6 user 10 critic

Thought Crimes: The Case of the Cannibal Cop (2015)

TV-MA | | Documentary, Crime | 20 April 2015 (USA)
A probing look into the potential future of "thought policing" through the headline-making case of the NYPD "Cannibal Cop," who was charged with conspiring to kidnap and eat women.


Erin Lee Carr
1 nomination. See more awards »


Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Credited cast:
Gary Allen Gary Allen ... Self
Violet Blue ... Self
James A. Cohen James A. Cohen ... Self (as James Cohen)
Joseph DeMarco Joseph DeMarco ... Self
Alan Dershowitz ... Self (as Alan M. Dershowitz)
Daniel Engber Daniel Engber ... Self
David Greenfield David Greenfield ... Self
Dareh Gregorian Dareh Gregorian ... Self
Robert Kolker ... Self
Chris Kraft Chris Kraft ... Self
Erin Murphy Erin Murphy ... Self
Laurie Penny Laurie Penny ... Self
Christina Rodriguez Christina Rodriguez ... Kathleen Mangan-Valle (voice)
Jane Rosenberg Jane Rosenberg ... Self
Lee Rowland Lee Rowland ... Self


Dubbed "The Cannibal Cop," Gilberto Valle was convicted in March 2013 of conspiring to kidnap and eat young women. Valle argued it was all a fantasy; the prosecution's narrative convinced jurors otherwise. Valle was facing a possible life sentence when filmmaker Erin Lee Carr began visiting him in prison. After 22 months behind bars, his conviction was overturned in a stunning reversal. The film was there for his release and subsequent house arrest to examine a life arrested. But the question remains: given the chance, would he, could he, have done it? "Thought Crimes" unravels the conflicting stories of a potentially dangerous young man and the unexpected consequences of our online activity. Written by Erin Lee Carr

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Documentary | Crime


TV-MA | See all certifications »

Did You Know?


One of the chat room users is known as Moody Blues. This screen name is a reference to The Moody Blues, an English progressive rock band originally from Birmingham. See more »


Features It: Part 2 (1990) See more »

User Reviews

When does one cross the line between (free) thought and (punishable) action?
14 July 2019 | by paul-allaerSee all my reviews

"Thought Crimes: The Case of the Cannibal Cop" (2015 release; 88 min.) is a documentary about NY cop Gilberto Valle. As the movie opens, we see Valle participating in a chatroom, having "ugly thoughts" about what he'd to to certain women. We then go back in time as we get to know Valle, a New York cop with a lovely wife and young daughter. When his wife discovers (through spyware) what Valle has been doing while on the computer, she contacts the police, and Valle is arrested for conspiring to kidnap. Did Valle cross the lien between free thought and punishable action? At this point we are 10 min. into the documentary, you'll just have to see for yourself how it all plays out.

Couple of comments: this was the first feature-length documentary from producer-director Erin Lee Carr. I recently watch her more recent work (2017's Mommy Dead and Dearest, and this year's outstanding At the Heart of Gold: Inside the USA Gymnastics Scandal and equally riveting I Love You, Now Die), which establish Carr as one of the country's best documentarians, period. For her debut feature-length, Carr looks at the infamous "Cannibal Cop" case, which presents a tough legal issue: where does one cross the blurry line between free thoughts (you can literally think the most ugly and repulsive thoughts as long as you don't act on it) and punishable actions. It appears that many reviewers here (and of course the jury) are not able to look beyond the ugly and disgusting thoughts of this despicable man. The theme of "thought police" have been explored before, including in "1984" and Steven Spielberg's "Minority Report", but it's once thing to see it in a fictional setting, it is quite another to be confronted with an actual real life scenario. Please note that since this documentary was released in May, 2015,, the US Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit ruled on the appeal in December of that year (not going to spoil it, but you can easily look up the court's ruling).

Bottom line: this is not an easy documentary to watch because of the underlying disturbing nature. But it would establish Carr as an up-and-coming true crime documentarian, and her reputation has only grown with subsequent documentaries she has made. Meanwhile, I'd readily suggest you check out "Thought Crimes", be it on VOD or on DVD/Blu-ray, and draw your own conclusion.

1 of 3 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 6 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.


Official Sites:






Release Date:

20 April 2015 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

Crímenes del pensamiento: el caso del policía caníbal See more »

Company Credits

Production Co:

HBO Documentary Films See more »
Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:

Dolby Digital



Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Holiday Movies on Prime Video for the Whole Family

Prime Video has you covered this holiday season with movies for the family. Here are some of our picks to get you in the spirit.

Get some picks

Recently Viewed