Nick and Drew take a trip to a local brewery to figure out their bar's beer selection. They each make a unique signature beer and have a keg party at their friend's house to decide which will earn permanent placement at Lachey's.
When Nick and Drew can't agree on which menu items to serve at their bar, they take the vote to the people--holding a taste test at a Cincinnati Bengals football tailgate. Also, Vanessa surprises Nick in Ohio.
After a challenge from their friends to bartend on opening night at their bar, Nick and Drew take bar tending classes in order to learn the necessary skills. Additionally, the guys are selected as Grand Marshals of Cincinnati's Oktoberfest celebration and enter various competitions at the event.
With Nick stuck in New York, Drew takes some friends on a rollicking trip to Kentucky's Bourbon Trail, where he purchases an expensive barrel of bourbon. When he surprises Nick with it, the brothers don't exactly see eye to eye.
It's all come down to this--the bar is finally ready to open. Or is it? Nick and Drew work through the night to get it ready to open, get the key to the city from the Mayor, and at long last, officially open the doors to Lachey's.
Nick and Drew have a private event space at the bar that they want to make use of, but when both brothers book parties in the same space on the same night, they have to figure out how to keep both sets of customers happy.