One knows from the outset from the subject matter alone, well before reading the plot synopsis, that "Great Expectations" would be a difficult episode to watch. The subject matter is such a disturbing one and anything that deals with the dangers of something so dangerous should be raised awareness of as much as possible. Especially when it is still so relevant. This episode did hit me quite hard on first watch.
And it still did hit me quite hard on rewatch. "Great Expectations" is not perfect or great, but it has many great elements, hardly sugar coats the subject matter (while not being heavy handed) and is to me one of the better episodes of the first half of Season 18. A half that on the whole was rather disappointing, though while the season was not a great representation of 'Law and Order: Special Victims Unit' generally it did improve later. "Great Expectations" as far as the season goes is closer to being one of the better episodes than one of the worst.
"Great Expectations" has a lot that works. It is as ever shot with the right amount of intimacy without feeling too up close, even with a reliance of close up camerawork. That the editing has become increasingly tighter over-time is great too. The music isn't over-scored, manipulative or used too much. There is intimacy and tautness in the direction.
The script is lean and thought provoking, dealing with a difficult issue in a pull no punches yet tactful way. The story also pulls no punches and evokes a lot of emotions, especially in the meatier second half. The acting is very good, with Peter Scanivino being the standout of the episode and the acting honour going to a chilling Brett Sexton as a truly vile individual. Really appreciated the insight into Carisi.
However, "Great Expectations" had room for improvement too. There are no real surprises, the only surprise was the tragedy concerning the victim which did feel unnecessary. Did feel that it could have done a lot more with the why try the perpetrator as an adult, that would have made for an interesting discussion but the episode didn't do it. That everybody else involved in the attack got off too leniently did push my suspend disbelief buttons.
Was really put off by Rollins' self-righteousness for no reason. It was generally not like her as well when she has been for a while one of the more sympathetic characters.
Overall, good episode if not great. 7/10.
