owner of the bra is pretty quirky and funny at first, it slides into some sadder moments and then downright creepy as the frustrations grow. The main character is an older man, some of the women seem to get younger, but the worst of it is that he actually climbs into a sleeping woman's bedroom to try to put a bra on her. What was the director thinking? This is a major assault of the worst kind. There was also a scene where he poisoned a doctor and nurse so he could fill in and take chest x-rays of women. As someone else pointed out in their review, some of these women were poor and putting their trust into the doctor to do the right thing, whereas the train operator exploits the whole idea in a horrible way. Since we knew the film was coming near the end, we sat it out to see the "happy" ending, but got up immediately before the credits rolled. Had no interest in debating the director on why he ruined an otherwise creative and interesting film.

I think some of the overly positive rating are are too high since there is no mention of these two major downfalls in the film.I gave it a six star rating because of the positives, but can't go any higher because of these two glaring plots in the story. So I say, viewer be prepared if you choose to see this.
5 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Charming little silent movie!
TheDome8114 May 2022
Charming little film. It says it's in English which is a bit deceiving. There's actually no dialogue whatsoever in the whole movie. What an accomplishment. It's a sweet tale about a train engineer in the remote area of India (I'm guessing). It shows his daily, boring life, until one day, a woman's bra gets tangled up on the front of the engine. He's then on a quest to return the bra to its rightful owner. Sounds boring, but I thought it was very engaging, in a very subtle sort of way. Just a delightful, well-acted story.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Today it feels perfect! :-)
verlinel22 March 2019
A poetic, funny and touching modern-times re-imagining of the Cinderella story and Chaplin's The Kid with a good cast, lovable characters, beautiful cinematography and a very fitting soundtrack. Oh, and with almost no words. :-)

I really enjoyed the fact there is a bit of everything in this movie - comedy, drama, action, suspense, erotica; love, hope, exasperation, misunderstanding, sadness, cruelty, humanity...

Unlike other people, I don't think the artistic exaggeration in a couple of the scenes was over the top - this is one of the main characteristics of comedy and in this specific instance it actually helped show in an amusing way the character's dedication to complete the mission. From what I heard around me after the end credits, the rest of the audience seemed to agree with me. Also, everyone laughed a good deal which counts as a great success in my books.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Well made and entertaining but some of it was just plain bizarre
etann-367073 July 2022
I felt some of the scenes were very cartoonish and others just were so slow and didn't have the same playful feeling to them, so I guess in a sense it just wasn't strange enough in some scenes and in others it was just too drawn out and real, I became frustrated for the character and felt no matter what the ending it just wasn't going to be satisfying and in a way it ended that way for me. Artistically it was fantastic and felt rewarding. Characters were endearing and culturally it was interesting to watch for me. I would genuinely like to see similar films constructed in this fashion with just a bit more attention to pace and rhythm. They really could have cut out about half of his failed interactions and it would have been far more satisfying to watch. The pace and repetitiveness would probably turn off a good deal of viewers but anyone who really enjoys the art of film should be able to see this as a worthwhile addition to their watch-list.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
What a fantastic piece of silent comedic art
skitofit7 October 2020
I wasn't sure what to expect but I'm glad I saw it on a whim. It didn't take long for the silent story to captivate me, and having travelled myself to similar cultured places was surprised to see the authenticity. The story is an obvious take on Cinderella where the protagonist is trying to find one specific person who owns this bra. But with a unique culture twist. I enjoyed it very much
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A quirky movie that's not for everyone
Hammer-Rocks12 October 2020
This is probably the quirkiest movie I've seen in over a decade or two. For one the movie has no dialogue from start to finish. And two, the movie revolves around a bra. Accept that simple story line and you will find this movie interesting. I think it's what got me to watch it all the way, to see how the story evolves.

But even without any dialogue, the actors where able to convey their intentions well and the movie articulate the story through acting and great direction. I mean, you fully understood what was happening. No need for complex explanation - it's all simple. And the whole thing surprisingly works extremely well.

A good way to summarise the type of story this is, is... it's a different take on the Cinderella story. Just using a bra instead of a glass sleeper.

Give it a go, you might get some amusement from it - just like I surprisingly did.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Funniest
nairtejas11 December 2022
The Bra is the funniest film I saw at IFFK 2022 at the time of writing. More so because a lot can go wrong in a film like this that often inadvertently tries to enter misogyny territory but never does. You can't predict what's going to happen and that's the charm of the lead character in this silent film that's periodically funny and ultimately poignant. I 100% enjoyed the film like I had never before and it's for that experience I give it a full 10. I'm gonna think about it days and kaybe weeks ahead and would highly recommend my women friends to give it a try so that I can know if the idea of liking the film is mutual.

(Watched at the 2022 International Film Festival of Kerala in Trivandrum.)
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Culturally Interesting, Overall Melancholy, A Bit Creepy
germanbini22 March 2023
"Wish" Walter Matthau type searches for the owner of a bra in this practically pantomimed Cinderella-esque movie set in Eurasia.

The cinematography is beautiful in this story of a lonely train engineer. While it is interesting to see the scenery and cultural differences in Azerbaijan, ultimately the movie devolves into desperation and unseemly circumstances. It's a tragic comedy with a bit of humanity.

I know nothing of the director or actors in this movie; I came across it in my streaming service and decided to watch it. I was very surprised there was practically no dialogue for ninety minutes.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
cinematique par excellence
ops-5253512 October 2020
If you love good old 36 mm cinematography, if you love pantomime, if you love silent movie, and wish to be placed back 40 years in todays '' modern life'', then take a look at this one. its just phenomenal.

i havent seen thelike since i saw'' adventures of picasso'', swedish made 1978, to find the same kind of inner joy to view a silent film.

this is a masterpiece in its genre, extremely well made and acted. a recommend from the grumpy old man
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Little Gem
dcarroll742 July 2020
What a clever, delightful, funny, witty film this is. It came out of left field, and stayed centred. I thoroughly enjoyed the viewing experience.

I'm no expert but, I believe there are three 1st with this movie. The first silent movie of the 21st century, the first silent movie in COLOUR, and the first silent movie with no story boards.

I am smiling as I write this little review, that says something. I'll never think of Bra in the same way again, not even in schoolboy French, which raised schoolboy tittilation (french translation for the uninitiated is ARM).

When I hear or see a Bra in the future, I will be transported once more, to a cinematic gem. The cast were fantastic, the direction was brilliant, the cinematography was unbelievable. This movie left me with a warm glow, which I haven't felt in some years

Blockbusters are good for the wallet, movies like this are good for the viewer.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful movie about a different kind of life.
nygerzzz11 October 2020
Great acting, beautiful shots, awesome music and most of all, an interesting story said without speaking a word. Definitely for the more intelligent viewers.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Trashy Eastern Euro Fairy Tale Farce
jackwriter-826332 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The matching lingerie was the key to finding the bra's owner. But really -- an old dude going door to door to find the owner of a lacy bra that his train snagged off a clothesline -- c'mon. And hot young chicks trying on the bra in front of the old dude? That gonna get gramps kilt in Detroit, much less trashy rural East Euro. I watched it and it was silent-film funny, and yes he got the whoopin he deserved. Nice ending, too.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Absolute Delight
davidremy27 March 2023
Now, this is a truly worthy film. Creative and spellbinding in it's ability to carry you along the search, without needing to explain using words. Well done, True Film Makers! The themed is focused perfectly without any sidebar distractions and useless banal "action". The main characters were honed nicely so you felt you knew them without any verbal explanation. The different episodes were creatively produced without a sense of repetition. Finally, an awesome ending authentic to the heart of the film. You find yourself immersed in the story as a sidekick to the main character. Worth every minute. I think this film is worthy to be in a film education class.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed