Love, Lies and Records (TV Series 2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
ROMANCE IN THE STRANGEST PLACE Warning: Spoilers
Who would ever have thought that one of the most interesting and original series could take place in a registrar's office? And yet that's exactly what you'll find in this series. The sad news is finding out that no season two if forthcoming. Compound that with cliffhangers here and perhaps a campaign to see it start again is in order.

The story revolves around Kate (Ashley Jensen), one of the main registrars in the Leeds Register Office. Kate has an incredibly busy life to lead not only due to work but her home life as well. Her son complains and wants, her daughter is having issues with self-esteem and her stepson is going through a breakup so has moved in with her and her companion Rob (Adrian Bower), a police detective. Yes even though her job is to marry folks she's not married herself as the show opens. She and Rob juggle responsibilities with the kids as best as they can.

Off to work she goes only to find as much turmoil there as at home. James (Mark Stanley) is a co-worker who is about to change from male to female. Rick (Kenny Doughty) is a co-worker Kate had drunken sex with at the Christmas office party. And Judy (Rebecca Front) is the office wet blanket, an enforcer of rules and creator of same. Various other office mates are found but these are the ones with storylines this time around.

For James his story is the entire transgender situation. He's comes out to the rest of the group and advises them that he'll be dressing as a woman forthwith. He tells Kate he's going to tell his wife and the end result of that doesn't go well. She kicks him out not wanting their two teen boys to see him like this. With no place to go he ends up adding to the crowd at Kate's home sleeping on the couch. His struggle takes various turns through this first season.

The other two have differing issues all due to the recent retirement of the head of the registry office. Everyone immediately assumes that temporary head Judy, the perennial butt kissing rule obeying and oft hated co-worker, will get the job. All are pleasantly surprised when supervisor Matthew (Matthew Marsh) lets them know that Kate has agreed to take the position full time. Everyone except Judy.

It seems that Judy has found the footage on the office CCTV of Kate and Rick having their fling in the storage room. She uses it to blackmail Kate, promising that if she decides to stay on the job she'll make Matthew aware of the footage as well as Rob. With so much going on in the office she gives her time to make her move.

Rick continues to pine for Kate. He's fallen in love with her and admits it's always been that way. What was a onetime thing for Kate is something Rick wants to make more permanent, willing to abandon his girlfriend to spend his life with her. Kate is flattered but rebuffs his advances.

But she's not quite sure about her own emotions. Is she still attracted to Rick? And what about Rob? Is there a reason that they two of them never married? To complicate that the two discuss getting married now only to discover that Rob never divorced his first wife officially.

As all of this drama behind the scenes is taking place there is plenty more out at the desks. One involves a young man who wants to marry his dying girlfriend. She put off treatment for her illness because she was pregnant. With the child here and dying they want to marry now. That changes into a story involving registering her death later.

Another involves a group of marriage scam artists and human trafficking. Girls forced into the country illegally gain citizenship status and then are forced to marry so the men can stay once their visas expire. With a little bit of intuition and a lot of research Kate pulls Rob into their investigation. This will either result in utter failure or capturing a group of criminals. When one of the girls ends up dead the stakes are raised.

Not enough stories yet? Well there is also the use of a plotline involving same sex marriage just made legal about the time of the series starting. Several same sex marriages with various issues involved are brought into play but mainly as a way of showing the prejudice Judy has towards this now legal procedure. Her maneuvering to not have to marry same sex couples comes into play with the back and forth issue of who will run this office.

The series is incredibly interesting no matter what your views are on different topics at hand. And while you may not support a character who has a one night stand you feel for her with the predicaments that follow. Her decisions aren't always the best ones to be made. She's human and makes mistakes just like the rest of us. Add in the touch of police drama in trying to catch the human traffickers and it gets more interesting.

Perhaps the biggest weakness of the show is the full blown open mindedness of Kate. She accepts nearly everything that people decide to do, not only accepting but encouraging everything. With James she counsels him to carry on with who he wants to be ignoring the issues it might cause for his family. With same sex marriages you get the feeling she's happier for those couples than the others whose weddings she officiates. Her own personal views on marriage seem at odds to her own situation most of the time. But it is these weaknesses that make the character more human than most offered on series these days. They provide a depth to her.

But the show has a bigger weakness. That's the fact that there is no second season. By the time I finished watching this I wanted to know what happened after that last episode. And yet apparently not enough interest was garnered for it to go. How that can be after only 6 episodes is confounding. So for now we're presented with those episodes on disc to enjoy more than once. And my guess is that given the chance you will find the show as interesting and enjoyable as I did.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
well written and acted BUT
xpharm14 June 2018
Charming, humorous and sad in spots but obviously pushed hard towards a leftist agenda. A lost opportunity
11 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I hope for another season - Don't watch if you don't have an open mind
barbie69820036 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I watched this program from the USA, and really enjoy it. I found the reviews to be interesting, particularly the ones who fund fault with the depiction of Christians and said that the only bad people in the program were Christians. This person obviously did not watch all of the episodes, as the the primary antihero and everyone they associate with is Muslim. The one loudly self-proclaimed "Christian" in the program is taken advantage of by the "evil" Muslims and only has regrets that her stringent religious views left her exposed to extortion.

As to the reviewer here who says the BBC is shoving left wing ideology down her throat, she should learn how to use her remote control and turn the program off if it offends her. Making programming that presents transgendered or gay people as humans who have been discriminated against is representing a real part of society. No one is cramming anything down her throat, she's cramming her ignorance and hatefulness down ours.
16 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Please have a second season
brendavanasco19 March 2018
Wasn't sure at first but once it got started I really loved this show. Ashley Jenson plays this part so well.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Anything can happen and probably has.
elboycio12 September 2018
Nothing surprises me in this life anymore and I thought this was a light hearted but possible look at what could happen in any office not just registration. It was great and let's have a second series.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Really enjoyable
trevorrg23 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
There's a bit of everything.

a male co-worker who decides he wants to go through gender reassignment so has to start dressing as a woman - that's a process you have to go through if you want gender reassignment surgery (that isn't something Kay Mellor just invented) The fact that James' wife didn't want him living at home with her and the kids if he was going to be dressing as a woman is very likely to be the case in real life for many trans-gender.

Same-sex marriages are now legal so it makes total sense that they'd be included in the storyline.

Another storyline is scam marriages and a link to the deaths of some women.

A work colleague who has found some CCTV footage of the Kate and Rick having sex in the store cupboard after a Christmas party uses that footage to try and persuade Kate to withdraw her application for a promotion.

I enjoyed it.
12 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Very disappointing ... but I'm not sure why.
markfranh15 May 2018
I had high hopes for this series. Great Cast. Ashley Jensen, Kenny Doughty, Rebecca Front. Brilliant writer with good track record in Kay Mellor. What could go wrong?

And yet it does all go terribly wrong and having said that I'm having problems putting into words just why it is that it does go so wrong.

I think what it comes down to (maybe!) is that it tries way too hard to be PC. Worse than that. It almost comes across like it is trying to preach to viewers as to HOW to be political correct.

Frightened of one day being confronted by a man at work who shows up dressed in woman's clothing and not sure how to react? Don't worry, this programme will give you some clues as to what to do and say.

Been invited to the wedding of an older man who is ex-army and who used to be married to a wonderful woman with whom he had two children but you've been shocked to discover he is now marrying a man? Again, this will ease you through the shock of not knowing how to react.

In this fantasy world, the cross dressing man is universally greeted with compliments by his fellow workers and clients. The gay man's former wife even attends his wedding to his new husband and has a huge smile on her face, obviously thrilled that he has at last found true love.

In real life though? Much as I'd like to say we live in a society where this is all possibly, the fact is we don't. A cross-dresser would certainly be greeted with some derision by at least some co-workers and certainly clients would be uncomfortable with the situation. A wife even attending her ex-husband's wedding to a man? Really? Most ex-wives wouldn't even attend his wedding to a new wife, let alone to a man all the time smiling at his new happiness. It just didn't ring true.

Worse, as I said, it felt like we were being preached to. This is what to do! This is how to behave! This is how to think!

In addition, one sub-plot has two of the Registers' workers fearing for their jobs after they were caught on CCTV by a 3rd blackmailing co-worker having sex after getting drunk at the office Christmas party. Leeds city apparently has a policy against co-workers entering into sexual relationships (true or not, I don't know) while at the same time is happy to have a cross-dressing male on staff and understandably (as per law and rightfully so) providing registers to conduct gay weddings? We aren't talking manager-employee sex by the way. Or Harvey Weinstein, Bill Cosby abuse of power and position type of sex. Just two co-workers at the same level, both consulting adults, having sex outside office hours after getting drunk at the Christmas Party . For that, City policy is instant dismissal. (Admitedly, the sex was on the premises but even so!). In this day and age, if the workers were fired, the union would call a full strike and the two fired workers would jointly higher lawyers to sue the Council for damages and solicitors would be queuing up to take on the task pro bono.

Again, it just didn't work for me.

My wife and I managed two episodes but after gritting our teeth through the last 20 minutes of the second episode we turned to each other and said, "No more".

By all means, make up your own minds and give it a try. Some will be happy watching this fantasy, others will be like us and other reviewers and just find it unsatisfactory.

By the way, what's with the "Lies" in the title? Does it refer to the lying about the real world being like this I wondered.
11 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Hateful portrayal of Christians
lindabruno-7341823 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The show is pretty good. The thing that bothers me most is the revelation that the psycho evil blackmailer is a Christian. It would be lovely to see Christians portrayed in British shows as loving followers of Jesus Christ, instead of crazy people. I'm a Christian and found myself loving the James/Jamie character.
9 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
So nice to watch
info-216-4886271 November 2019
I hope they would make the second season. Where can we find out about it?
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Silly and childishly written script
qui_j29 May 2018
Really thought this would have been top rate but, Man, was I disappointed. The script seems to revolve around so many coincidences that it becomes totally unbelievable. The dialogue is trite, and the script so badly written, that it could have come out of a high school drama club. The final episode is so cheesy and desperate to find a happy ending. Loose ends are all neatly tied up and the viewer is glad to see the back end of all the characters.
9 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
It never registered
Prismark1021 December 2017
I would never have thought that working in the Births, deaths and marriages department in Leeds would be all that glamorous or exciting. Kay Mellor's television series was rather proof of this.

Kate (Ashley Jensen) finds herself balancing a hectic family life with sulky teenage kids, a partner who is a cop and a secret. An affair with a work colleague that was caught on cctv. She also has heavy responsibilities at work where she is admired apart from one token villainess who is trying to blackmail her by wanting to expose her drunken infidelity.

Kate copes with the newly bereaved, fake wedding immigration scams, gay marriages, babies surviving the odds and Freddie Flintoff making his acting debut and somehow staying sober.

It was a load of unbelievable tosh.
14 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
So disappointed
Tokyomom20 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I love so many of the actors in this show...Rebecca Front, Adrian Bower, Ashley Jensen...but I was so disappointed. The main character performs marriages but doesn't deem it important for her to marry the father of her 15 year old daughter. Of course she never married the father of her 17 year old son but marriage in Europe really seems an afterthought now so that is not too surprising. Except that she marries people for a living. And of course this being 2017 we have to have a brave transgender character. Never mind that he is a married man with two sons. We are to feel sorry for him, not his wife and sons and of course the writers make sure to remind us where our sympathies lie. Obviously his family isn't "woke". But Kate (Ashley Jensen) is. She is also unfaithful to her partner but hey, they aren't married so that's okay. The villain in all this is Judy (Rebecca Front). Because she doesn't think a man should come to work dressed as a woman and she has the dirt on Kate's infidelity. I mean she is so intolerant, right? Makes sense she isn't running the department. She isn't "woke" either. Of course there is an immigration fraud subplot which might be interesting if they actually rescue the girls who are obviously being trafficked for nefarious purposes but we need to focus on the messy lives of the main characters. I guess I just couldn't really figure out what the purpose of this show was. Is it a soap opera about messy office lives? Or are the people in the Registrar's office doing important work? Of course, as is typical of BBC shows the home life is messy and the kids are always acting up but the writers never stop to think that maybe the kids are so miserable because the parents are always so busy with their own lives. The daughter is sick and Kate wants her partner (who is a police office investigation a murder) to pick her up because she is busy with important records work. Granted it is a very touching scene with a dying woman realizing she wants to marry the father of her child, but the marriage has been performed and it is just tying up loose ends that her co-worker/illicit lover can finish up. If you can't put your sick child before your job then don't be surprised that your kids do things to try and get some attention. I enjoyed the series "Blue Murder" but whenever the series dealt with Janine's kids' home life and their anger and feelings of neglect I wanted to scream at her "your kids need you to spend time with them and listen to them and put them first, not your job" but at least she was solving a murder. I feel like Kate's job isn't so important that she can't arrange her schedule to actually spend some time with her kids instead of reacting when they act up because they need some attention and acting shocked that they don't feel they can confide in her. But hey, maybe I'm just not "woke".
16 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Cringe-makingly awful
mikey-7213221 December 2017
Two stars rather than one, only because of the lovely Ashley Jensen, who deserves far better than this politically correct garbage. And dear Rebecca Front - what on earth are you doing taking part in this right-on turn-off? Shudderingly dreadful.
16 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed