Carolee informs Emma that DA Harrigan didn't believe Reynolds' story. She laments that everything is her fault since she convinced Steve to let Reynolds lay out the case for Harrigan. Maggie recounts for Matt her phone call to Wyoming and sending Greta to bed. Matt tries to make her see that Greta told him Maggie's secret out of concern for her. Billy accidentally overhears a hopeless Carolee comment that Dan is going to haunt their lives forever. Maggie admits to Matt that she had a nightmare in which Frank taunted her about making up the story of her kidnapping last winter. When Matt continually refers to Frank as a crazy cowboy, Maggie bristles at the word crazy and says that's how Frank described her. Dan haunts Billy's dreams, warning him that he'll be punished like never before if he ever tells anyone about Dan's personal journal. Carolee races into Billy's room when he awakens and screams for Dan to let him go.
—Skip Eastport